The trial developed in New York on the nationalization of YPF reached a negative resolution for the State, which must now pay compensation of between US$3.5 billion and US$17 billion. With the adverse result, the treatment that Congress gave to the initiative in 2012 was called into question.
Following the impulse of Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, the initiative had 208 affirmative votes in Deputies and 63 affirmative in the Senate. The project was approved after a marathon session in the lower house, on May 3 of that year it was approved in both chambers.
Although the initiative was approved mainly by pro-government legislators, there were also opposition leaders who accompanied the document that the then front for victory had sent to Congress.
Among the pro-government supporters who raised their hands on that occasion are Diana Conti, Carlos Heller, Andrés Larroque, Facundo Moyano, Mayra Mendoza, Agustín Rossi, Felipe Solá, Victoria Donda, fernando solanas, Hector Recalde, Rosana BertoneAnd till Omar Perotti.
Among the legislators who voted in the affirmative, there were many voices that today criticize Kirchnerism. Among them, Ricardo Gil Lavedra, Mario Negri, Gerardo Milman, Miguel Bazze, Ricardo Buryaile o Julio Martinezamong others.
Meanwhile, among those who voted negatively, on the other hand, were Elisa Carrió, Patricia Bullrich, Graciela Camaño, Graciela Ocaña, Jorge Triaca, Eduardo Amadeo, Alberto Asseff, Gustavo Ferrari and Laura Alonso, among others. The most notable absentees in that vote: Margarita Stolbizer, Gabriela Michetti, Oscar Aguad and Silvia Majdalani.
Meanwhile, the initiative had, a month before in the Senate, 63 affirmative votes and 3 negative. There, the initiative was approved in a session that was chaired by the then vice president Beloved Bodou.
The nationalization project was celebrated and supported by the pro-government leaders as Daniel Filmus, Hannibal Frenandez.
Meanwhile, there were also several leaders, today recognized critics of the opposition, who supported the initiative. Among others, one can mention Louis Judge, Gerardo Morales, Luis Naidenoff, Ernest Sanz, y Miguel Angel Pichettothen at the head of the leadership of the official bench.
Among the legislators who opposed the project at that time were Adolfo Rodríguez Saá, Juan Carlos Romero and Liliana Negre de Alonso.
front for victory (115) Albrieu, Oscar Edmundo Nicolás; Alonso, Maria Luz; Arena, Celia Isabel; Arregui, Andrés Roberto; Avoscan, Herman Horace; Balcedo, Maria Ester; Barrandeguy, Raúl Enrique; Basterra, Luis Eugenio; Bedano, Nora Esther; Bernal, Mary Eugenia; Bertone, Roseanne Andrea; Bianchi, Maria Del Carmen; Bidegain, Gloria Mercedes; White Of Pearl, White; Brawer, Mara; Bromberg, Isaac Benjamin; Calcagno and Maillmann, Eric; Carlotto, Gerard Rowing; Carmona, William Ramon; Caselles, Graciela Mary; Catalan Magni, Julius Caesar; Eyebrows, George Albert; Chieno, Mary Helen; Ciampini, Joseph Albert; Fox, Louis Francis George; Clery, Mark; Conti, Diana Beatriz; Cordoba, Stella Maris; Currilen, Oscar Rubén; Data, Alfredo Carlos; Of Peter, Edward Henry; Depetri, Edward Fernando; DiTullio, Juliana; Diaz Bancalari, Jose Maria; Diaz Roig, Juan Carlos; Donkin, Carlos Guillermo; Eliceche, Carlos Tomas; Elorriaga, Osvaldo Enrique; Above, Roberto José, Felix, Omar; Fernandez Sagasti, Anabel; Ferra De Bartol, Margarita Ferreyra, Araceli Susana Del Rosari; Francioni, Fabian Marcelo; Gallardo, Miriam Graciela Del Valle; Garcia Larraburu, Silvina Marcela; Garcia, Andrea Fabiana; Garcia, Maria Teresa; Gdansky, Carlos Enrique; Giaccone, Claudia Alejandra; Giacomino, Daniel Oscar; Giannettasio, Graciela Maria; González, Juan Dante; González, Nancy Susana; Pomegranates, Sweet; Grosso, Leonardo; Guccione, Joseph Daniel; Gutierrez, Monica Edith; Blacksmith, Griselda Naomi; Ianni, Hannah Mary; Kosiner, Paul Francis John; Kunkel, Charles Michael; Landau, George Alberto; Larroque, Andres; Leverberg, Stella Maris; Llanos, Ermindo Edgardo Marcelo; Lotto, Ines Beatriz; Martinez, Oscar Ariel; Mendoza, Mayra Soledad; Mendoza, Sandra Marcela; Metaza, Mario Alfredo; Mirkin, Beatriz Graciela; Mongelo, Jose Ricardo; Moreno, Carlos Julio; Moyano, Juan Facundo; Muller, Mabel Hilda; Nebreda, Carmen Rosa; Porto, Mario Nestor; Ortiz Correa, Marcia Sara Maria; Ortiz, Mariela; Country, Juan Mario; Perie, Julia Argentina; Perotti, Omar Angel; Perroni, Ana Maria; Pietragalla Corti, Horace; Pilatti Vergara, Maria Ines; Plaini, Francisco Omar; Puiggros, Adriana Victoria; Recalde, Hector Pedro; Redczuk, Oscar Felipe; Rios, Liliana Maria; Rios, Roberto Fabian; Risko, Silvia Lucrecia; Rivarola, Ruben Armando; Rivas, Jorge; Rossi, Agustin; Salim, Juan Arturo; Santillan, Walter Marcelo; Sciutto, Ruben Dario; Segarra, Adela Rosa; Simoncini, Silvia Rosa; Solanas, Julio Rodolfo; Soto, Gladys Beatriz; Tineo, Javier Hector; Tomas, Hector Daniel; Unac, Jose Ruben; Vilarino, Jose Antonio; Villa, Jose Antonio; Molina, Manuel Isauro; Yarade, Rodolfo Fernando; Yazbek, Rubén David; Yoma, Jorge Raúl; Zamarreno, Maria Eugenia; Ziebart, Cristina Isabel and Ziegler, Alex Roberto.
Ari Civic Coalition (2) Piemonte, Horace; ate, Carlos Marcelo
Federal Cordoba (1) Fortuna, Francisco Jose
Federal Thought Stream (1) Ledesma, Julio Ruben
Egalitarian and Participatory Democracy (1) Rodriguez, Marcela Virginia
civic front (12) Matarazzo, Norma Amanda; Alonso, Frederick; Brue, Augustine; Blacksmith, Joseph Albert; Martinez, Ernesto Felix; Mazzarella, Susan of the Valley; Navarro,Graciela; Oliver, Christian Rodolfo; Shepherdess, Myrtle Ameliana; Ruiz, Aida; Veaute, Mariana Alexandra; Village, Graciela.
Radical Civic Union (37) Albarracin, George Louis; Alfonsine, Richard Louis; Alvarez, Elsa Maria; Alvarez, George Mario; Barbieri, Mario Leandro; Baze, Miguel; Benedetti, Attilio Brizuela and Doria, Agnes; Buryaile, Richard; Casanas, John Francis; Chemes, George Ornar; Coast, Edward Raul; Of Ferrari Wheel, Patricia; Spindola, Gladys Susan; Fernandez, Rodoho Alfred; Fiad, Mario Raymond; Forte, Ulysses; Garrido, Manuel; Gil Lavedra, Ricardo; Giubergia, Michael Angel; Jury, Mariana; Kroneberger, Daniel Richard; Maldonado, Hugh; Martinez, Julo Cesar; Mouilleron, Robert Mario; Negri, Mario; Orsolini, Pablo Eduardo; Portela, Agustin Alberto; Rivara, Raúl Alberto; Rogel, Fabian Dulio; Sacca, Luis Fernando; Santín, Eduardo; Alone, Felipe Chaos; Storani, Maria Luisa; Tunessi, Juan Pedro; Wow, Enrique; Yague, Linda.
People’s Union (5) DeGennaro, Victor; Iturraspe, Nora Graciela; Lozano, Claudia Raúl; Stop, Liliana; Riestra, Antonio Sabino
Peronist Union (3) Mouilleron, Roberto Mario; Rivara, Raúl Alberto; Alone, Felipe
Union for San Juan (1) Ibarra, Mauricio
U.De.So. Salta (1) Biella, Bernardo Jose
Free South (1) Donda Perez, Victoria
Holy Faith in Motion (1) Forconi, Juan Carlos
GEN (3) Linares, Maria Virginia; Milman, Gerardo; Peralta, Fabian Francisco
Jump We Are All (1) Olmedo, Alfredo Horacio
South Project (3) Argumedo, Aldra Susana; Cardelli, Jorge Justo; Solanas, Fernando Ezequiel
Socialist Party (6) Barchetta, Omar; Ciciliani, Alice; Curtain,Roy; Cuccovillo, Ricardo Oscar; Rasino, Elida Elena; Zabalza, Juan Cartos
new meeting (5) Harrispe, Gaston; Heller, Charles; June, John Charles Isaac; Raimundi, Charles; Sabbatella, Martin
Peronist Front (3) and Federal (1) Atanasof, Alfredo Néstor; Cremer De Busti, Maria Cristina; Roberti, Alberto Oscar; Wayar, Walter Raul
People’s Movement (4) Shine, José Ricardo; Comelli, Alicia Marcela; Garramuno, Jorge; Guzman, Olga Elizabeth
La Pampa Justicialist Party (2) Regazzoli, Maria Cristina; Robledo, Robert
Santa Fe Federalism (1) Latorre, Roxana Itatí
civic front (2) Iturrez De Cappellini, Ada Rosa Del Valle; Judge, Luis Alfredo
Front of All (1) Roldan, Jose Maria
GEN (1) Linares, Jaime
Justicialista October 8 (1) Escudero, Sonia Margarita
Neuquén Popular Movement (1) Lords, Horace
new meeting (2) Diaz, Maria Rosa; Lopez, Osvaldo Ramon
PJ La Pampa (2) Higonet, Maria De Los Angeles; Verna, Carlos Alberto
Current Liberal Party (1) Meabe, Josefina Angelica
Salta Renewal Party (1) Perez Alsina, Juan Agustin
Socialist Party (1) Giustiniani, Ruben Hector
PJ Front for Victory (31) Aguirre, Hilda Clelia; New Ward, Walter Basil; Bermejo,; Rolando Adolphus; Biancalani, Fabio Darius; Blas, InÉS Imelda; Bongiorno, Mary Joseph; Cabral, Salvador; Colazo, Mario George; Corradi De Beltran, Anna Maria; Corrected, Elena Mercedes; De La Rose, Mary Graciela; Fellner, Liliana Beatrice; Fernandez, Hannibal; Filmus, Daniel Ferdinand; Fountains, Marcelo George; Godoy, Rupert Edward; Gonzalez, Paul G.; Guastavino, Peter William Angel; Guinle, Marcellus Alexander Horace; Irrazábal, John Manuel; Labado, Mary Esther; Leguizamon, Mary Laura; Moon, Mirtha Mary Teresa Mansilla, Sergio Francisco; Mayans, Joseph Michael Angel; Parrilli, Nancy Mary Augustine; Pichetto, Michelangelo; Persian, Daniel Rapul; Riofrio, Marina Raquel; Rojkes De; Alperovich, Beatriz Liliana; Ruiz Diaz, Elsa B.
Buenos Aires Federal Project (1) Cabanchik, Samuel Manuel
Santa Fe Federal (1) Reutemann, Carlos Alberto
Work and Dignity (1) Di Perna, Graciela Agustina
Radical Civic Union (14) Artaza, Eugenio Justiniano; Borello, Martha; Cano, Jose Manuel; Cimadevilla, Mario Jorge; Marine, Juan Carlos; Martinez, Alfredo Anselmo; Montero, Laura Gisela; Morales, Gerardo; Nikisch, Roy Abelardo; Petcoff Naidenoff, Luis Carlos Rached, Emilio Alberto; Sanz, Ernesto Ricardo; Vera, Arturo; Verani, Pablo
THE NATION