Share the post “Private space, public space… a new balance to build in the cosmos”
During the event “2050 we are_ TOMORROW,” Caroline Freyssinet discussed the challenges of a rapidly transforming space environment, where nations and private companies are now vying to conquer and exploit space resources. As an astrochemist and research fellow at the CNRS, her work at Latmos (Laboratory of Atmospheres, Space Observations) involves searching for signs of extraterrestrial life and developing instruments for Mars exploration and Saturn’s moon Titan.
With a practical outlook, Caroline Freyssinet took the stage to discuss the future of space. She began by emphasizing that “Space is becoming the new frontier of international competition, posing significant scientific, economic, and strategic challenges.” This observation calls for a rebalancing of roles between public authorities and private companies in this domain.
Space: The New Playground for Major Powers
Caroline Freyssinet reminded the audience that since the Cold War, space has been a battleground for intense competition among major powers, especially between the United States and the Soviet Union. The dynamics have shifted today, with nations like China and India emerging as significant players. “Space is no longer solely the domain of historical powers; we are witnessing a proliferation of space programs from emerging nations,” she explained. Geopolitical issues are diversifying, leading to a never-before-seen landscape of technological and economic rivalry.
At the same time, space is no longer solely under governmental control. Private companies like SpaceX and Blue Origin have become pivotal players in this new era of space. “What we are observing now is the rise of the private sector in a realm that was once reserved for governments. This competition is equally economic and scientific, presenting gigantic opportunities for the exploitation of space resources.”
From Conquest to Exploitation: The New Economic Challenge
According to Caroline Freyssinet, the primary challenge of this new space era is not merely conquest but the exploitation of resources beyond Earth. “It is no longer about sending missions to explore but rather about utilizing space resources for economic purposes.” The economic potential of space is enormous, whether through mining rare metals from asteroids, harnessing solar energy in orbit, or expanding communications satellites.
These resources could also be crucial for the energy transition. She emphasized that “Control over space and its resources could become a factor of economic dominance in the future.” The technological capabilities of each nation and private entity to capitalize on these opportunities will ultimately define the geopolitical balance of power for decades.
“Whoever controls the resources of space will dominate the economy of the future.”
After the 1967 Space Treaty, A New Legal and Ethical Framework Must Be Established
Despite the vast opportunities, Caroline Freyssinet cautioned against the risks of chaotic development if legal frameworks fail to adapt to the new spatial reality. “The 1967 Outer Space Treaty, which prohibits the militarization and territorial claims in space, is now outdated. It no longer provides adequate responses to private ambitions and technological advancements.”
She advocates for strengthened international cooperation to avoid a new race for resources devoid of clear regulations. “If we do not want space to become a new battleground for resources, we must urgently establish rules to ensure peaceful and equitable use of these new territories.”
Cooperation: A Key to the Future of Space
Despite increasing tensions among states and private entities, Caroline Freyssinet remains convinced that international cooperation is vital to address the challenges presented by space. She believes that space exploration should be regarded as a collective endeavor, in which collaboration among governments, companies, and scientists is essential. “No one can succeed alone. The key to success lies in the synergy between the public and private sectors, alongside close international cooperation.”
Caroline Freyssinet concludes by advocating for space to be preserved as the common good of humanity: “It is not about limiting ambitions but about ensuring that space remains a shared resource, where innovation can thrive ethically and sustainably.” The future of space depends on the ability of all actors to strike a balance between competition and collaboration while safeguarding the integrity of this new frontier.
SUPPORT WE TOMORROW, SUPPORT INDEPENDENT EDITING
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter
and subscribe to our magazine.
Share the post “Private space, public space… a new balance to build in the cosmos”
Private Space, Public Space: A New Balance to Build in the Cosmos
During the event “2050 we are_ TOMORROW,” Caroline Freyssinet presented the challenges of a space in full transformation, where States and private companies are now competing to conquer and exploit space resources. An astrochemist and research fellow at the CNRS, her work at Latmos (Laboratory of Atmospheres, Space Observations) focuses on searching for traces of extraterrestrial life and designing instruments for the exploration of Mars or even Titan, Saturn’s moon.
With a pragmatic vision, Freyssinet took to the stage to discuss the future of space. From the outset, she emphasized that “Space is becoming the new horizon of international competition, with major scientific, economic, and strategic challenges.” This pivotal observation calls for a rebalancing of roles between public authorities and private companies in this vital area.
Space, the New Playground for Great Powers
Freyssinet highlighted that since the Cold War, space has been the scene of fierce competition between major powers, mainly the United States and the Soviet Union. Today, the dynamics have shifted, with nations such as China and India gaining significant ground. “Space is no longer the preserve of the great historical powers; we are witnessing a multiplication of space programs, including on the part of emerging nations,” she explained. This diversification of geopolitical issues creates an unprecedented terrain of technological and economic confrontation.
Space is also no longer solely under governmental influence. Private companies like SpaceX and Blue Origin have become central players in this new era. “What we are seeing today is the emergence of the private sector in what was for a long time the reserved domain of States. This competition is now as much economic as scientific, with gigantic opportunities in terms of exploitation of space resources.”
Key Players in the Space Race
- United States: Home to leading companies like SpaceX and Boeing, the U.S. is spearheading both governmental and commercial space efforts.
- China: Rapidly expanding its projects in both lunar and Martian exploration, China’s investments are substantial.
- India: The Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) is increasingly seen as a major player, launching affordable missions.
- Private Sector: Companies like Blue Origin and Virgin Galactic are innovating space tourism and commercial launches.
From Conquest to Exploitation: The New Economic Challenge
Freyssinet argues that the primary challenge of this new space era is not merely conquest but the exploitation of resources beyond Earth. “It is no longer about sending missions to explore, but about using space resources for economic purposes.” These resources include rare metals present on asteroids, solar energy harvested in orbit, and a multiplication of communications satellites, all of which embody immense economic potential.
These space resources could play a pivotal role in the energy transition. She stressed that “Control of space and its resources could become a factor of economic domination in the future.” The technological capabilities of each nation or private enterprise to exploit these opportunities will undoubtedly define the geopolitical balance of power for decades to come.
“Whoever masters the resources of space will dominate the economy of the future.”
After the 1967 Space Treaty: Inventing a New Legal and Ethical Framework
Despite the immense opportunities, Freyssinet warns of the risks of unregulated development if legal frameworks do not evolve to meet the new spatial reality. “The 1967 Outer Space Treaty, which prohibits the militarization and territorial claims of space, is now obsolete. It no longer provides adequate responses to the ambitions and technological developments of the private sector.”
She calls for strengthened international cooperation to prevent a new resource race without clear regulations. “If we do not want space to become a new battlefield for resources, we must quickly establish rules to guarantee peaceful and shared use of these new territories.”
International Cooperation: A Key to the Future of Space
Despite the increasing tensions between states and private actors, Freyssinet is convinced that international cooperation is vital to address the challenges posed by space. She believes that space exploration should be a collective adventure, where collaboration between governments, businesses, and scientists is essential. “No actor will be able to succeed alone. The key to success lies in synergy between the public and private sectors, as well as close international collaboration.”
Freyssinet concludes by advocating for maintaining space as a common good for humanity: “It is not about curbing ambitions, but about ensuring that space remains a common good, where innovation can develop in an ethical and sustainable way.” The future of space hinges on the ability of all actors to achieve a balance between competition and cooperation while upholding the integrity of this new frontier.
Benefits of Maintaining Space as a Common Good
- Promotes Ethical Innovation: Ensures technology and discoveries serve humanity as a whole.
- Facilitates Global Communication: A shared resource model fosters collaboration on pressing challenges like climate change and resource depletion.
- Encourages Sustainable Practices: Combines public safety with economic ambition, ensuring responsible resource utilization.
- Enhances Scientific Culture: Encourages education and public interest in astronomy and space exploration as communal pursuits.
Case Studies: Successful International Space Collaborations
| Nations Involved | Collaborative Project | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| USA, Russia, Europe, Japan | International Space Station (ISS) | Promoted scientific research and international cooperation in space. |
| USA, UAE, India | Mars Exploration Missions | Enhanced understanding of Martian geology and potential for life. |
| China, Russia | China-Russia Lunar Research Facility | Aim to establish a research base on the Moon by 2030. |