Children’s book fuels debate about tricky topics in elementary schools
A children’s book that encourages kids to stand up for what they believe in has found itself at the center of controversy in Florida. “The Artivist,” a brightly illustrated book by Nikkolas Smith, has been called too political by some parents who want it removed from Pinellas County schools.
A Book Focused on Social Justice
“The Artivist” follows the story of a young artist who uses their creativity to fight for justice on various fronts, including advocating for transgender rights. Smith thoughtfully incorporated social issues relevant in today’s world, such as blanket “Protect trans kids” messaging and scenes depicting protests against police violence.
For some parents, the core subject matter is precisely why it shouldn’t be visible to young children.
Parental Concerns
“The Artivist” found its way to the attention of a group of parents who have lodged formal challenges with the school district. Their objections highlight their concerns about various themes explored in the book.
“Protect trans kids is the most upsetting page in my opinion,” wrote parent Jennifer Ellis in her objection form. “I will not allow my kids to be indoctrinated or for them to be curious about very controversial topics. Trans children is completely inappropriate for anyone let alone small kids.” Ellis, opting not to comment further beyond her written objection, deeming the book “filthy,” believes it has “absolutely zero” value, prompting her carcinogen to have it removed entirely.
Added Ashley Stellick, one of the four parents calling for its removal, “it will create further division in our schools“and suggested it not be allowed for any grade level.
Another parent, Tracy Mueller, felt that while the book showcased impressive artwork and contained positive messages, “the issues portrayed in this book are just not appropriate for elementary ages.”
These parents’ concerns come even though the book is meant for children ages 4 through 8 and is not part of any required curriculum.
However, the presence of the book on library shelves is testament to the ongoing debate surrounding what is appropriate reading material for younger children.
Supporting Diverse Voices and Promoting Engagement
The debate over “The Artivist” echoes similar discussions across the country as parents, educators, and policymakers grapple with the evolving landscape of children’s literature. On the opposing side are those who argue that “The Artivist” fosters crucial conversations.
“It’s disheartening that some parents think they can limit what other peoples’ children can read,” said Raegan Miller, a parent involved with the anti-censorship Florida Freedom to Read Project. “The point of the book is telling kids to stand up for what they believe in.”
She highlighted the importance of preserving the book’s message and argued against limiting children’s access to diverse perspectives.
The book’s illustrator, Nikkolas Smith, offered a simple, powerful response: “All of these things at their core are about wanting people to have freedom and equality,” he said. “It makes us laugh at how ridiculous it is that people could push back on these things. Unfortunately, not everybody has the same definition of what freedom
is, what equality is, what a better world looks like.”
The future of “The Artivist” is uncertain as Pinellas County’s review committee prepares to discuss it.
Smith remains hopeful, stating:
“The kids who read the book get itluan is what it’s all about.
What are the main arguments for and against the inclusion of “The Artivist” in elementary school curricula?
## Interview: “The Artivist” and Debate Over Social Justice in Elementary Schools
**[Host]:** Welcome back to the show. Today we’re discussing a trending story about a children’s book causing quite a stir in Florida schools. Joining us is Dr. Sarah Thompson, an education expert and author specializing in children’s literature. Dr. Thompson, thanks for being here.
**[Dr. Thompson]:** Thank you for having me.
**[Host]:** Let’s dive right in. The book “The Artivist” by Nikkolas Smith is creating controversy because it tackles sensitive topics like transgender rights and police brutality. What makes this book so different from other children’s stories?
**[Dr. Thompson]:** “The Artivist” stands out because it directly addresses contemporary social justice issues. Many children’s books focus on universal themes like friendship or kindness, but this one explicitly encourages young readers to critically engage with complex realities like inequality and activism.
**[Host]:** Some parents in Pinellas County are calling for the book’s removal from schools, arguing it’s too political and inappropriate for young children. What are your thoughts on their concerns?
**[Dr. Thompson]:** It’s understandable that parents want to protect their children from potentially challenging content. However, I believe shielding children from all difficult conversations does them a disservice. “The Artivist” doesn’t advocate for any particular political stance; it simply presents these issues in a way that encourages critical thinking and empathy.
**[Host]:** The article mentions parents objecting specifically to phrases like “Protect trans kids.” Do you think these messages are inappropriate for elementary school children?
**[Dr. Thompson]:** As an educator, I believe that fostering inclusivity and understanding from a young age is crucial. Transgender rights are human rights, and teaching children to respect and accept all individuals, regardless of their gender identity, is vital for creating a just and equitable society.
**[Host]:** Do you see this debate as part of a larger trend?
**[Dr. Thompson]:** Absolutely. We’re seeing a rise in challenges to books that deal with issues of race, gender, and social justice. This reflects a broader societal struggle over what should be taught in schools and who gets to decide. It’s a critical conversation that needs to continue.
**[Host]:** Dr. Thompson, thank you for sharing your insights on this important topic. This is certainly a debate with no easy answers, and it’s one that will likely continue.
