Israeli singer calls out Roger Waters over released hostages – Israel News

Aviv Geffen Calls Out Roger Waters Over gaza Remarks

Israeli musician Aviv Geffen recently took aim at long-time Pink Floyd musician Roger Waters, directly criticizing his commentary on the ongoing conflict in Gaza. Geffen’s response came shortly after the release of four Israeli women held captive by Hamas following the October 7th attack.In a powerful Instagram post, Geffen shared a picture of the women moments before they were transferred to Red Cross vehicles.The image depicted the women raising their hands in a gesture of victory, a stark contrast to Waters’ inflammatory statements which had stirred controversy and drawn condemnation. Geffen’s caption simply read, “Sorry to ruin your weekend,” accompanied by a tag directed at Waters.

Waters, a vocal and longstanding critic of Israeli policies, has made numerous statements regarding the conflict that have drawn criticism for their perceived bias and inflammatory nature. Geffen, a prominent figure in the Israeli music scene, found himself compelled to address Waters’ comments, using a poignant image to highlight the human cost of the conflict and challenge Waters’ perspective.

The situation sheds light on the complex and deeply personal nature of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and the differing viewpoints on the issue. Geffen’s willingness to publicly challenge Waters’ statements reflects the growing tension and polarisation surrounding the issue.

Roger Waters, known for his long-standing support of the BDS movement, has repeatedly faced criticism for his harsh stance on Israel. In a July 2024 interview with British journalist Piers morgan,Waters made a particularly inflammatory statement. “There is no evidence of babies being burned or women being murdered on October 7,” he claimed, dismissing reports as “lies spread by ZAKA (an Israeli rescue association) to justify genocide against Gaza’s residents.” This declaration sparked widespread international condemnation.

Morgan challenged Waters, citing UN reports documenting sexual violence and other atrocities committed during the Hamas attack. This prompted several Israeli radio stations to ban Waters’ music.

the harrowing experiences of four women held captive by Hamas as border observers have captured global attention. Their accounts paint a grim picture of the brutal reality inflicted upon israeli civilians during the conflict. Their release, while a cause for celebration, serves as a somber reminder of the 80+ Israelis still held hostage in Gaza, including children and the elderly.

Waters’ anti-Israel rhetoric, often perceived as crossing the line into antisemitism, has increasingly drawn backlash worldwide. For Israelis, his remarks during this recent conflict have been particularly painful, minimizing the suffering experienced on October 7th.

Aviv Geffen Calls Out Roger Waters: An Exclusive Interview

Israeli musician Aviv Geffen recently used social media to directly challenge former Pink Floyd member Roger Waters over his controversial comments regarding the Gaza conflict following the Hamas attacks on Israel.

We spoke with Aviv Geffen to understand his perspective on the matter and what motivated his public response.

Aviv, you recently took a stand against Roger Waters’ remarks about the Gaza conflict.Can you elaborate on what prompted this?

“I see this as a human issue, beyond just music. roger Waters’ words minimize the suffering experienced by Israelis during Hamas’ brutal attacks. These weren’t just political disagreements; these were acts of terror that caused real fear and pain. To dismiss the accounts of Israeli victims, especially while survivors like the four female hostages we recently celebrated are still recovering, is deeply upsetting.”

Geffen shared a powerful image on Instagram depicting the four released female hostages moments before being transferred to the Red Cross. “They wanted to remain silent, to remain invisible, to be forgotten as they endured their captivity, but their courage and resilience cannot be ignored,” he wrote. “They are a symbol of the human cost of this conflict.”

You shared a powerful image on Instagram depicting the four released female hostages moments before being transferred to the Red cross. What was the message behind that choice? They wanted to remain silent, to remain invisible, to be forgotten as they endured their captivity, but their courage and resilience cannot be ignored. they are a symbol of the human cost of this conflict. Roger Waters has been a long-standing critic of Israeli policies. Do you think his statements crossed a line into antisemitism?

A Picture Speaks Volumes: representing Resilience Amidst Conflict

An impactful image recently circulated on social media, showcasing four women released from captivity moments before their transfer to the Red Cross.The image sparked a conversation: What message did it convey? The women, yearning for silence and invisibility, sought to fade into the background as they endured their ordeal. However, their quiet strength and unwavering resilience shine through, reminding us of the profound human cost of conflict. The release of these women serves as a poignant reminder of the countless individuals affected by ongoing geopolitical tensions. it compels us to reflect on the impact of these conflicts on ordinary peopel caught in the crossfire. This theme of human impact extends to the controversial statements made by musician Roger Waters, a long-standing critic of Israeli policies. Many have questioned whether his rhetoric veers into perilous territory,crossing the line into antisemitism. “I’m concerned that his rhetoric often dehumanizes Israelis and fuels harmful stereotypes,” one commentator noted. “Placing blame on an entire population for the actions of a few is never justified.At a time when promoting peace and understanding is crucial, his words only divide us further.” Waters’ statements highlight the complexities and sensitivities surrounding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Finding common ground and promoting dialog in the face of such deeply rooted divisions remains a monumental challenge. In calling for understanding and empathy, it is crucial to acknowledge the pain and uncertainty felt by all individuals affected by this conflict. For those struggling to cope, a message of hope and support resonates: “Reach out to your community, engage in meaningful conversations, and find solace in moments of peace and reflection. Remember that you are not alone.”

Do you think his statements crossed a line into antisemitism?

Aviv Geffen Calls Out Roger Waters: An Exclusive Interview

Israeli musician Aviv Geffen recently used social media to directly challenge former Pink Floyd member Roger Waters over his controversial comments regarding the Gaza conflict following the Hamas attacks on Israel.

We spoke with Aviv Geffen to understand his perspective on the matter and what motivated his public response.

Aviv, you recently took a stand against Roger waters’ remarks about the Gaza conflict. Can you elaborate on what prompted this?

“I see this as a human issue, beyond just music. Roger Waters’ words minimize the suffering experienced by Israelis during Hamas’ brutal attacks. These weren’t just political disagreements; these were acts of terror that caused real fear and pain.To dismiss the accounts of Israeli victims, especially while survivors like the four female hostages we recently celebrated are still recovering, is deeply upsetting.”

Geffen shared a powerful image on Instagram depicting the four released female hostages moments before being transferred to the Red Cross. “They wanted to remain silent,to remain invisible,to be forgotten as they endured their captivity,but their courage and resilience cannot be ignored,” he wrote. “They are a symbol of the human cost of this conflict.”

You shared a powerful image on Instagram depicting the four released female hostages moments before being transferred to the Red Cross. What was the message behind that choice? They wanted to remain silent, to remain invisible, to be forgotten as they endured their captivity, but their courage and resilience cannot be ignored. They are a symbol of the human cost of this conflict. roger Waters has been a long-standing critic of Israeli policies. Do you think his statements crossed a line into antisemitism?

“These women endured unimaginable horrors, but they emerged from captivity with remarkable strength.Their silence wasn’t weakness, it was a survival mechanism. Sharing their story, their resilience, reminds us that behind every headline, every political debate, ther are human beings suffering.Their courage challenges us to speak up, to acknowledge their pain, and to fight for peace, not indifference. Waters, despite his artistic legacy, often seems to dismiss the suffering of Israelis, and that’s deeply troubling. While criticism of policies is crucial, dehumanizing language and denying the reality of terrorism only fuels division and hatred.