Flames and smoke rise in an area targeted by an Israeli air strike on Beirut‘s southern suburbs, on October 6.
We were preparing to go live on air when the first airstrike hit the southern suburbs of Beirut shortly after 11 p.m. Saturday – kicking off a night of intense and constant Israeli strikes.
About 30 minutes earlier, I had been sat with a young woman who lives in the southern suburbs, when our phones flashed with a post on X. It was from the Arabic-language spokesman for the Israel Defense Forces, issuing new evacuation orders for several neighborhoods ahead of what he said would be strikes on Hezbollah targets.
The woman gasped. Her family’s home was within one of the evacuation zones. Like many residents of one of the most densely populated parts of the country, she had fled her home as Israeli strikes intensified in recent days, leaving with very little.
Hours earlier she had wanted to go back home to grab some warm clothes, as winter is approaching. But even during the day a return to the suburbs would have been dangerous, so she decided to take the advice of colleagues and not return home. And as feared, there were multiple strikes with no prior warning.
Saturday night’s strikes were among the most sustained and intense I have witnessed hitting the southern suburbs since this war began. First we heard rumbling sounds, followed by flashes in the distance. Then we heard the blasts. At least two of the strikes triggered what appeared to be secondary explosions – balls of fire that at times would light the night sky, accompanied by blasts that echoed across the city.
Amid the explosions came another evacuation order and another IDF post on X saying it is “currently targeting Hezbollah terrorist targets in the Beirut area.”
Many people I have spoken to over the past 10 days do not believe statements about “targeted” and “precise” strikes. They fear this war is going to be as destructive as the war in Gaza, that reduced much of the enclave to rubble and killed more than 41,000 people.
As I am writing this at 3:30 a.m., I hear another big blast rattle the windows of my hotel room. I can still hear the constant buzz of Israeli drones over the city – usually an indication of more strikes to come – and I can’t help but think of the people of Beirut who have been through so much for so long.
How many casualties are there? Did people evacuate in time? How are parents comforting their children during this long and terrifying night?
Is that young woman’s house still standing?
**Potential Debate Questions:**
The recent events in Beirut, particularly the escalated Israeli airstrikes, prompt critical discussions about the implications of military actions on civilian populations and the role of international responses. A potential debate question could be:
“In light of Israel’s intense airstrikes on densely populated areas in Beirut, should the international community prioritize immediate humanitarian intervention over political resolutions in conflict zones?”
This question highlights the urgent humanitarian crisis that arises from military actions, as evidenced by reports of evacuation orders and civilians fleeing their homes to escape the bombardment, often leaving behind essential belongings as they seek safety [1[1[1[1[1[1[1[1]; [3[3[3[3[3[3[3[3]. It also invites discussion on whether military operations can ever be justified when they disproportionately affect civilian lives, particularly in such densely populated regions as the southern suburbs of Beirut where the strikes have been most concentrated [2[2[2[2[2[2[2[2].
The debate could explore perspectives regarding the responsibilities of nations engaged in conflict, the ethical implications of warfare, and the potential effectiveness of humanitarian aid versus long-term political solutions in achieving sustainable peace and security in the region.
**Debate Question:** To what extent do targeted military operations, such as the recent Israeli air strikes in Beirut, prioritize civilian safety, and do the justifications provided by military officials adequately address the humanitarian impact of such actions?
Debate Question: To what extent do targeted military operations, such as the recent Israeli air strikes in Beirut, prioritize civilian safety, and do the justifications provided by military officials adequately address the humanitarian impact of such actions?
