[Lim Byeong-seon, Reporter]
[Smart PC Love = Lim Byeong-seon, Reporter]
Traditionally, the controller for fighting games was always a joystick, commonly referred to as an arcade stick. The joystick operates by moving a long lever to control the character and pressing a button to execute an attack. Although the operation method is intuitive, it does not provide the most reasonable functionality.
For those who have enjoyed arcade games, using a joystick for fighting games seems more convenient. However, players without experience using joysticks have no particular reason to choose this method. Alternatives like leverless controllers, such as hitboxes and gamepads, have emerged. Even young professional gamers are achieving remarkable success with gamepads. Let’s explore the advantages of using gamepads for fighting games.
Why should you use a gamepad for fighting games? As previously stated, joysticks have been the fundamental controllers for fighting games. Gamers accustomed to joysticks often find them more comfortable, and once they adapt to a specific controller, changing it can be challenging. However, those unfamiliar with joysticks need not restrict themselves to using them. Gamepads, being the most accessible controllers for fighting games, offer several benefits.
First, the gamepad allows for free operating postures. Joysticks typically weigh between 1 to 3 kilograms and are large, requiring placement on a desk or lap, which results in a fixed posture. In contrast, leverless controllers without levers also need a stable surface, and smaller products may not even fit comfortably on your lap.
In comparison, gamepads can be held anywhere, provided you have enough space in your hand. They can be used while sitting, standing, or even lying down, offering more versatile gameplay options. While few players might opt for playing while lying down, the possibility to enjoy gaming in varied positions is a significant advantage.
Quiet Operation
The primary benefit of gamepads is their quiet operation. Joysticks generate noise when maneuvering the lever, and the internal structure can create sounds when buttons are pressed. Although quieter components are available, the overall noise levels from joysticks are still higher when compared to other fighting game controllers. Leverless controllers, being slimmer, produce less resonance but still cannot entirely eliminate button noises.
Gamepads, on the other hand, are notably quiet. Some gamepads feature completely silent buttons. The analog and digital sticks also produce less noise compared to joystick levers. Operations can be performed with minimal hand movements, resulting in quieter gameplay. While noise may be acceptable in empty spaces, it becomes crucial when other individuals are nearby, making noise reduction essential.
Choosing the Right Gamepad for Fighting Games
With various gamepad options available, let’s discuss what makes a gamepad suitable for fighting games. Firstly, it’s essential for a gamepad to provide stable input and minimal input lag.
Most gamepads utilize wireless connections, which can significantly reduce the polling rate. This decline is even more pronounced with Bluetooth connections, so it’s best to choose a gamepad that connects via a USB dongle when possible. If a USB dongle is not an option, a wired connection is highly recommended. Fortunately, recently released gamepads commonly support USB dongle connections, alleviating concerns about lag.
Another feature to consider is support for six front buttons. Many fighting games operate with a 4- or 5-button system, but the Street Fighter series, one of the most popular franchises, uses a 6-button layout. If Street Fighter is your primary game, opting for a gamepad with six front buttons would be beneficial.
Cross Key vs. Analog Stick
One challenge in using a gamepad for fighting games is controlling character movement. Typically, gamepads come equipped with a cross key, left and right analog sticks, and various buttons. There are no strict rules on which to use, as it largely depends on personal preference, but it’s wise to try both options and select the one that feels most comfortable.
The cross key allows for quick inputs, making it convenient for actions like dashing or backstepping. It’s also easier to execute diagonal movements, particularly helpful for lower guards. However, it can tire the thumb on extended play sessions due to the low positioning and difficulty in performing turning commands.
Conversely, the analog stick’s height simplifies command inputs, reducing fatigue during longer gameplay. Yet, the speed at which it returns to neutral can be slower, making dashes and backsteps less convenient, and it can be tricky to confirm diagonal positions while guarding down. Nonetheless, both controls can be adapted to some extent with practice.
Recommended Gamepads
Here’s a list of gamepads recommended for fighting games.
SIE DualSense Edge
If you are looking for a standard gamepad for fighting games, the DualSense is a top choice. Many fighting game tournaments utilize the PlayStation platform, making the DualSense a go-to controller. Previously, the standard was the DualShock, but with the PlayStation 5 launch, the DualSense became the native controller. Some players noted that the DualSense could be inconvenient for fighting games, but that debate ended once several professional gamers achieved success using it.
The DualSense Edge is an advanced version of the DualSense, featuring adjustable sensitivity and movement range of the analog sticks and trigger buttons, as well as programmable back buttons. If you frequently play fighting games, the analog stick may wear out, but it can be easily replaced by simply swapping the analog stick module. It also comes with caps for analog sticks of varying heights, allowing for customization for different gameplay styles.
The most significant advantage of the DualSense Edge is its optimization for wired connections. While the standard DualSense can connect via USB and function wired, it does have the drawback of the cable becoming disconnected easily. In contrast, the DualSense Edge features a dedicated USB braided module that firmly secures the connection, making it reliable for wired use.
Hori Fighting Commander Octa
This gamepad, released by HORI, a Japanese gaming accessory company, is designed specifically for fighting games. Its standout feature is the six-button layout, allowing players to enjoy any fighting game seamlessly. Additionally, the directional input on the analog stick is guided by an octagonal (OCTA) design, facilitating 8-direction movement. However, this stick is not optimal for general 3D action games that require 360° operation.
The cross key is also shaped in a circular format to support 8-way input rather than the usual 4-way, ensuring compatibility when using either the cross key or the analog stick in fighting games. The latest model incorporates a right analog stick, functioning more like a slide pad rather than a typical analog stick, offering more convenience.
The buttons are digital, ensuring quick response and high sensitivity. Please note this is a wired-only gamepad, which may not suit those preferring wireless gameplay. The design and functionality vary slightly across PS/Xbox/PC platforms, so select the version that aligns with your preferred platform. However, it’s not officially released in some regions, so it might need overseas purchasing.
Thrustmaster eSwapX Pro Controller
This gamepad from Thrustmaster, renowned for its racing controllers, features a traditional gamepad shape but allows for customizable placement of cross keys and analog sticks. Each part is modular and can be easily switched out due to magnetic attachments.
The right analog stick can be replaced with a cross key. If configured as such, it retains the function of a cross key while mimicking the operation of an analog stick. Thus, players can arrange a left side with a cross key and analog stick, and a right side with a cross key for enhanced gameplay flexibility.
While it isn’t specifically a fighting game controller, including the fighting module, which converts it to a 6-button fighting game pad, allows for optimal fighting game performance. When playing standard games or 4-button fighting games, it can function normally with the analog stick or cross key, and additionally supports the fighting module for 6-button games, corresponding to the RB and RT buttons.
Joytron Flydigi Vader 4 Pro
This product stays true to the core functionality of a gamepad. Its design may appear simpler than earlier mentioned gamepads, but it remains highly functional. It features six front buttons that enable easy access to 6-button fighting games. Unlike typical 6-button layouts, this one supports the necessary operations solely through its front buttons. It also includes four mappable back buttons.
The action buttons are mechanical switch types with significant pressure requirements, helping prevent unintentional inputs.
The analog stick employs a Hall effect sensor, providing it with a long lifespan with minimal drift issues. It’s made from durable POM material, ensuring it withstands wear and tear. Additionally, it boasts a 12-bit precision level that is 16 times that of standard analog sticks, allowing for refined control.
A standout feature is the adjustable damping force dial stick, which lets users modify the analog stick’s sensitivity by turning a dial. Counterclockwise turns yield a softer feel, while clockwise turns increase stiffness, providing an advantage in fighting games requiring precise inputs. Users can set the sensitivity anywhere from 40gf to 100gf.
The gamepad truly shines in its wireless mode. Even with a USB dongle, it features a 1000Hz polling rate and 1ms ultra-low latency, enabling smooth and uninterrupted operation when gaming wirelessly.
Why Gamepads Are Taking Over Fighting Games: A Deep Dive into Controllers
[임병선 기자] In the realm of fighting games, the controller has historically been the joystick, also known as an arcade stick. This traditional method of control allowed for intuitive character movements via a long lever and button presses to perform attacks. However, as gaming evolves, new alternatives have emerged. Particularly for those new to the fighting game genre, gamepads present a compelling alternative to joysticks. This article explores the advantages of gamepads for fighting games and offers recommendations for optimal choices.
The Evolution of Controllers in Fighting Games
Historically, joystick controllers were synonymous with fighting games. However, newer gamers who haven’t grown up with joysticks are more inclined to utilize gamepads. These controllers are far more accessible, and their designs promote flexibility in how they can be used. Let’s take a closer look.
Advantages of Using Gamepads Over Joysticks
1. Freedom of Operating Posture
One key advantage of gamepads is their ability to be used in various positions. Unlike joysticks, which typically weigh between 1 to 3 kg and require a firm surface for operation, gamepads are lightweight and portable. This allows players the freedom to sit, stand, or even recline while gaming, offering a far more versatile gaming experience.
2. Reduced Noise Levels
The noise generated by traditional joysticks can be quite loud, especially when turning the lever or pressing buttons. Even attempts to employ low-noise versions do not completely eliminate the sound. In contrast, gamepads operate quietly, with some models boasting completely silent buttons. Players can enjoy their games without disturbing those around them, making gamepads a preferable choice for shared living spaces.
3. Enhanced Features and Settings
Modern gamepads come equipped with numerous features that cater to competitive play in fighting games. These include:
- Stability and Low Input Lag: Look for gamepads with a consistent input lag for optimal performance.
- USB Dongle Connectivity: Wireless models often have reduced polling rates—choose gamepads that connect via USB dongle whenever possible.
- Button Configurations: Many fighting games utilize a 6-button layout, particularly in the popular Street Fighter series. A gamepad designed with a sufficient button layout can significantly enhance gameplay.
Choosing the Right Gamepad for Fighting Games
Cross Keys vs. Analog Sticks
One crucial factor in gameplay is how to maneuver your character effectively using the controller’s layout. Gamepads typically feature cross keys on the left and either analog sticks or additional buttons. While both options are viable, personal preference heavily influences the decision.
- Cross Keys: These provide quick directional input and are particularly effective for maneuvers like dashing or backstepping. However, they can be uncomfortable during prolonged play.
- Analog Sticks: More suited for casual play, analog sticks allow for easier command execution but can be slower to return to the neutral position after input.
Recommended Gamepads for Fighting Games
If you’re considering investing in a gamepad for fighting games, here are some top recommendations:
| Gamepad | Key Features | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| SIE DualSense Edge | High customization, wired connection options, replaceable stick modules | General fighting game tournaments |
| Hori Fighting Commander Octa | 6-button layout, octagonal guide for 8-way input, fast digital response | Exclusive fighting game play |
| Thrustmaster eSwapX Pro Controller | Modular design with customizable module placement | Versatility in various gaming genres |
| Joytron Flydigi Vader 4 Pro | Mechanical switches, 12-bit analog, adjustable stick sensitivity | Precision control in wireless play |
1. SIE DualSense Edge
The DualSense has become the benchmark for fighting game controllers, especially with the rise of PlayStation tournaments. The DualSense Edge enhances this experience with features like customizable sensitivity, replaceable stick modules, and a secure wired connection option. Its widespread acceptance among professional gamers validates its effectiveness in competitive play.
2. Hori Fighting Commander Octa
This gamepad is tailored specifically for fighting games, featuring a six-button design and an octagonal analog stick. Notably responsive, it is perfect for players who prefer digital inputs, supporting an unparalleled level of control.
3. Thrustmaster eSwapX Pro Controller
With the ability to rearrange its analog sticks and cross keys, this unique gamepad caters to diverse gaming needs. When equipped with its fighting module, it permits seamless transitions between fighting games and standard 4-button formats.
4. Joytron Flydigi Vader 4 Pro
This gamepad is underscored by its simplistic yet functional design featuring six buttons and four back buttons. Notably, the adjustable damping force for the analog stick is particularly advantageous for fighting games that require precise command inputs.
Conclusion
The landscape of fighting games continues to evolve, with emphasis on gamer comfort and innovative design. Gamepads now rival traditional joysticks, offering quieter operation, ergonomic use, and customizable features that can significantly enhance gameplay. By embracing the right gamepad—be it the DualSense Edge for its robust features or the Hori Fighting Commander for its specialized design—players can enjoy a richer fighting game experience.
