2024-09-12 17:16:32
ÖVP and Greens spoke today in the Budget Committee for the postponement of its motion for a resolution concerning budgetary means for Austria‘s participation in the European Sky Shield air defence initiative. Specifically, according to the motion for a resolution, budgetary authorization should be created to justify the pre-existing costs for the necessary purchases of air defence systems (4145/A(E)).
The ÖVP and the Greens stated that, in their view, joining Sky Shield did not constitute a military alliance, contrary to the criticism of the FPÖ, and did not see this as a contradiction to Austria’s neutrality. The Greens justified the postponement by saying that they did not want to anticipate these far-reaching budgetary measures on this issue so close to the election.
Debate on compatibility with neutrality
Jakob Schwarz (Greens) was convinced that monitoring European airspace for defense purposes was only possible in cooperation with European partners. Joining Sky Shield would not lead to operational activities. Nevertheless, justifying pre-existing burdens so close to the election would be looking too far into the future, said Schwarz. Friedrich Ofenauer (ÖVP) did not see the defense initiative as a military alliance, but rather a procurement initiative. It was a fact that joining would not contradict Austria’s neutrality. The purchases were important to protect Austria and its population.
In contrast, Volker Reifenberger (FPÖ) cited reports that clearly state that accession is incompatible with Austria’s neutrality. He called for an immediate halt to Austria’s participation and the continuation of Austria’s independent defense. He interpreted the postponement as meaning that the FPÖ’s political pressure on this issue was having an effect. Reifenberger agreed with Christoph Matznetter (SPÖ) that the Defense Minister was lacking documents and information. Matznetter took the view that the matter must be prepared with great care and that all the facts must be on the table. Only then can a report be drawn up on whether there has been a violation of neutrality, he said to the FPÖ. In his view, it is currently “a good decision not to make one.”
According to the application, in July 2023 Austria signed a letter of intent to participate in the European Sky Shield Initiative. The aim is to strengthen the air defense of the participating European states against attacks from the air by projectiles, missiles or aircraft. The project to set up a coordinated air defense system for the European states was created against the backdrop of the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine.
Currently, 19 states have signed a declaration of intent to participate in this European initiative, according to the motion for a resolution. Austria intends to participate in joint procurement and training measures, but not in operational measures. Measures that could be interpreted as participation in a military alliance or as allowing bases on Austrian territory are expressly excluded. Overall, the declaration explicitly excludes any measure that would conflict with Austrian neutrality.
Crisis measures continue to place a high budget burden
In addition, the members of the Budget Committee discussed the ongoing budget implementation. According to Parliament’s budget service, this is characterized by a persistently difficult economic environment and a declining but still high budgetary burden due to crisis measures. The delayed effect of high inflation on some areas of expenditure such as pensions and personnel costs as well as the priorities set in the context of budget preparation and the new financial equalization are leading to a sharp increase in payments. On the payment side, the higher wage bill is leading to additional payments, but overall the economic environment is dampening the development of payments.
At the end of July 2024, for example, the federal government’s net financing balance (the deficit) was -15.8 billion Ꞓ. This is 7.4 billion Ꞓ more negative than in the previous year, the Finance Ministry reports in its monthly updates to the Budget Committee. As far as the budget path according to the federal estimate is concerned, Finance Minister Magnus Brunner stated in the committee that this would be adhered to despite the challenging economic situation.
The majority of the ÖVP and the Greens took note of the monthly results for May to July 2024 (168/BA, 167/BA, 163/BA) as well as the report on overspending and previous burdens in the second quarter of 2024 (164/BA). The majority of the ÖVP and the Greens also took note of reports for the second quarter of 2024 on the measures taken within the framework of the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) (165/BA) and on the measures to stabilize the balance of payments (166/BA). (Continuation of the Budget Committee) mbu
NOTE: The Parliamentary Budget Service offers economic analyses of budget policy and documents from the Federal Ministry of Finance. All current data on budget implementation (monthly reports) can be found on the Ministry of Finance website.
1726162157
#Budget #Committee #ÖVP #Greens #postponed #resolution #Sky #Shield
Neutral Swiss Ramble
Table of Contents
European Sky Shield Initiative: Strengthening Air Defense in Europe
In a significant move to bolster air defense capabilities, 19 European countries, including Austria, Switzerland, and Italy, have signed a declaration of intent to participate in the European Sky Shield Initiative (ESSI) [[2]]. This collaborative effort aims to create a coordinated air defense system to protect European airspace from aerial attacks, such as projectiles, missiles, or aircraft.
Background
The ESSI was launched in response to the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine, highlighting the need for European countries to strengthen their air defense capabilities. The project is designed to promote cooperation among participating countries, enhancing their collective security and fostering a more cohesive defense strategy.
Austria’s Participation
Austria signed a letter of intent to participate in the ESSI in July 2023 [[1]]. The country intends to engage in joint procurement and training measures, but not in operational activities. The agreement explicitly excludes any measures that would conflict with Austria’s neutrality. In a recent Budget Committee meeting, the ÖVP and Greens parties postponed a motion for a resolution concerning budgetary means for Austria’s participation in the ESSI, citing concerns about the timing of budget decisions ahead of elections.
Debate on Neutrality
The participation of Austria in the ESSI has sparked a debate on the compatibility of this initiative with the country’s neutrality. The ÖVP and Greens argue that joining the ESSI does not constitute a military alliance and does not contradict Austria’s neutrality. In contrast, the FPÖ has expressed concerns that the initiative is incompatible with Austria’s neutrality, citing reports that support this view.
Switzerland and Italy Also On Board
Switzerland and Austria have signed a declaration of intent to join the European air defense system Sky Shield [[1]]. Italy, too, has expressed its interest in participating in the ESSI, recognizing the importance of strengthening European air defense capabilities [[2]].
Budget Implications
The ongoing budget implementation discussions in Austria have highlighted the persistently difficult economic environment and the high budgetary burden of crisis measures. The delayed effect of high inflation on certain expenditure areas, such as pensions and personnel costs, has led to a sharp increase in payments. Despite these challenges, the Finance Minister has assured that the budget path will be adhered to.
Conclusion
The European Sky Shield Initiative is a significant step forward in promoting European air defense cooperation. As more countries join the initiative, the collective security of European nations will be enhanced. The debates surrounding Austria’s participation in the ESSI highlight the importance of carefully considering the implications of such initiatives on national neutrality. Nevertheless, the ESSI represents a crucial effort to strengthen European air defense capabilities in the face of emerging security threats.
How does Austria’s participation in the European Sky Shield Initiative align with its long-standing policy of neutrality?
Austria’s Participation in European Sky Shield Initiative Sparks Debate on Neutrality
In a recent meeting of the Austrian Budget Committee, the ÖVP and Greens pushed for the postponement of a motion for a resolution concerning budgetary means for Austria’s participation in the European Sky Shield air defense initiative. The motion aims to create budgetary authorization to justify the pre-existing costs for the necessary purchases of air defense systems (4145/A(E)) [[1]].
The ÖVP and Greens argued that joining Sky Shield did not constitute a military alliance and did not see it as a contradiction to Austria’s neutrality [[1]]. Jakob Schwarz (Greens) emphasized that monitoring European airspace for defense purposes was only possible in cooperation with European partners, and joining Sky Shield would not lead to operational activities. Friedrich Ofenauer (ÖVP) added that the defense initiative was a procurement initiative, and joining would not contradict Austria’s neutrality.
On the other hand, Volker Reifenberger (FPÖ) cited reports stating that accession was incompatible with Austria’s neutrality and called for an immediate halt to Austria’s participation and the continuation of Austria’s independent defense [[1]]. He argued that the postponement was a result of the FPÖ’s political pressure on this issue.
In July 2023, Austria signed a letter of intent to participate in the European Sky Shield Initiative, which aims to strengthen the air defense of participating European states against attacks from the air by projectiles, missiles or aircraft [[2]][[3]]. The project was created against the backdrop of the Russian war of aggression against Ukraine. Currently, 19 states have signed a declaration of intent to participate in this European initiative [[1]].
Austria intends to participate in joint procurement and training measures but not in operational measures. Measures that could be interpreted as participation in a military alliance or as allowing bases on Austrian territory are expressly excluded. The declaration explicitly excludes any measure that would conflict with Austrian neutrality [[1]].
The debate on Austria’s participation in Sky Shield has sparked a larger discussion on the country’s neutrality and its role in European defense initiatives. While some argue that joining Sky Shield would not compromise Austria’s neutrality, others believe it would be a contradiction to the country’s long-standing policy.
In addition to the debate on Sky Shield, the Budget Committee also discussed the ongoing budget implementation, which is characterized by a persistently difficult economic environment and a declining but still high budgetary burden due to crisis measures [[1]]. The committee will continue to monitor the budget implementation and make decisions on Austria’s participation in the European Sky Shield Initiative.
References:
