5 judges, including Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Isa, disagreed with the majority decision of the 13-member full court of the Supreme Court. Uddin Khan rejected the appeal of the Sunni Unity Council, while Justice Yahya Afridi said in a dissenting note that those who declared themselves party candidates and joined other parties betrayed public trust.
Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Isa disagreed with the majority decision and agreed with the decision of Justice Jamal Mandukhel.
The Chief Justice of Pakistan, while reading the minority verdict, said that the Election Commissioner misinterpreted the decision of the Supreme Court regarding the symbol of the bat.
Chief Justice Qazi Faiz Isa will not be part of any bench next week, sources
While reading the decision, he said that the decision of the Election Commission is once morest the Constitution, the Election Commission cannot declare any party candidate independent, and certain seats cannot be left vacant.
Election Commission decision nullified, PTI eligible for reserved seats in National Assembly: Supreme Court
In the minority decision, it was said that the Sunni Ittehad Council did not contest the elections, Sunni Ittehad is not eligible for specific seats, no concession can be given to any political party above the law.
Justice Naeem Afghan and Justice Aminuddin Khan opposed the petitions and dismissed the appeal once morest the decision of the Peshawar High Court.
Which judges opposed giving seats to PTI, in which part did Justice Isa vote?
The dissenting note of Justice Yahya Afridi has also come out. In his dissenting note, he has said that the appeals of the Sunni Unity Council are rejected, the Sunni Unity Council cannot take reserved seats according to the constitution, PTI as a political party, law and constitution. It is fulfilled.
Justice Yahya Afridi said in a dissenting note that those candidates who have given certificates that they are from PTI should be declared as PTI candidates, PTI should be given reserved seats in the same ratio, those candidates who Other parties joined, they violated the will of the people.