MEXICO CITY.- The Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation (SCJN) admitted the query to review the reform of the Judiciarypublished in the Official Gazette of the Federation (DOF) on September 15
With eight votes in favor and three against, the Plenary Session of the Court will submit for discussion and analysis one of the 10 pending consultations made by the minister president, Norma Piña.
These are consultations to analyze whether or not the challenges presented by federal judges and magistrates against the judicial reform are admitted.
With this decision, the SCJN will begin a discussion about what powers it has to analyze the reform and, if applicable, determine if the initiative of the former president Andrés Manuel López Obrador whether it is endorsed or derogated.
With 8 votes in favor and 3 against, the pending consultation proposed by Minister González Alcántara Carrancá is approved. pic.twitter.com/x6IiSOKsSf
— Norma PH (@NormaPinaH) October 3, 2024
Analysis of the reform of the Judicial Branch admitted in the SCJN
By majority vote, the Court determined that the Organic Law of the Judicial Power of the Federation (LOPJF) grants the Supreme Court powers to resolve legal conflicts that affect the autonomy of the Judicial Branch of the Federation.
This law also provides independence to its members to be able to issue resolutions.
The only votes against were from the ministers Lenia Batres, Loretta Ortiz y Yasmin Esquivelwho on previous occasions have been singled out for their closeness to the Obrador administration.
🚨⚠️ EXTRA: Minister Luis María Aguilar Morales energetically addresses the arguments of the three ministers of the ruling bloc and tells them:
“The Court is an organ derived from the will of the people…it would seem that the Court is not a democratic body as I hear here…”
With… pic.twitter.com/5w7XYJWCZY
— Ernesto Guerra | #LastLegislative🗳️ (@ErnestoGuerra_) October 3, 2024
Ministers Lenia Batres and Yasmín Esquivel accused the Court of approving the discussion of the reform as a “coup d’état.”
Lenia Batres warns of a ‘coup d’état’ if the Court analyzes the controversy over judicial reform
The minister @LeniaBatres pointed out that “if the @SCJN to assume powers that it does not have, it would violate the principle of constitutional supremacy, as well as the division of powers and… pic.twitter.com/L5sNSZem92
— Politico MX (@politicomx) October 3, 2024
The Supreme Court #SCJN approves by majority to review the constitutionality of the Judicial Reform, to determine if it can be reversed or annulled.
Minister of Morenoist origin, Lenia Batres says that if the Reform is stopped, a Coup d’état would be brewing in Mexico. pic.twitter.com/5hbzTUG5Jk— Jesús Rubén Peña (@revistacodigo21) October 3, 2024
In this Thursday’s session, the draft ruling that proposed admitting a pending consultation presented by the National Association of District Judges and Circuit Magistrates (Jufed).
Said project warns that the judicial reform violates the autonomy of the Judicial Branch of the Federation and the division of powers.
The ministers highlighted that admitting the consultation of the magistrates It does not imply a definitive pronouncement on the Court’s power to review judicial reform.
Nor does it prejudge the content of said reformgiven that A ruling must first be approved to define the powers granted to the Court by its organic law for the analysis of a constitutional reform.
The next sentences will determine whether or not the SCJN endorses the reform of the Judicial Branch.
‼️There is no legal reason to prevent the analysis of the Judicial Reform: Minister Margarita Ríos Farjat
📍This historic moment offers the Supreme Court the possibility that Mexican constitutional law is enriched with greater and broader debates in favor of and in… pic.twitter.com/Db7S2gBRjE— Erica Mora (@MoraErica) October 3, 2024
Without a doubt, a minister with a legal position represents me more than 3 ministers with a political position. Thank you Minister Laynez! ❤️ pic.twitter.com/PFhBwWvPSc
— Lupita Hinojosa (@lupita_hinojosa) October 3, 2024
“The SCJN is also a body created by the Constitution and the people of Mexico”
Minister Luis Ma. Aguilar pic.twitter.com/k8ZNmcYo3X
— VERÓNICA OSORNIO ⚖️🦉 (@veroosornio) October 3, 2024
🚨“NO ONE CALLED Ernestina Godoy, Adán Augusto and Monreal COUPISTS”🚨 😱, says the Minister of the @SCJN Juan Luis González Alcántara 🔥. Remember that 10 years ago, those of the 4T asked to review the constitutionality of a reform and THEY WERE NOT CHARGED ⚖️. Morenoist double standards? 😳… pic.twitter.com/FATY2SPLdv
— LuisCardenasMX (@LuisCardenasMx) October 3, 2024
Margarita Ríos-Farjat responds to Lenia Batres
After the minister @LeniaBatres He said there would be a ‘coup d’état’ if the @SCJN analyzes the controversy over judicial reform, the minister @MargRiosFarjat He emphasized that these types of statements “distort the litis and give… pic.twitter.com/cBslChEtsH
— Politico MX (@politicomx) October 3, 2024
They celebrate the Court’s decision
Workers of the Judicial Branch celebrated the Court’s resolution this Thursday.
🔴 The celebrations continue by Workers of the Judicial Branch, after the resolution of the Supreme Court
📽️ #VIDEO @Finan_R from EL UNIVERSAL pic.twitter.com/kHDgRnKAmR
— El Universal (@El_Universal_Mx) October 3, 2024
Opponents of the reform also expressed their satisfaction with the ministers’ vote.
Mexican men and women, these 8 brave Ministers of the Supreme Court of Justice of the United Mexican States approved that the highest court review the constitutionality of the judicial reform authored by the despot López Obrador.
The republic still stands 🇲🇽 Mexico… pic.twitter.com/Y2p6fkULS0
— Emilio Vallejo Rangel-Larios (@EmilioVallejoRL) October 3, 2024
Figures from the ruling party, such as the senator of the Labor Party, Gerardo Fernández Noroña, criticized the Court’s decision.
It seems obvious but many do not see it: the regime will not abide by any resolution that suspends or reverses the reform.
It is a real technical coup d’état. They are destroying the rule of law.
What sense does it make to return to the courts to issue resolutions that they will not comply with? pic.twitter.com/GOyUL8yt3K
— Carlos Arteaga (@CarlosArteagaTo) October 3, 2024
IGNORING THE SCJN IS A COUP D’ÉTAT. 🤬🤬🤬🤬 https://t.co/y8dwTcdzMY
— Martha Márquez (@MarthaMrqz) October 3, 2024
YOU MAY BE INTERESTED: PJ worker violates presidential security and rebukes AMLO and Sheinbaum in elevator (Video)
Related
#SCJN #admits #consultation #constitutionality #reform
2024-10-05 23:53:24
