Poland’s Border Crisis: A Test of Security and Stability
Table of Contents
In the midst of Europe’s largest land conflict in decades, Poland’s border with Belarus has become a focal point of tension, showcasing the complexities of safeguarding the european Union’s values and territorial integrity.
With over 13,000 border guards and soldiers deployed along a 400-kilometer (250-mile) stretch,the Poland-Belarus border has transformed into a critical buffer zone. This heightened security comes in response to Belarus’ alliance with Russia, wich has used the country as a launchpad for its invasion of Ukraine.Similar fortifications can be seen along Poland’s northern border with Russia’s Kaliningrad region.
Poland plays a pivotal role as Ukraine’s primary logistical supporter. The majority of Western-supplied weapons and equipment destined for Ukraine pass through Polish territory. Meanwhile, Russia’s use of belarus as a staging area has further strained relations between the neighboring nations.
At the border near Połowce, a 5.5-meter (18-foot) steel barrier adorned with razor wire and surveillance cameras stands as a stark reminder of the once-friendly ties now fractured by war. Drones,helicopters,and armored vehicles patrol the area,ensuring constant vigilance.
On January 16, the Polish EU presidency invited 60 international journalists to observe the security measures firsthand. The scene was marked by concrete obstacles, concertina wire, and a closed border crossing. Polish officials argue that these measures are essential to counter what they describe as a hybrid warfare tactic by Russia and Belarus, aimed at destabilizing Poland and the EU.
“We have tightened our visa policy, and above all we have decided to suspend the right to asylum wherever we are dealing with mass border crossings organized by Belarus and Russia,” said Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk during a press briefing.
The situation escalated in 2023, with nearly 30,000 attempted border crossings reported.Most of those attempting to cross are young men from Ethiopia, Eritrea, and Somalia. According to Polish authorities, these individuals often arrive in Belarus on tourist or student visas and are then facilitated to cross the border for fees ranging from $8,000 to $12,000.
polish officials claim that belarusian security services and other organizers assist these migrants,frequently enough recruiting Ukrainians who have fled their war-torn homeland. These individuals reportedly earn $500 for every migrant they help cross the border.
Border guards frequently face violent encounters, with migrants allegedly using slingshots, small explosives, rocks, and pepper spray. Over 400 such incidents were recorded last year,resulting in the hospitalization of 307 individuals. Tragically, one border guard lost his life, and several others were injured.
as one official noted, the actions of these groups are “very unpredictable, and very precise and coordinated,” highlighting the challenges faced by Polish forces.
Amid these tensions, organizations like Doctors Without Borders have offered alternative perspectives, emphasizing the humanitarian dimensions of the crisis and the plight of those caught in the crossfire.
As Poland continues to navigate this complex and volatile situation, the border with Belarus remains a critical test of the EU’s ability to uphold its security and values in an increasingly uncertain world.
The Human Cost of Europe’s Border Policies
As 2021, nearly 9,000 cases of what humanitarian organizations call “violent pushbacks” have been reported along Europe’s eastern borders. these practices, which involve denying individuals the right to seek asylum, are in clear violation of international law. Yet, for Polish authorities, the issue is framed differently. Maciej Duszczyk, Poland’s Undersecretary of State, insists on using the term ”turnbacks” instead, arguing that migrants must apply for asylum at designated border points rather than attempting to cross illegally.
The Reality on the Ground
The border town of Połowce has become a focal point in this debate. Last year, only 670 asylum applications were filed there, and by mid-January, that number had dropped to zero. The government attributes this decline to its strict border policies,which include plans to suspend asylum applications during perceived crises. A proposed law, currently under parliamentary review, would allow Poland to close its borders for up to 60 days if officials suspect migrants are being used as a “weapon” by neighboring countries.
“If anyone uses violence against the border guards, we close the border,” Duszczyk stated.
However, human rights organizations warn that such measures could have devastating consequences. Doctors Without Borders has urged Poland to reconsider its approach, emphasizing the need to protect migrants and refugees. “This could have dramatic consequences,” the institution warned, calling for a “drastic change of course.”
the Political Dimension
The debate over border security is deeply intertwined with politics.Poland’s Prime minister, Donald Tusk, has framed strict migration policies as essential to national security and a way to counter the rise of populism. “If we do not want to hand over these matters to radicals,extremists,populists,we must find the right answers so that no one in the world doubts that democratic states are able to effectively defend themselves against illegal migration,” he said.
Tusk’s stance reflects a broader trend across Europe. Following recent elections, the European Union has seen a shift toward nationalist and populist policies, particularly in France and Germany. Tusk has described border protection as a “sacred duty,” a sentiment echoed by Hungary’s Prime Minister, Viktor Orbán.
the Human Toll
Behind the politics lies a stark human reality. Migrants attempting to cross into Poland often face harrowing conditions. since late 2022,aid organizations have treated over 400 individuals stranded in forests along the border,many suffering from exhaustion,hypothermia,and dehydration. Reports of physical assaults, including bruises and dog bites, have also surged.
“Many of them have been stranded for weeks in uninhabitable forests and exposed to violent practices at the border,” one charity reported.
Despite these accounts, verifying the situation on the ground remains challenging. The border area is heavily restricted, with NGOs and media requiring special permits to access it. even international agencies working with migrants are excluded, though they provide contact details for migrants to file complaints independently.
Looking Ahead
As Poland and other EU countries continue to tighten their borders, the human cost of these policies cannot be ignored. While governments argue that such measures are necessary to maintain security, critics warn that they risk violating fundamental human rights. The coming months will test weather Europe can strike a balance between protecting its borders and upholding its humanitarian obligations.
How do Poland’s border control measures align with international law and EU values?
Interview with Dr. Katarzyna Nowak, International Security Analyst and Migration Expert
Conducted by Anna kowalska, Archyde News Editor
Anna Kowalska: Dr. Nowak, thank you for joining us today. Poland’s border with Belarus has become a flashpoint in Europe’s ongoing security and migration crisis. Can you provide some context for our readers on the current situation?
Dr. Katarzyna Nowak: Thank you for having me, Anna.The situation at the Poland-belarus border is a complex interplay of geopolitical strategy, migration flows, and humanitarian concerns.Since 2021, Belarus, with Russian backing, has been accused of orchestrating irregular migration flows towards the EU, notably through Poland. This is seen as a form of hybrid warfare—a tactic aimed at destabilizing EU member states by overwhelming their borders and straining their resources.
Anna Kowalska: Polish authorities describe these border crossings as coordinated and well-organized. What evidence supports this claim?
Dr. Katarzyna Nowak: Polish officials have documented several patterns that suggest a high level of organization. Migrants, primarily young men from Africa and the Middle East, arrive in Belarus on tourist or student visas. They are then reportedly facilitated by Belarusian security services and other intermediaries to cross the border illegally. The fees for this service range from $8,000 to $12,000 per person. Additionally, there have been reports of Ukrainians, displaced by the war, being recruited to assist in these crossings for a fee of $500 per migrant. These operations are marked by a degree of precision and coordination that points to state-sponsored facilitation.
Anna Kowalska: The situation has led to violent encounters between migrants and Polish border guards. Can you elaborate on the challenges faced by those on the frontlines?
Dr. Katarzyna Nowak: The violence is a tragic and escalating aspect of this crisis. Border guards have faced attacks involving slingshots, small explosives, rocks, and pepper spray. Over 400 such incidents were recorded last year, resulting in the hospitalization of 307 individuals. Tragically, one border guard lost his life. These confrontations highlight the desperation of those attempting to cross and the immense pressure on Polish forces to maintain security. As one official noted, the actions of these groups are “very unpredictable, and very precise and coordinated,” which makes the task of border guards even more challenging.
Anna Kowalska: Poland has tightened its visa policies and suspended the right to asylum in cases of mass border crossings. How do these measures align with international law and EU values?
Dr. Katarzyna Nowak: This is a contentious issue. International law,including the 1951 Refugee Convention,guarantees the right to seek asylum. However,Poland and other EU countries argue that the current situation represents an abuse of this system,orchestrated by external actors to create instability. While they frame their actions as “turnbacks” rather than “pushbacks,” humanitarian organizations view these measures as violations of asylum seekers’ rights. It’s a delicate balance between upholding security and respecting humanitarian obligations.
Anna Kowalska: Organizations like Doctors Without Borders have emphasized the humanitarian dimensions of this crisis. What are the key humanitarian concerns at the border?
Dr. Katarzyna Nowak: The humanitarian concerns are profound. Migrants often find themselves trapped in a geopolitical tug-of-war, facing harsh conditions, violence, and extreme weather. Many have already fled conflict or persecution in their home countries, only to encounter further hardship at the border. Organizations like doctors Without Borders highlight the urgent need for medical care, shelter, and protection for these individuals. The crisis underscores the importance of addressing both the immediate needs of migrants and the root causes of their displacement.
Anna Kowalska: Looking ahead, what steps could be taken to de-escalate the situation and address the underlying issues?
Dr. Katarzyna Nowak: A multi-faceted approach is essential. First, there needs to be greater international pressure on Belarus and Russia to cease their destabilizing actions. Second, the EU must work towards a more unified and humane migration policy that balances security with humanitarian obligations.Third, addressing the root causes of migration—such as conflict, poverty, and climate change—requires long-term investment and cooperation with countries of origin.dialog and transparency between all stakeholders, including governments, NGOs, and affected communities, are crucial to finding enduring solutions.
Anna Kowalska: Dr. Nowak,thank you for your insightful analysis.The situation at Poland’s border with Belarus is undoubtedly a critical test of the EU’s ability to navigate complex security and humanitarian challenges.
dr. Katarzyna Nowak: Thank you, Anna. it’s a complex and evolving issue,and I hope that through continued dialogue and cooperation,we can find a way forward that upholds both security and human dignity.
