Portnikov emphasised that there can’t be any “partnership” between Ukraine and the Russian Federation
photograph from open sources
Portnikov: “The historical past of Russia and the historical past of Ukraine are the histories of two completely different international locations, on completely different continents in Europe”
Social networks are actively discussing the Feygin Stay broadcast and YouTube channels, the place Ukrainian journalist Vitaly Portnikov mentioned with Russian publicist Yulia Latynina. Specifically, Portnikov fully destroyed all makes an attempt of Latinina to show that Ukrainians and Russians as soon as constructed an empire collectively, and Ukrainians had been allegedly not oppressed in it.
The defeat of the Russian journalist
The subject of the printed was a dialogue regarding Russia’s imperial heritage, whereas Latynina acknowledged that Ukraine mustn’t painting Russians as “genetic imperialists” for “navy propaganda”. In response, Portnikov emphasised that solely ethnic Ukrainians might participate within the development of the Russian Empire, who “renounced their very own identification and accepted another person’s, comparatively talking, Moscow, following which Russian nationwide identification.”
“And people Ukrainians who weren’t prepared for such actions had been all the time enemies of this empire, all the time persecuted and despised by it. And this is applicable not solely to Ukrainians,” emphasised the Ukrainian journalist, recalling the persecution of representatives of the Jewish folks.
Portnikov recalled the destruction of Baturin in the course of the time of Peter I, the horrible occasions in Buch in the course of the present full-scale warfare. He famous that there can’t be any “partnership”: “The historical past of Russia and the historical past of Ukraine are the histories of two completely different international locations, on completely different continents in Europe.”
The response of social networks
Historian, head of the Ukrainian Institute of Nationwide Remembrance in 2014-2019, Individuals’s Deputy of Ukraine Volodymyr Vyatrovych delighted from “battle”: “When a Ukrainian athlete defeats a Russian athlete, Ukrainians applaud. When a Ukrainian mental enters right into a dispute with a Russian one, he’s condemned. Vitaly Portnikov completely demonstrated that Russians can and ought to be smeared not solely on sports activities grounds.”
Journalist Vitaly Chervonenko emphasisedthat the dialogue between Portnikov and Latynina confirmed the pondering and understanding of Ukraine “even by the kind of progressive Russian intelligentsia.”
“When Russians learn one thing a bit basically, they already turn out to be sturdy specialists and assume they’ve figured it out. Latynina’s theses are actually an exquisite imperial narrative – they gave you the chance to turn out to be janissaries and glorify Moscow, how dangerous the empire was. The dialogue in regards to the nearly good Russian empire and the Austrian one, which isn’t superb for Ukrainians, is totally ridiculous,” he stated in his submit.
Ex-adviser of the President’s Workplace, Oleksiy Arestovych, as properly reacted for dialogue He known as Portnikov “an mental mass that implements the ideological attitudes of a sure a part of the viewers”, criticized Feigin, however praised Latynina.
Even the Russians are in shock
It’s noteworthy that even Russians are ashamed of the statements Latynina superior in the course of the dialogue. Of their feedback, they name her a “manipulator” and need Ukraine a speedy victory:
We’ll remind, in keeping with Ukrainian publicist, author, journalist Vitaly Portnikov, we should always not hope that ideology will change in Russia, as a result of the Russian folks don’t see the necessity for any modifications. As Portnikov says, the Russians might change their views solely in a single case – if the enemy military entered Moscow, as enemy armies entered Berlin.
Learn additionally: Portnikov advised how the Russian authorities will clarify their defeat in opposition to Ukraine to their residents
