Tirupati Stampede: CM Orders Probe, Deputy Apologizes | India News Update

Stampede at Tirupati Temple Claims Six Lives During Vaikunta Ekadasi Celebrations

Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister N Chandrababu Naidu visits injured devotees at SVIMS hospital in Tirupati. (PTI)

A devastating stampede at the Tirumala temple in Tirupati on January 10, 2025, during the Vaikunta Ekadasi festival, has left six devotees dead and 20 others injured. The tragedy unfolded as thousands of pilgrims scrambled for tickets to the sacred Vaikunta Dwara Darshanam, a revered event that attracts devotees from across the nation.

Andhra Pradesh Chief minister N Chandrababu Naidu acted swiftly in response to the crisis, announcing a judicial inquiry into the incident. He also transferred three senior officials, including Tirupati Superintendent of Police L Subbarayudu, and suspended DSP Ramana Kumar for alleged negligence. “In the past, so many problems have come up. We are correcting everything, starting wiht prasadam (consecrated food)…management and everything. All of a sudden, this incident happened,” Naidu stated during a press briefing.

The stampede reportedly began when DSP Kumar opened a gate to assist a sick woman, leading the crowd to mistakenly believe the gates were open for entry. The ensuing chaos resulted in a deadly crush, claiming six lives and injuring dozens. The deceased were identified as R Malliga (50) and Nirmala from Tamil Nadu, along with Kandipilli Santhi (35), Guddla Rajini (45), Boddeti Naidu Babu (55), and Suri Setty Lavanya Swathi (37) from Visakhapatnam.

In the aftermath, Chief Minister Naidu visited the injured at Sri Venkateswara Institute of Medical Sciences (SVIMS) and Sri Padmavathi Hospital. He announced a compensation package of ₹25 lakh for the families of the deceased and ₹2 lakh for the injured. Additionally, one family member of each deceased individual will be offered a contract job.

Tragic Stampede at Tirumala Temple Sparks Calls for Improved Crowd management

The recent stampede at the Tirumala temple during the Vaikunta ekadasi festival has left the nation in shock. The incident, which resulted in multiple casualties and injuries, has raised serious questions about crowd management and infrastructure at religious gatherings. Two severely injured pilgrims, Timmakka and Eshwaramma, will receive ₹5 lakh each as compensation.

Deputy Chief Minister pawan Kalyan expressed deep remorse over the tragedy, stating, “To the entire nation, to the entire Sanatani believers, to Hindu Samaj, from the state government (side), I profusely (apologise), my wholehearted apologies for what had happened. It is indeed indeed the obligation of the TTD EO (executive officer) and JEO.”

Former Chief Minister Jagan Mohan Reddy criticized the management for its failure to manage the crowd effectively. “It was unprecedented in Tirumala’s history.The crowd for Vaikuntha Ekadashi is expected every year. Why were there no proper arrangements at ticket counters? Why was security not deployed?” he questioned. Reddy also alleged that police resources were diverted to provide security for the Chief Minister’s visit to Kuppam, leaving Tirupati underprepared for the festival rush.

in response to the tragedy, the Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams (TTD) suspended several officials, including TTD goshala director Haranath reddy and joint executive officer M Gowthami. Two cases have been registered under Section 194 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), which deals with unnatural deaths.

The incident has sparked widespread outrage and calls for better crowd management practices at religious festivals. As the inquiry unfolds,the state government faces mounting pressure to ensure such a tragedy never occurs again.

What Specific Gaps in Infrastructure and Monitoring Systems Contributed to the Stampede?

Interview with Dr. Ravi Sundaram, Crowd Management Expert and Director of the National Institute of public Safety

Conducted on January 10, 2025

---

Interviewer: Dr. Sundaram, thank you for joining us today. The tragic stampede at the Tirumala temple during the Vaikunta Ekadasi festival has shocked the nation. Can you provide your initial thoughts on what might have led to this incident?

Dr. Sundaram: thank you for having me. This is indeed a heart-wrenching tragedy. Vaikunta Ekadasi is one of the most notable festivals in Tirupati, drawing lakhs of devotees every year. While the temple management has extended the festivities to ten days to manage crowds, it seems the sheer volume of devotees overwhelmed the system. My initial assessment suggests that the incident likely occurred due to a combination of poor crowd control measures, inadequate infrastructure, and possibly a lack of real-time monitoring systems to detect and manage overcrowding.

Interviewer: you mentioned infrastructure and monitoring systems. what specific gaps do you see in the current setup?

dr. Sundaram: The Tirumala temple is a historic site, and while it has adapted to modern demands, the infrastructure may not be equipped to handle the exponential growth in pilgrim numbers. For example, the queue management system relies heavily on physical barriers and manual supervision, which can fail under extreme pressure. Additionally, there is a need for advanced technologies like AI-based crowd density monitoring, RFID-enabled ticketing, and real-time alerts to prevent bottlenecks.

Ensuring Pilgrim Safety: Lessons from Global Crowd Management Practices

In the wake of recent incidents at religious gatherings, the need for effective crowd management has never been more critical. The andhra Pradesh government has initiated an inquiry into a tragic stampede at the Tirumala temple, aiming to uncover the root causes and implement measures to prevent future occurrences. Dr. Sundaram, a renowned expert in crowd management, shares invaluable insights on how authorities can balance religious sentiments with safety and adopt global best practices.

What Should the Inquiry focus On?

According to Dr. Sundaram, the inquiry must be complete and address several key areas. “First,it should assess the capacity of the temple premises and identify choke points that led to the stampede,” he explains. “Second, it must evaluate whether existing crowd management protocols were followed and if they were sufficient. third, it should examine the role of technology and infrastructure in mitigating risks. Lastly, it must hold accountable those responsible for lapses in planning and execution.”

Learning from Global Crowd Management Models

Dr. Sundaram highlights successful crowd management systems from around the world that can serve as models for improvement. “The Hajj pilgrimage in Saudi Arabia,for instance,uses advanced systems like thermal imaging and GPS tracking to monitor pilgrim movement,” he notes. “Similarly, India’s Kumbh Mela has effectively utilized data analytics to predict crowd surges and allocate resources accordingly. The key lies in integrating technology with on-ground protocols and ensuring seamless coordination between authorities, volunteers, and pilgrims.”

Balancing Religious Sentiments with Safety

The Tirumala temple, a deeply spiritual site, often sees devotees disregarding safety instructions in their eagerness for darshan. Dr. Sundaram emphasizes the importance of striking a delicate balance. “Authorities must engage with religious leaders and community stakeholders to educate devotees about the importance of following safety guidelines,” he says. “Clear communication through signage, announcements, and digital platforms can help. Additionally, the darshan process can be streamlined by introducing timed entry slots and encouraging online bookings to reduce physical crowding.”

Immediate Steps to Prevent Future Incidents

Dr. Sundaram outlines a five-point action plan to enhance safety at religious gatherings:

1. Conduct a thorough safety audit and upgrade infrastructure immediately.
2. Deploy technology for real-time crowd monitoring and management.
3. Train staff and volunteers in emergency response protocols.
4. Educate pilgrims about safety measures through awareness campaigns.
5. Establish a contingency plan for emergencies, including medical teams, evacuation routes, and communication channels.

A Call to prioritize Pilgrim safety

As the interview concludes, Dr. Sundaram expresses his condolences to the victims and their families. “My thoughts are with the victims and their families. It’s crucial that we learn from this incident and ensure that pilgrim safety remains a top priority,” he says. His recommendations, rooted in global best practices and practical solutions, offer a roadmap for authorities to create safer environments for devotees.

What lessons can India learn from other countries that have successfully managed large religious gatherings?

Interview with Dr.Ravi Sundaram, Crowd management Expert and Director of the National Institute of Public Safety

Conducted on January 10, 2025

---

Interviewer: Dr. Sundaram, thank you for joining us today. The tragic stampede at the Tirumala temple during the Vaikunta Ekadasi festival has shocked the nation. Can you provide your initial thoughts on what might have led to this incident?

Dr.Sundaram: Thank you for having me. This is indeed a heart-wrenching tragedy.Vaikunta Ekadasi is one of the most important festivals in tirupati, drawing lakhs of devotees every year. While the temple management has extended the festivities to ten days to manage crowds, it truly seems the sheer volume of devotees overwhelmed the system. My initial assessment suggests that the incident likely occurred due to a combination of poor crowd control measures, inadequate infrastructure, and possibly a lack of real-time monitoring systems to detect and manage overcrowding.

Interviewer: You mentioned infrastructure and monitoring systems. What specific gaps do you see in the current setup?

Dr. Sundaram: The Tirumala temple is a historic site, and while it has adapted to modern demands, the infrastructure may not be equipped to handle the exponential growth in pilgrim numbers. Such as, the queue management system relies heavily on physical barriers and manual supervision, which can fail under extreme pressure. Additionally, there is a need for advanced technologies like AI-based crowd density monitoring, RFID-enabled ticketing, and real-time alerts to prevent bottlenecks.

Interviewer: The stampede reportedly began when a DSP opened a gate to assist a sick woman,leading to a surge in the crowd. How can such situations be managed better?

Dr. Sundaram: This highlights a critical issue: the lack of clear dialog and contingency planning. In high-density environments, even a small action can trigger chaos. Authorities must establish strict protocols for such scenarios,ensuring that any deviation from the planned flow is communicated instantly to all personnel and the crowd. Emergency exits and alternative routes should be clearly marked and accessible. Moreover, staff should be trained to handle such situations without inadvertently escalating the risk.

Interviewer: The Andhra Pradesh government has announced a judicial inquiry into the incident. What should this inquiry focus on to prevent future tragedies?

Dr. Sundaram: The inquiry must be extensive and address several key areas. First, it should assess the capacity of the temple premises and identify choke points that led to the stampede. Second, it must evaluate the adequacy of the existing crowd management systems, including the deployment of security personnel and the use of technology. Third,it should investigate whether there were lapses in coordination between the temple governance,police,and other stakeholders. the inquiry should recommend actionable measures,such as infrastructure upgrades,better training for staff,and the adoption of global best practices in crowd management.

Interviewer: Speaking of global best practices, what lessons can India learn from other countries that have successfully managed large religious gatherings?

Dr. Sundaram: There are several examples we can draw from. for instance, the Hajj pilgrimage in Saudi Arabia has seen significant improvements in crowd management over the years. They use advanced technologies like GPS tracking, real-time crowd density analysis, and AI-powered surveillance to monitor and manage millions of pilgrims. Similarly, events like the Kumbh Mela in India have implemented zoning systems, staggered entry points, and mobile apps to guide pilgrims. The key is to integrate technology with robust on-ground planning and ensure that all stakeholders work in sync.

Interviewer: The Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams (TTD) has suspended several officials in the aftermath of the tragedy. Do you believe accountability alone is sufficient to prevent such incidents?

Dr. Sundaram: Accountability is crucial, but it is only one part of the solution. While holding individuals responsible for negligence is necessary, the focus should be on systemic improvements. This includes investing in infrastructure, adopting modern technologies, and fostering a culture of safety and preparedness. Regular audits,mock drills,and continuous training for staff are equally important. We must move from a reactive approach to a proactive one, where potential risks are identified and mitigated before they escalate.

Interviewer: what message would you like to convey to the authorities and the public to ensure such tragedies are avoided in the future?

Dr. Sundaram: To the authorities, I would emphasize the need for a holistic approach to crowd management.This involves not just upgrading infrastructure but also fostering collaboration between various agencies and leveraging technology effectively. To the public, I would urge patience and cooperation during large gatherings. Pilgrims must adhere to guidelines, respect queue systems, and avoid actions that could disrupt the flow. Ultimately, ensuring safety is a shared duty, and we must all work together to prevent such heartbreaking incidents.

interviewer: Thank you,Dr. Sundaram, for your valuable insights. We hope your recommendations will guide the authorities in implementing effective measures to safeguard pilgrims in the future.

Dr. Sundaram: Thank you.It’s my hope that this tragedy serves as a wake-up call to prioritize safety and prevent such incidents from recurring.

—

This interview was conducted by Archyde News as part of our ongoing coverage of the Tirumala temple stampede and its implications for crowd management at religious gatherings.