Two hours lengthy interview turned the feeling of the week, and in it the Russian chief gave an entire bunch of weird interpretations of the historic fact.
V. Putin introduced the historical past of Russia to the journalist in an very simple kind, harking back to tales for elementary college college students, with out counting on the conclusions of contemporary science: archaeological or ethnographic analysis, genetic knowledge.
Though earlier than holding the interview, the journalist defined that he needed to disclose the opposite facet of the conflict in Ukraine, as a result of the West is concerned regarding listening solely to Kyiv, in keeping with consultants, this dialog had nothing to do with objectivity.
Historical past lesson for T.Carlson
The Riurikai dynasty the founder, Duke Rurik, a lot of trendy scientists time a semi-mythical historic determine shrouded in legend.
Telling in regards to the alleged arrival of the ruler, which is taken into account the start of the existence of the trendy Russian state, V. Putin presents an primarily epic story as an argument within the trendy political and even authorized sphere.
Educating T.Carlson, like himself mentioned, “historical past lesson”, V. Putin doesn’t keep away from deviations.
For instance, he talks in regards to the residents of the Grand Duchy of Lithuania (LDK): “It was even referred to as the “Nation of Russia and Lithuania” as a result of Russians made up a major a part of this state. They spoke the outdated Russian language and have been Orthodox.”
Some Russian historians have been making an attempt to repeat this lie for a very long time. They declare that Lithuania is solely Slavic lands that weren’t occupied, however merely returned to the place they belong – within the arms of the Russian Empire.
In response to them, Vilnius has been a Russian metropolis since historic occasions, so whether or not it’s the historical past of the LDK or Russia is similar factor. In different phrases, the true essence of Lithuanians is that they have been Russian-speaking and Orthodox, and solely the Poles ruined all the things, turning Lithuanians into Catholics and orienting them to the West.
These are lies and propaganda tales.
For LDK creation time there isn’t a consensus. Most historians think regarding its starting to be the institution of the monarch’s energy It elevated occasions (second quarter of the thirteenth century), when a part of the white tribes have been united into the state of Lithuania lands (in historic sources, Mindaugas is already titled Grand Duke). In response to others, LDK was fashioned when from the thirteenth century the outdated Russian lands have been joined to the state of Lithuania.
It needs to be famous that the time period “Outdated Russian” utilized by V. Putin is obscure and unscientific.
The declare that Russians dwelling within the LDK spoke “outdated Russian” is a really severe simplification and maybe even a politically motivated manipulation.
Distorted the info
V. Putin, speaking to an American journalist, informed much more lies.
He additionally tries to rewrite the historic fact by saying that “Poland inspired Hitler to start out World Warfare II.”
“In 1939, when Poland was cooperating with Hitler, he supplied – we’ve all of the paperwork in our archives – to conclude a peace, friendship and alliance treaty with Poland, however demanded that Poland return to Germany the so-called Danzig Hall, which related the principle a part of Germany with the Kingdom and the East Prussia.
After the First World Warfare, this a part of the territory handed to Poland, and as a substitute of Danzig, town of Gdańsk appeared. Hitler requested at hand it over peacefully – the Poles refused. Nevertheless, they cooperated with Hitler and took part within the division of Czechoslovakia collectively,” Putin mentioned.
Actually, from 1919 to 1939 Danzig had a free metropolisthe standing of which doesn’t formally belong to both Poland or Germany.
The Polish authorities had sure rights to this territory, however it had its personal legal guidelines and its personal administration.
Accusing Poland of collaborating with the Nazis, V. Putin “forgets” regarding 1939 in Moscow. August 23 signed by Nazi Germany and the USSR pact – non-aggression pact and secret protocols for the division of Central and Japanese Europe.
The pact was signed by the overseas ministers of the USSR and Germany – Joachim von Ribbentrop and Vyacheslav Molotov.
Secret agreements between the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany for a lot of many years led to many disasters that befell the individuals of Lithuania – occupations, mass killings, deportations, expropriation of property, repressions, restrictions on rights and freedoms.
VIDEO: The Baltic Approach: How the Longest Human Chain Turned an Vital Occasion within the March to Independence
Lenin and Ukraine
Considered one of V. Putin’s favourite tales, which is consistently heard in his public speeches, was not left unmentioned – the story that Ukraine was created by the Bolsheviks and Vladimir Lenin personally:
“When the Soviet Union was fashioned, it was already in 1922, the Bolsheviks began to create the USSR and created Soviet Ukraine, which didn’t exist till then,” V. Putin claimed in the course of the interview.
Actually, proto-state buildings within the Ukrainian lands started to be created shortly following the autumn of the monarchy in Russia in 1917. in February
in 1917 March 17 the Central Council of Ukraine was based on June 23 of the identical 12 months. it declared the autonomy of Ukraine and eventually in 1918 January 22 – full independence.
1918.04.22 was accepted Structure of the Individuals’s Republic of Ukraine.
It was abolished on 29.04.1918 Individuals’s Republic of Ukraine and the Ukrainian State, or Hetmonate, was based.
On the identical day, Pavlo Skoropadskyj was introduced by Ukraine etmon. He cooperated with the German occupation management, however relied primarily on the officers of Tsarist Russia, and was a supporter of the Ukrainian-Russian federal union.
Therefore, even earlier than the institution of Soviet energy in Ukraine, there already existed its personal statehood and even two varieties (conditionally – left-wing democratic and authoritarian).
The Soviet Union was not formally established till 1922, and the Ukrainian SSR was one in every of its founders, as said within the Treaty Establishing the Union.
Soviet Artefacts picture/Unsplash picture/Lenin
The independence of Ukraine was formally acknowledged by the Soviet authorities and this was mirrored in worldwide agreements.
For instance, in 1921 March 18 making Peace of RigaUkraine (Ukrainian SSR) and the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic acted independently, and in Article 2 of the peace settlement it was said: “Each contracting events, following the precept of self-determination of peoples, acknowledge the independence of Ukraine and Belarus…”
Later, Ukraine’s standing as a founding member of the Soviet Union was accredited within the Białowieża agreements on the collapse of the USSR:
“We, the Republic of Belarus, the Russian Federation and Ukraine, because the founders of the state of the USSR Union, in 1922 We, the signatories of the Union Treaty, hereinfollowing known as the Excessive Contracting Events, declare that the Union of the USSR as a topic of worldwide regulation and a geopolitical actuality ceases to exist.”
Prevented sharp questions
Since T. Carlson didn’t ask many delicate questions, for instance, in regards to the legality of the annexation of Crimea or the preparation of “referendums” on the annexation of the occupied territories to Russia, V. Putin didn’t want to clarify his place.
Nevertheless, when speaking regarding present political points, V. Putnas doesn’t draw back from decoding them the best way he likes.
For instance, when describing China’s achievements, the Russian chief repeats twice:
“China’s potential is big, immediately it’s the first economic system on the planet by way of buying energy and financial quantity. It has lengthy overtaken the USA, and the tempo is rising.”
Certainly, by way of gross home product calculated at buying energy parity, China lenkia JAV.
Nevertheless by whole GDP The US continues to be primary.
Luxembourg has the very best GDP per capita adopted by China lagging behind even from Belarus.
It’s logical to imagine that the calculation of GDP primarily based on buying energy parity was chosen as a criterion not for any goal causes, however solely as an instance the “potential” of Beijing.
Buying energy parity is calculated as the typical of sure ratios of the costs of products and providers in contrast between international locations, expressed within the nationwide forex of the international locations. First, the buying energy parity (ie value ratio) is calculated for every good and repair, then the typical of those ratios is derived in keeping with a particular methodology.
Reuters/Scanpix picture/Vladimir Putin
The journalist was additionally improper
The publication “The Washington Put up” evaluated this interview as a affirmation of the Kremlin’s ties with the Republican Celebration of former US President Donald Trump.
At its starting, the journalist complains that the top of the Kremlin stays unheard.
“Not a single Western journalist bothered to interview Vladimir Putin, the president of one other nation concerned on this battle,” T. Carlson mentioned. – Most Individuals don’t know why V. Putin invaded Ukraine and what targets he’s now pursuing. They’ve by no means heard his voice. It’s improper.”
However The Washington Put up’s Adam Taylor saysthat it was T.Carlson who misled his viewers right here.
In his textual content, he recalled the occupation of Lithuania in 1939, V. Putin’s statements regarding it and the present state of affairs of the conflict with Ukraine, when he doesn’t want T. Carlson to convey his message.
“The Russian president has had no scarcity of alternatives to specific his opinion regarding why he determined to invade Ukraine in 2022. February 24 Certainly, he has repeatedly supplied detailed explanations of this mystifying resolution. If T.Carlson hasn’t heard them earlier than, then he hasn’t listened,” the journalist mentioned in his remark.
The Russian president has not given interviews to Western journalists since his troops launched a full-scale invasion of Ukraine practically two years in the past. The final time he did it was in 2021. in Octoberwhen the CNBC correspondent talked to V. Putin on the sidelines of the power convention in Moscow for 20 minutes.
Nevertheless, this alternative was made not by journalists, however by the Kremlin. “Over the previous 18 months, we’ve made a number of requests to the Kremlin,” he mentioned in response to Carlson’s video wrote BBC Russia editor Steve Rosenberg. “We have all the time had a solution.”
Later himself The Kremlin denied T.Carlson’s assertion. “Mr. Carlson is improper,” on Wednesday in the course of the each day information briefing Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov mentioned. “We get quite a lot of requests to interview the president.”
ZUMAPRESS/Scanpix picture/Tucker Carlson
15min verdict: partly a lie. V. Putin’s interview with T. Carlson comprises each clearly false statements and a lot of tendentious interpretations and assessments.
The publication was ready in quarter-hour in partnership with Metawhich goals to cease the unfold of deceptive information on the social community. Extra regarding this system and its guidelines – right here.
#Vladimir #Putins #lies #omissions #interview #Tucker #Carlson
2024-05-15 04:57:49
