Ah, Netflix, the gift that keeps on giving—like an uncle who just found out he can give you socks without any guilt! Their latest offering, “The Merry Gentleman,” has graced our screens just in time for the festive season, and boy, it’s already number one on the charts. Apparently, it has achieved this feat by wrestling the crown off “Hot Frosty,” which, let’s be honest, sounds like something you’d find on the menu of a dodgy pub.
Now, as we dive into the reviews, they appear to be as mixed as your Nan’s fruitcake. Some are throwing praise at the all-male dance revue, likely with enough glitter to start a disco ball factory, while others are left scratching their heads wondering if they accidentally clicked on a parody. Personally, I watched “The Merry Gentleman” and found it moderately enjoyable—akin to finding that a cup of tea has one biscuit, but not the good kind—in other words, it’s a bit forgettable. But if Hallmark rom-coms are your jam, then hey, why not crank that festive spirit up to 11?
What’s “The Merry Gentleman” All About?
This charming little flick follows Ashley, played by Britt Robertson, a disgruntled big-city dancer who couldn’t cut it in the fast-paced world of showbiz because… she’s aged out. The horror! Like a milk carton past its expiration date. When she returns to her hometown for some festive cheer, she finds her family’s bar stuck in financial quicksand! So, naturally, she decides to whip together an all-male Christmas dance revue. Because who needs traditional family gatherings when you can have a half-naked carpentry-enthusiast shaking it on stage? Enter Chad Michael Murray as Luke, the local chiseler—sorry, carpenter—who joins her for what sounds like a series of whimsical dance misadventures. Picture “Dirty Dancing,” but with twice the flannel and half the plot.
The Reception: Critics are a Mixed Bunch
Currently, “The Merry Gentlemen” holds a somewhat suspicious status on Rotten Tomatoes, sitting on a rocky foundation where only two out of seven reviews have been favorable. That’s not just a rotten score, it’s downright compost! But fear not, for not all is misery; one brave reviewer, Archi Sengupta from LeisureByte, claims the flick is “ridiculously goofy” and promises “lusty moments” to keep viewers entertained! Not quite sure how one defines “lusty” in a Christmas movie, but a little spice never hurt anyone, right? Maybe we’re getting a seasonal rebranding of “Take Me Out”—with more tinsel and fewer awkward silences.
However, not everyone shares this festive mirth. The Guardian’s Benjamin Lee pointed out that while there’s nothing “distractingly bad,” it falls into the “overcrowded” space of Christmas films that simply offer no reason to click it. This sounds about as appealing as a Christmas karaoke night that turns into a competition for the most ear-splitting renditions of classic hits. Further adding to the cacophony, Sarah Musnicky from But Why Tho? suggests it’s a lovely touch showcasing male dancers, though it appears the enthusiasm doesn’t translate into the overall magic of the season.
Should You Stream It?
So here’s the big question: Should you tumble down the rabbit hole of “The Merry Gentleman”? If you’re the kind of person who can guzzle down mulled wine and laughter at any cheesy Christmas film, then yes! Otherwise, if you’re expecting a traditional frosty glass of cinematic brilliance, you may be better off cozying up with a classic Hallmark film—or perhaps even something spicier with more emotional depth. Who knew that could even be an option? Fancy that!
In a nutshell, while “The Merry Gentleman” might not be the Christmas gift you were hoping for, it could still provide some light entertainment—a bit like your distant cousin’s dodgy dance moves at the office party. You’ll laugh, you’ll cringe, but you might leave with a light heart and a chuckle. Either way, it’s here, it’s festive, and it’s definitely watching-worthy for a lazy December evening. Who knows, maybe the male revue will save more than just the bar; it could save your will to believe in Christmas movies, one questionable dance at a time!
“The Merry Gentlemen” is available to stream on Netflix now.
Netflix has unveiled its latest holiday feature, “The Merry Gentleman”, which has quickly ascended to the No.1 rank on the charts of its streaming platform. Previously reigning supreme was the film “Hot Frosty”, which has now been eclipsed by “The Merry Gentleman” as the holiday favorite on the platform.
As audiences stream the film, initial reviews have started pouring in. Current feedback on the film appears mixed; some viewers have praised its engaging all-male dance revue, while others have expressed their displeasure with the concept. After watching the film myself, I find it distinctly unremarkable and easily forgettable. However, those with a penchant for Hallmark-style romantic comedies might discover some entertainment in it.
What is ‘The Merry Gentleman’ about?
“The Merry Gentleman” follows Ashley (Britt Robertson), a talented dancer from the city who faces dismissal from her Christmas performance due to age. Seeking solace, she heads back home, only to discover that her family’s small-town venue is weighed down by financial woes.
In a bid to salvage her parents’ bar before Christmas, Ashley concocts a plan to put on an all-male Christmas revue, persuading Luke (Chad Michael Murray), the charming local carpenter, to join her. Amidst showing off some scintillating dance numbers, the duo ignites a romantic spark as they work together to secure funds needed to keep the bar afloat.
‘The Merry Gentleman’ reviews — critics aren’t loving this movie so much
As of now, “The Merry Gentlemen” has yet to receive a Rotten Tomatoes score. However, of the seven reviews counted thus far, only two have garnered positive feedback, setting the film up for a potentially low rating.
In a rare bright note, LeisureByte’s Archi Sengupta remarked: “The Merry Gentlemen on Netflix is ridiculously goofy, but it’s the lusty moments that will keep viewers hooked and merry this Christmas season.”
Meanwhile, Sarah Musnicky from But Why Tho? expressed that “the special flair of having an all-male dance revue come to save the day is a lovely touch that works to attract viewers while reminding us that creativity can indeed save the day.”
Unfortunately, the overall sentiment surrounding the film leans toward the critical side. Guardian’s Benjamin Lee noted, “There’s nothing distractingly bad about this one… but due to the crowded genre, there’s also nothing here that’s worth a click.” I find myself resonating with this viewpoint.
Samantha Bergeson from indieWire also emphasized the film’s lack of that quintessential holiday spirit: “Murray and Robertson feel tired as leads, and the conventional scenes lack the holiday spice that the genre thrives on.”
Radio Times’ Patrick Cremona perfectly encapsulated my thoughts: “For lovers of the genre, it might go down well with a glass of mulled wine and a mince pie, but this film feels more entertaining in concept than in execution.”
Should you stream ‘The Merry Gentleman’?
While “The Merry Gentleman” may appeal to fans of cheesy holiday rom-coms, it didn’t resonate with me. Despite the undeniable chemistry between Robertson and Murray, their connection feels rushed, lacking true emotional depth that often elevates such films.
Some acting moments veer into the cringe-worthy territory, though I suppose that’s somewhat expected for Hallmark-style offerings. Sadly, the film seems devoid of the festive charm that encourages repeat viewings during the holiday season.
Nevertheless, if you revel in a Christmas movie binge and enjoy the lighthearted allure of holiday rom-coms, “The Merry Gentleman” could still be a worthy addition to your holiday watch list. While it’s not a remarkable standout, it does offer cozy entertainment for those feeling the Christmas spirit.
For those less interested, explore our guide on all 47 Hallmark Christmas movies and where to stream them. Or for those seeking something a bit more thrilling this holiday season, consider checking out these top Christmas thrillers.
“The Merry Gentlemen” is available to stream on Netflix now.