The Patchwork Charm of “Water for Elephants” on Broadway
By [Your Name]
In a world where extravagant circus performances have become the norm, the new Broadway musical “Water for Elephants” offers a refreshing change. Set in the Benzini Brothers’ Depression-era traveling circus, the show embraces a patched-together aesthetic that adds to its charm and authenticity.
Unlike the tiptop big top of other circuses, the Benzini Brothers’ establishment is a ragtag affair. The animals are malnourished and slightly mangy, while the performers, though skilled, appear a little weary. The tent and the traveling quarters are not polished and pristine either. But these imperfections only add to the show’s allure.
Based on the best-selling novel by Sara Gruen, “Water for Elephants” tells the story of Jacob Jankowski, a young man who joins the circus in 1931 following dropping out of veterinary school. The musical seamlessly switches between the present, where an elderly Jacob reminisces regarding his time at the circus, and the past, where the audience witnesses his transformative journey.
One of the standout characters is August, the circus owner and ringmaster, played by Paul Alexander Nolan. August is a sleek charmer with a dark side, portrayed brilliantly by Nolan, who manages to captivate the audience every time he takes the stage. The score, composed by the talented PigPen Theatre Co., perfectly complements August’s sinister persona.
As the story unfolds, we meet Marlena, August’s wife, whose soaring voice is brought to life by Isabelle McCalla. Marlena becomes a victim of August’s brutality, as does the crowd-drawing elephant, Rosie. Interestingly, the animal characters in the musical are portrayed through puppets, adding a unique dimension to the storytelling. This device allows humans and animals to seamlessly intertwine, blurring the line between spectacle and reality.
Directed by Jessica Stone and featuring stunning acrobatics choreographed by Shana Carroll from the Montreal collective the 7 Fingers, “Water for Elephants” is a visceral experience. The precision and physicality of the cast’s performances bring even the simplest acts, like hammering stakes to set up the tent, to life. It’s a reminder of the inherent risks embraced by circus performers and the constant athleticism required in their everyday lives.
While the music in “Water for Elephants” may not be the most memorable aspect of the production, it effectively captures the spirit of the 1930s, infused with elements of folk rock from the late 1960s and early ’70s. The duet “Wild,” sung by Jacob and Marlena, evokes the romanticism of early Joni Mitchell, while other songs transport us to a melancholic Americana atmosphere reminiscent of Randy Newman’s compositions.
However, the lyrics sometimes fall into the trap of bland earnestness, lacking the sharp angles that characterized Newman’s work. If only the score had taken more risks and matched the show’s overall spirit of adventure and unpredictability.
“Water for Elephants” is currently running at the Imperial Theatre in New York, captivating audiences with its patchwork charm. It reminds us that even in a world of polished and perfected performances, there is beauty in imperfection and authenticity in the unconventional.
Implications and Future Trends:
The enduring appeal of “Water for Elephants” lies in its ability to transport audiences to a bygone era. In a time where technology dominates the entertainment industry, this musical serves as a nostalgic reminder of the power of live performances and the raw talents of exceptional artists.
As we look to the future, we can expect a resurgence of interest in immersive and experiential entertainment. Audiences crave moments that allow them to escape from everyday monotony and engage with captivating stories and characters. “Water for Elephants” taps into this desire by transporting viewers to a time when the circus was the epitome of spectacle and wonder.
Furthermore, the integration of puppets and acrobatics in the show highlights the potential for innovative storytelling techniques in the industry. The seamless blending of human and animal characters offers a new perspective on the relationship between humans and nature, a topic that resonates strongly in today’s world.
In an age where environmental conservation and animal welfare are becoming increasingly important, “Water for Elephants” serves as a powerful reminder of our responsibility to protect and respect the natural world. It encourages us to appreciate the beauty and complexity of the animal kingdom and reevaluate our own place within it.
Looking ahead, the success of “Water for Elephants” may inspire other productions to explore similar themes and inventive storytelling methods. By combining nostalgia, spectacle, and thought-provoking narratives, future musicals and theatrical experiences have the potential to captivate audiences while sparking conversations regarding our interconnectedness with the world around us.
Recommendations for the Industry:
Based on the success of “Water for Elephants,” industry professionals should consider embracing more diverse and unconventional storytelling techniques. By pushing boundaries and exploring new forms of expression, they can captivate audiences in ways that go beyond traditional musical theater.
Collaborations between theater companies, circus artists, and puppeteers can lead to groundbreaking productions that blur the line between different art forms. These partnerships allow for the development of immersive experiences that transport audiences to imaginative worlds, while also delivering important messages regarding social and environmental issues.
Furthermore, the integration of live music and creative use of technology can enhance the overall theatrical experience. By incorporating interactive elements and multimedia displays, productions can engage audiences on multiple sensory levels, creating unforgettable moments that resonate long following the final curtain falls.
In conclusion, “Water for Elephants” is a testament to the power of storytelling and the enduring allure of the circus. It not only provides a captivating experience for theater enthusiasts but also serves as a catalyst for future trends in the industry. By embracing unconventional narratives and merging diverse art forms, the theater world can continue to captivate audiences and inspire meaningful conversations for years to come.
