*How I Met Your Mother‘s* Controversial Finale: A Missed Opportunity?
Many viewers were left with mixed feelings after watching the series finale of How I Met Your Mother. The final scenes, in particular, sparked heated debate among fans.
While some were satisfied with the ultimate reunion between Ted and Robin, others felt the ending ultimately undermined the emotional journey endured throughout the series.
“Honestly more so those last few minutes, it wasn’t necessarily bad that Tracy…” one fan observed, “but Ted’s kids being so apathetic and getting him to run back off to Robin again was such a slap in the face. And pretty much all because they were so insistent on not just re-recording the ‘[And] that kids, is how I met your mother’ scene because the kid actors are older now?”
This sentiment echoed the disappointment of many who felt the writers missed an opportunity to explore Ted’s growth and acceptance following Tracy’s death.
“I feel Ted could have had a whole new character arc about moving on regarding Tracy and the things he learns from that,” another fan lamented, “but I’d still rather have a cut short open ended finale than what we got in the very last few moments.”
Whether intended or not, the finale’s controversial nature reflected a broader conversation about closure and satisfying resolutions in television storytelling. Some argue that open-ended conclusions, while perhaps unexpected, can be more realistic and thought-provoking.
Others contend that viewers deserve a sense of completion, especially after investing years in emotional journeys alongside beloved characters.
Regardless of where one falls on the spectrum, the finale of How I Met Your Mother undoubtedly left a lasting impact on viewers, sparking passionate discussions and reinforcing the enduring power of television to evoke strong emotional responses, both positive and negative.
:
## How I Met Your Mother’s Controversial Finale: A Missed Opportunity?
**Host:** Welcome back to the show. Today we’re discussing the finale of the popular sitcom *How I Met Your Mother*, which continues to spark debate years after it aired. Joining us is u/Aggressive-Analyst88, a dedicated fan of the show who has some strong opinions on the controversial ending. Welcome to the show!
**u/Aggressive-Analyst88:** Thanks for having me! I’m happy to be here to talk about *HIMYM*.
**Host:** So, let’s dive right in. The finale was certainly divisive. What were your initial thoughts when you first watched it?
**u/Aggressive-Analyst88:** To be honest, I was pretty disappointed. For nine seasons, we followed Ted’s journey to find “the one,” and the show built up this incredible love story with Tracy, the Mother. To have her die and then see Ted end up with Robin felt like a betrayal of everything the show had been building towards. [[1](https://screenrant.com/how-met-mother-ending-perfect-controversial-finale-underrated/)]
**Host:** Many fans felt the same way. They felt like the writers essentially erased Tracy’s entire impact on Ted’s life and undermined the importance of their relationship.
**u/Aggressive-Analyst88:** Exactly! The writers tried to justify it by saying Ted needed to find closure with Robin, but I don’t think it worked. It felt forced and ultimately disrespectful to Tracy’s character and the audience’s investment in her story.
**Host:** Do you think there was a better way to end the series?
**u/Aggressive-Analyst88:** I believe so. The seventh-to-last episode, “How My Mother Met Me”, was actually quite brilliant. It showed Tracy’s perspective and built a genuine connection between her and Ted. Maybe the finale could have focused on their love story and shown how Ted learned to grieve Tracy while cherishing their time together.
**Host:** Interesting perspective! It seems many fans, like yourself, feel the finale missed an opportunity to truly honor the show’s core themes of love, loss, and finding your person.
**u/Aggressive-Analyst88:** Absolutely. It’s a shame because *How I Met Your Mother* had so much potential for a satisfying and emotionally resonant ending.
**Host:** Well, thanks for sharing your thoughts with us today. It’s clear that the debate surrounding the *How I Met Your Mother* finale is far from over.
**u/Aggressive-Analyst88:** Thanks for having me!
