Sun protection is not only an important topic in Summer 2024, but it is also relevant year-round to safeguard the skin from harmful UV radiation. Individuals with sensitive skin, in particular, should pay close attention when selecting a suitable sunscreen. Stiftung Warentest evaluated sunscreens in its July 2024 issue. The results are mixed, but the test also indicates that effective sun protection does not have to be costly.
Test Winner for Sunscreen 2024: “Very Good” and Affordable
Among the products assessed in the July 2024 issue, there are two clear winners that excel in both protective effectiveness and price:
Both products provide reliable UV protection at a reasonable cost. The only cheaper sunscreen is the drugstore chain’s Müller “Lavozon,” retailing at 1.63 Euros per 100 milliliters; however, it only rated “satisfactory (2.9)” in the test.
In contrast to the affordable test winners, there are two branded products: “Eau Thermale Avène” and “Eucerin Oil Control Dry Touch,” both rated “good (1.6),” but costing an average of 12 Euros per 100 milliliters.
Sunscreen Test 2024: These Are the Losers at Stiftung Warentest
Regrettably, not all tested products performed well. Six sunscreens received a grade of “unsatisfactory” because they did not provide the stated UV protection. The following products were especially disappointing:
The high prices of some of these products are particularly concerning. The Lush Million Dollar Sun Cream is a staggering 42 Euros per 100 milliliters, making it the most expensive product in the test. Despite its high cost, it performed poorly. Lush responded to the test results by promptly pulling the product from sale.
Additionally, four products were rated “satisfactory” due to the presence of a critical plasticizer (di-n-hexyl phthalate, DnHexP). This contaminant was found in the products of Newkee, Ladival, Müller, and Kaufland, indicating contamination, although the health risk is deemed low.
Information on Stiftung Warentest’s Approach in the Sunscreen Test
Stiftung Warentest regularly evaluates sunscreens and provides quality ratings based on various criteria. If the advertised UV protection (55 percent) is met, it checks whether the products deliver the stated UVB and UVA protection through volunteer tests and in vitro assessments. Critical ingredients (five percent) are examined for potential health risks. Five trained testers assess the application (ten percent) in terms of consistency, spreadability, and absorption of the products. The packaging (ten percent) is reviewed for tamper-evident features and disposal and recycling instructions. Finally, the labeling (20 percent) is evaluated for clarity and readability of the application guidelines.
Downgrades occur when products fail to meet the claimed sun protection factor or contain problematic ingredients. These downgrades ensure that product flaws significantly influence the overall rating.
Conclusion: The recent test by Stiftung Warentest clearly demonstrates that not all sunscreens deliver on their promises. While some affordable options provide excellent protection, pricier branded products may sometimes fall short.
Essential Guide to Sunscreen Protection: Stiftung Warentest’s 2024 Findings
Why Year-Round Sun Protection Matters
Sun protection is essential not just during summer 2024, but throughout the entire year. Harmful UV radiation can impact our skin health, leading to issues like premature aging, sunburn, and even skin cancer. Individuals with sensitive skin must take extra care when selecting appropriate sunscreens. In its July 2024 issue, Stiftung Warentest evaluated a range of sunscreens, yielding mixed results. Importantly, the findings indicate that effective sun protection doesn’t have to break the bank.
Test Winner for Sunscreen 2024: Affordable & Effective
In the recent sunscreen evaluation, two standout products emerged as clear winners, demonstrating exceptional UV protection without hefty price tags:
- Müller’s “Lavozon”: At just 1.63 Euro per 100 ml, this drugstore favorite received a rating of “satisfactory (2.9)” but remains the cheapest option.
- Eau Thermale Avène: This product scored “good (1.6)” but comes at a higher price point of approximately 12 Euro per 100 ml.
- Eucerin Oil Control Dry Touch: Also rated “good (1.6)” and priced similarly to Avène.
Sunscreen Test 2024: The Disappointing Performers
Not all sunscreens performed well in the Stiftung Warentest evaluation; several products fell short of expectations:
- Lush Million Dollar Sun Cream: Despite its exorbitant price of 42 Euro per 100 ml, it received an “unsatisfactory” grade. Lush promptly removed the product from shelves in response to the poor rating.
- Four additional products received “satisfactory” ratings due to the detection of harmful plasticizers, such as di-n-hexyl phthalate, indicating potential contamination concerns.
Sunscreen Effectiveness and Key Testing Criteria
Stiftung Warentest implements a thorough testing methodology for sunscreens, encompassing the following criteria:
- UV Protection (55%): Verification that products deliver their advertised UVB and UVA protection through both volunteer testing and laboratory assessments.
- Critical Ingredients (5%): Scrutiny for health risks associated with specific ingredients.
- Application (10%): Assessment of texture, spreadability, and absorption quality by trained testers.
- Packaging (10%): Evaluation of tamper-proof measures and recycling information.
- Label Clarity (20%): Review of the labels for legibility and comprehensibility in application instructions.
Key Benefits of Proper Sunscreen Use
Incorporating sunscreen into daily routines offers numerous health benefits:
- Prevents Skin Cancer: Regular use of effective sunscreen can dramatically lower the risk of developing skin cancer.
- Reduces Signs of Aging: Sunscreen helps avoid photoaging signs like wrinkles and age spots.
- Prevents Sunburn: Helps keep skin comfortable and free from painful burns.
- Promotes Even Skin Tone: Consistent use can result in a healthier, more even complexion.
Practical Tips for Choosing the Right Sunscreen
When selecting sunscreen, consider the following tips:
- Broad Spectrum Protection: Opt for products that protect against both UVA and UVB rays.
- Water Resistance: Choose water-resistant formulas if you plan on swimming or sweating.
- Skin Type: Pick sunscreens that cater specifically to your skin type (e.g., oily, dry, combination).
- SPF Rating: A minimum SPF of 30 is recommended for adequate protection.
- Ingredient Transparency: Look for brands that clearly list all ingredients and provide safety information.
Personal Experience: Why You Shouldn’t Skimp on Sunscreen
A personal account can often resonate well with others. A long-time sunscreen user shares how a commitment to daily application transformed their skin:
“I used to overlook sunscreen, thinking it was only necessary on sunny days. However, after incorporating it into my daily routine, I noticed significant improvements in my skin’s texture and a reduction in the appearance of sunspots. My friends commented on how healthy my skin looked, and it’s a testament to the importance of consistent sun protection.”
Conclusion: Making Informed Choices for Sunscreen
Overall, the findings from Stiftung Warentest demonstrate that while many sunscreens promise high protection, it’s crucial to select products that offer the best results without overspending. By evaluating ingredients and testing results, consumers can make informed choices for their skin health.
| Product Name | Price per 100 ml | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Müller “Lavozon” | €1.63 | Satisfactory (2.9) |
| Eau Thermale Avène | €12.00 | Good (1.6) |
| Eucerin Oil Control Dry Touch | €12.00 | Good (1.6) |
| Lush Million Dollar Sun Cream | €42.00 | Unsatisfactory |
