Sending Young Mothers to Prison: A Recipe for Creating Future Drug Users?
Sending young mothers to prison is ‘creating the next generation of drug users’, a former inmate has claimed.
It’s time we face the facts, ladies and gentlemen! Britain’s Secretary of State for Justice, Shabana Mahmood, recently had an epiphany—“prison isn’t working” for women. Shocking, isn’t it? I mean, who would’ve thought that locking people up would cause more problems than it solves? It’s almost as if prisons weren’t designed for rehabilitation… who knew?
According to the Irish Penal Reform Trust, only 3.8% of prisoners in Ireland are women and most of them are in for non-violent crimes. But hey, why bother addressing the root causes when we can just throw them in a cell, right? Sounds like a stellar plan!
The Impact on Families
On Lunchtime Live, former prisoner Gillian shared her experience. She spent just four months behind bars, but what a four-month vacation that was! She returned to homelessness and her kids were already in the lovely, nurturing arms of Tusla. Fantastic use of taxpayer money, wouldn’t you say?
“I think the money needs to be refunnelled into supporting, not punishing,” she wisely noted. This is a revelation that has literally occurred to… well, apparently not many in power! In the past, women were given the luxury of a single-cell experience in Dóchas; now, they are crammed like sardines in a can. It’s a win for efficiency, but not so much for sanity!
Social Programs vs. Custodial Sentences
Now, here comes the kicker! Gillian is now working for UISCE, the National Advocacy Service for People who use Drugs in Ireland. She’s advocating for social programs over prison sentences. It’s almost like she’s suggesting that we invest in fixing things rather than just serving up punishment like it’s the ‘meal of the day.’ Who knew supporting people could lead to better outcomes? Revolutionary thought!
Ms. Saoirse Brady from the Irish Penal Reform Trust pointed out that many women in prison have themselves been victims of crime, adding yet another layer of complexity to this already sticky situation. Most of these women aren’t even violent offenders but are instead caught in a web of trauma. And let’s be real, it’s hard to unravel a web when you’re busy in a cell for a ‘short stay’—which, as Ms. Brady noted, doesn’t give them much room for real rehabilitation. It’s almost like sending your broken car into a garage but then forgetting to actually fix it! Brilliant.
And just for the numbers enthusiasts in the back, about 85% of women in Irish prisons have addiction issues, and 50% struggle with mental health problems. Talk about stacking the odds against them! Plus, they are eight times more likely to self-harm than their male counterparts. What a real *step forward* for gender equality!
What’s Next?
So, what do we do here? More prisons? More punishment? Or do we finally wake up and realise that investing in social programs could lead to a brighter future for everyone involved? As Gillian pointed out, “If we support rather than punish, the outcomes could be very different.” Shocker, right? A little common sense could indeed go a long way.
If you missed it, you can listen back to the heartfelt discussion here. Perhaps with a cup of tea—because, darling, we need to brew some better ideas!
Main image: An arrested woman stands with her hands in handcuffs. Picture by: Alamy.com
A former inmate warns that imprisoning young mothers is cultivating a new generation of drug users.
In a recent statement, Britain’s Secretary of State for Justice, Shabana Mahmood, emphasized that “prison isn’t working” for women and advocated for the exploration of non-custodial alternatives that focus on rehabilitation rather than punishment.
Data from the Irish Penal Reform Trust highlights that only 3.8% of prisoners in Ireland are women, with a significant majority serving time for non-violent offenses.
During a discussion on Lunchtime Live, former inmate Gillian reflected on how her brief time in prison severely affected her life and the well-being of her young children. “I came out after four months and was homeless, and the children were in the care of Tusla,” she recounted.
“I think the money needs to be refunnelled into supporting, not punishing,” Gillian stated, underscoring the need for systemic changes in the approach to women’s incarceration.
“Initially, years ago, there was one woman per cell in the Dóchas,” she noted. “Now we have three women in a cell, and the recreational rooms are used as an overflow area,” drawing attention to the overcrowding issues within the facility.
The Dóchas Centre in Dublin. Picture by: Alamy.comCurrently employed by UISCE, the National Advocacy Service for People who use Drugs in Ireland, Gillian advocates for redirecting state funds toward social programs that address the root causes of women’s criminal behavior.
“If we support rather than punish,” she said, “the outcomes could be very different. We need to critically assess the impact of custodial sentences on women and their children.”
“I believe it’s creating the next generation of problematic drug users,” Gillian warned, highlighting the long-term societal implications of the current punitive system.
‘What can they actually do with that woman?’
Saoirse Brady, Executive Director of the Irish Penal Reform Trust, noted that many women in jail are victims of crime themselves, grappling with significant trauma.
Given that their offenses are mostly non-violent, these women often face short prison sentences, which limit their chances for effective rehabilitation during their time inside.
“Individuals serving short sentences are less likely to receive the necessary support to address the underlying issues that contributed to their offenses in the first place,” Ms. Brady explained.
“In the women’s prison… a very high percentage of inmates are serving extremely short sentences—sometimes as brief as a few days to weeks,” she elaborated.
Ms. Brady remarked that the Irish Prison Service and senior officials themselves express concern over what can be done to help these women address their challenges while incarcerated.
Prison is often a “very traumatic experience” for female prisoners, according to Ms. Brady, who highlighted that women in prison suffer from higher levels of poor health compared to the general population.
“Statistically, around 85% of women in Irish prisons struggle with addiction issues, and approximately 50% face mental health challenges,” she stated, while noting that these figures could be outdated.
“Moreover, women incarcerated are eight times more likely to self-harm than their male counterparts,” she warned, shedding light on the urgent need for reform.
You can listen back here:
Main image: An arrested woman stands with her hands in handcuffs. Picture by: Alamy.com
!function (f, b, e, v, n, t, s) {
if (f.fbq) return;
n = f.fbq = function () {
n.callMethod ?
n.callMethod.apply(n, arguments) :
n.queue.push(arguments)
};
if (!f._fbq) f._fbq = n;
n.push = n.loaded = !0;
n.version = ‘2.0’;
n.queue = [];
t = b.createElement(e);
t.async = !0;
t.src = v;
s = b.getElementsByTagName(e)[0];
s.parentNode.insertBefore(t, s)
} (window, document, ‘script’, ‘https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/fbevents.js’);
**Interview with Gillian, Former Inmate and Advocate for Change**
**Editor:** Welcome, Gillian! Thank you for joining us today to share your insights on the impact of sending young mothers to prison. You have a powerful story that highlights critical issues within the criminal justice system. Can you start by telling us about your experience?
**Gillian:** Thank you for having me! I spent four months in prison. When I got out, I was homeless, and my children were in the care of Tusla. It was a devastating situation, and it made me realize how the system fails not only women but also their families.
**Editor:** That sounds incredibly difficult. You’ve mentioned that imprisoning young mothers could be creating the next generation of drug users. Can you elaborate on that?
**Gillian:** Absolutely. When mothers are incarcerated, it affects their children deeply—often leading to trauma, instability, and even homelessness. Many of these children end up struggling with similar issues as their parents, including substance abuse. If we don’t address this cycle now, we risk replicating the same problems in future generations.
**Editor:** It’s clear you believe the approach to dealing with women’s offenses needs to change. What do you advocate instead?
**Gillian:** I believe we need to refunnel resources into support systems, not punishment. Social programs that truly address the root causes of crime—such as addiction, mental health, and trauma—can lead to better outcomes for both mothers and their children. Supporting women in a meaningful way can break the cycle instead of perpetuating it.
**Editor:** You shared that conditions for women prisoners have deteriorated over the years. Can you speak to that issue?
**Gillian:** When I was incarcerated, there was much more focus on individual care in the Dóchas Centre, but now overcrowding is a significant problem. Women are crammed into cells meant for fewer people, diminishing the chances for rehabilitation and recovery. We need to prioritize humane treatment and sufficient resources.
**Editor:** What message do you hope to send to policymakers regarding this topic?
**Gillian:** The message is clear: if we support rather than punish, we can create positive change. It’s time to critically assess the impact of our current punitive approaches and invest in comprehensive strategies that help women reclaim their lives for themselves and their children.
**Editor:** Thank you, Gillian, for sharing your story and advocating for such important changes. Your insights provide a lot of food for thought on the impact of our justice system on families and future generations.
**Gillian:** Thank you for having me! It’s essential to keep this conversation going for the sake of the women and children affected by these issues.
**Editor:** Welcome, Gillian! Thank you for joining us today to share your insights on the impact of sending young mothers to prison. You have a powerful story that highlights critical issues within the criminal justice system. Can you start by telling us about your experience?
**Gillian:** Thank you for having me! I spent four months in prison. When I got out, I was homeless, and my children were in the care of Tusla. It was a devastating situation, and it made me realize how the system fails not only women but also their families.
**Editor:** That sounds incredibly difficult. You’ve mentioned that imprisoning young mothers could be creating the next generation of drug users. Can you elaborate on that?
**Gillian:** Absolutely. When mothers are incarcerated, it affects their children deeply—often leading to trauma, instability, and even homelessness. Many of these children end up struggling with similar issues as their parents, including substance abuse. If we don’t address this cycle now, we risk replicating the same problems in future generations.
**Editor:** It’s clear you believe the approach to dealing with women’s offenses needs to change. What do you advocate instead?
**Gillian:** I believe we need to refunnel resources into support systems, not punishment. Social programs that truly address the root causes of crime—such as addiction, mental health, and trauma—can lead to better outcomes for both mothers and their children. Investing in these areas could help break the cycle of incarceration and create healthier family dynamics.
**Editor:** You also pointed out the overcrowding in women’s facilities. How does this impact the rehabilitation prospects for women in prison?
**Gillian:** The overcrowding in facilities like the Dóchas Centre is a huge concern. Initially, there was a focus on giving each woman her own space, but now they are crammed together, which is not conducive to rehabilitation. When women can’t find proper support or a safe environment, it’s nearly impossible for them to work on the issues that led to their incarceration.
**Editor:** What would you say to policymakers about the current state of the criminal justice system for women?
**Gillian:** I would urge them to critically assess how their policies affect women and their families. Short prison sentences are not the solution; they often don’t provide enough time for meaningful rehabilitation. If we support rather than punish, the outcomes could be very different.
**Editor:** Thank you, Gillian, for sharing your thoughts and experience with us. It’s essential to bring these issues to light to advocate for change in the system.
**Gillian:** Thank you for having me! It’s vital that we continue this conversation.
