Ester Naomi Perquin Wins Paul Snoek Poetry Prize

Unsolicited Advice: A Poetic Exploration of National Identity and Individual Responsibility

By archyde.com News Team – April 7, 2025

A deep dive into a poem that challenges us to consider our relationship with our nation, community, and personal voice, urging a balance between belonging and critical viewpoint.

deconstructing the lines: A Journey Through the Poem

the poem,titled Unsolicited advice,presents a series of evocative directives,urging introspection on national identity,community ties,and the delicate balance between belonging and individual expression. It’s not a straightforward narrative, but rather a tapestry of images and commands, inviting the reader to actively participate in its meaning-making.

The opening lines, “Indicate the country who knows how to lie: beautiful / Under sea level, in the middle of paradise,” instantly introduce a paradox.The description of a potentially idealized nation is juxtaposed with the unsettling attribute of deception. This mirrors the often-complex relationship citizens have with their countries, acknowledging both their beauty and their flaws.

The poem then shifts to a series of imperatives: “Give it the Manken, the Blind, the Stamelaars / And slissers.The silence.” This segment encourages inclusivity, urging acceptance of those marginalized or overlooked within society. The repeated command to “give it” suggests offering empathy, understanding, and perhaps even a voice to those who are often silenced. This resonates with the ongoing discussions in the U.S. about social justice and the need to amplify marginalized voices.

The next stanza brings forth relatable human experiences: “Give it the old man who starts fishing early in the morning,/ Only to avoid his wife – we are too / That man,that woman,we are that fish too.” This introduces the theme of shared human fallibility. The poem suggests that we are all interconnected, experiencing similar struggles and desires, regardless of our background. The comparison to the “fish” evokes a sense of being caught in the currents of life, subject to forces beyond our control. This feeling is particularly relevant in today’s uncertain economic climate in the U.S., where many feel like “fish” struggling against the tide.

The poem continues with similarly potent imagery, like “Give it the woman who teaches children: take zebras on foot, / Save back when you are beaten, always take care of your dog.”, offering practical, almost folksy wisdom. This highlights the importance of community and mentorship, drawing a parallel to the critical role teachers and community leaders play in shaping future generations in the United States. The advice is a mix of resilience (“Save back when you are beaten”) and compassion (“always take care of your dog”), demonstrating a balanced approach to life. In the context of rising tuition costs in the U.S., the financial prudence advice is especially pertinent.

Further into the poem,it urges acceptance of those who are ambivalent towards their homeland,“Give it who wants to leave but can’t miss it. / who stays. Who knows boundaries, the crooked facades / And the earth.” This acknowledges the complexities of national identity, recognizing that some individuals may feel torn between their desire to leave and their enduring connection to their roots. This is especially relevant in the U.S., a nation of immigrants, where many continue to maintain ties to their countries of origin while building new lives.

The line “Break open screaming, look: there too we are, / shoulder on shoulder around the fire, growling / And hopeful.Wait. To stare.” provides a visualization of shared humanity. The image of people huddled around a fire, both “growling” and “hopeful,” captures the duality of human nature—our capacity for both aggression and optimism. The call to “wait” and “stare” suggests a need for patient observation and understanding before judgment.

The poem emphasizes giving to “who barely fits,” indicating a need to support the vulnerable and marginalized within communities. The instruction, “Look beyond the most stuck posters, ignore / The softest words, the delusions and the smile – / Give your country, your city, your time,” calls for critical engagement with society, urging readers to look beyond superficial appearances and engage with the realities of their communities. In the U.S., this translates to encouraging active participation in civic life, from volunteering at local organizations to engaging in political discourse.

The concluding lines, “But give one voice away. / Never the power,” offer a powerful statement on individual agency and the dangers of unchecked authority. They encourage the relinquishing of individual ego (“one voice away”) for the collective good, while concurrently cautioning against surrendering personal power to oppressive forces.

thematic Resonance in the American Context

This poem speaks directly to the current American socio-political landscape. With increasing polarization and debates surrounding immigration, social justice, and political power, the poem’s message of inclusivity, critical thinking, and responsible citizenship resonates deeply. The call to give a voice to the voiceless aligns with ongoing efforts to amplify marginalized perspectives in the U.S., from the Black Lives Matter movement to advocacy for LGBTQ+ rights.

The poem’s warning against surrendering “the power” is particularly relevant in an era of increasing concerns about government overreach and corporate influence in American politics.It serves as a reminder of the importance of civic engagement and vigilance in safeguarding democratic values.

Analyzing the Poem: A Framework for Understanding

Analyzing poetry, as highlighted by Lewis University, involves investigating the poem’s “content, word usage, and format to improve your understanding of a piece of poetry and it’s multiple meanings.” In the case of Unsolicited advice, it’s critical to consider the metaphorical language, the fragmented structure, and the deliberate ambiguity of the directives to fully grasp its intended message.

Understanding the layers of meaning inherent in poetry can empower readers to glean insights that transcend the literal. As Lewis University further notes, “Analyzing poetry can lead to a greater understanding of the piece’s significance, the context the piece was written in, as well as…” its enduring relevance to contemporary issues.

Practical Applications: From Personal reflection to Community Action

The poem encourages a multi-faceted approach to national identity and civic responsibility. Here are some practical applications inspired by the poem:

• Personal Reflection: Use the poem as a prompt for journaling, exploring your own relationship with your country and community.
• community Engagement: Identify local organizations that support marginalized communities and find ways to contribute your time or resources.
• Critical Media Consumption: Practice critical thinking when consuming news and media, questioning narratives and seeking diverse perspectives.
• Political Activism: Engage in informed political discourse, advocating for policies that promote inclusivity and social justice.

Counterarguments and Considerations

Some might argue that the poem’s ambiguity renders it ineffective in delivering a clear message. Critics could contend that its fragmented structure and metaphorical language obscure its meaning,making it inaccessible to a wider audience. However, the poem’s strength lies in its open-endedness, inviting readers to interpret its message in ways that resonate with their own experiences and perspectives. Its lack of specificity allows for broader request across diverse contexts.

others may find the poem overly idealistic, arguing that its call for inclusivity and social justice is unrealistic in the face of entrenched social and political inequalities. Though, the poem serves as a reminder of the values to which we should aspire, even if achieving them requires ongoing effort and struggle.

>What is the connection between the poem “Unsolicited Advice” and the challenges and realities of life in the United States, notably when considering the current economic climate?

Interview: Dr. Anya Sharma on “Unsolicited Advice” and its Relevance to American Identity

By Archyde.com news Team – April 10, 2025

A Conversation with Dr. Sharma

Welcome back to Archyde.com. Today, we’re joined by Dr.Anya Sharma, a renowned Professor of Literature and Cultural Studies at Columbia University. Dr. sharma, thank you for being with us.

Dr. Sharma: Thank you for having me. It’s a pleasure.

Deciphering “Unsolicited Advice”

Archyde.com: The poem “Unsolicited advice” has generated notable discussion. how would you describe its core message in relation to national identity and individual responsibility, particularly within the American context?

Dr. Sharma: the poem is a complex tapestry of societal commentary. On the surface, it appears to be a series of suggestions inviting introspection, however, on a deeper level, it probes the delicate balance between belonging, critical outlook, and personal agency. In America, where we celebrate diversity, the poem calls and implores on us to support marginalized groups and practice responsible citizenship. The poem is an invitation to engage, challenge, and contribute.

Inclusive Vision and Social Justice

Archyde.com: the poem seems to advocate for inclusivity, especially when it urges readers to “give it the Manken, the Blind, the Stamelaars / And slissers.” How does that particular segment of the poem resonate with the current socio-political landscape in the U.S. particularly discussions surrounding social justice?

Dr. Sharma: It’s absolutely crucial. Those lines are a poignant appeal for empathy and understanding. It is a reminder that societies flourish when they recognize the value of everybody, regardless of their perceived flaws or marginalization. This speaks directly to the ongoing efforts, such as the Black Lives Matter movement, and advocacy for LGBTQ+ rights within the U.S.,which are all aimed at amplifying the voices of those often overlooked.

The American Dream and Economic Uncertainty

Archyde.com: Certain stanzas, like the one about the old man fishing or the woman teaching children, seem to tap into the human experience. How do these segments address the challenges and realities of life, especially with the current economic climate in the United States?

Dr. Sharma: They ground the abstract in relatable human stories. It shows how we share common struggles: the man avoiding his wife; the teacher shaping young minds. The poem reminds us that individuals are the backbone of communities. The advice on resilience and financial prudence feels particularly relevant when many Americans are grappling with financial challenges. it underscores the importance of the community in guiding the next generation during economically uncertain times. this is especially true as the poem calls for us to show empathy to those who barely fit.

The Call for Critical Engagement

Archyde.com: The poem urges readers to “look beyond the most stuck posters, ignore / the softest words, the delusions and the smile.” How does this encourage a critical engagement with society and the importance of informed civic participation?

Dr. Sharma: it represents a profound call for critical thinking.It pushes us to look past superficial appearances, to challenge existing norms and challenge those that are trying to gain authority. In the context of America, it translates to the importance of informed civil engagement: participating in civic life that goes beyond simply voting. It’s about being an informed citizen, contributing to political discussions, and advocating for the causes you believe in. This relates and encourages people to participate and to care for one another, which in return, builds a stronger and more supportive community.

The Power of Voice and Authority

Archyde.com: The concluding lines, “But give one voice away. / Never the power,” are particularly striking. What is the significance of this in a society often grappling with issues of power and control?

Dr. Sharma: Those lines are a powerful statement on individual agency. It suggests the relinquishing of individual ego for the collective good. simultaneously, it is a warning regarding the dangers of surrendering personal power to oppressive forces. at the center of our democracy is the importance of responsible leadership and how voters are able to influence and shape the direction of their communities. This highlights the ongoing debate of authority and how it applies to civil duty to those in positions of leadership, the need for engagement, and the importance of safeguarding democratic values.

Reader Interaction

Archyde.com: This poem invites a critical approach in regards to national identity. What are your thoughts on how literature can impact a person’s perspective of their community or country?

Dr. Sharma: Literature,as a powerful medium,is a lens,that grants us the ability to see the world,our communities,and countries from different perspectives. The poem, “Unsolicited Advice,” allows readers to engage with the beauty of their country but also acknowledge its flaws.When literature inspires the reader to evaluate both positive and negative attributes, this is when it can truly build a strong nation.

Final Thoughts

Archyde.com: Dr. Sharma, thank you for offering invaluable insights regarding this poem. We truly appreciate it.

Dr. Sharma: Thank you for the opportunity. It’s been a pleasure.

Join the Conversation

What are your interpretations of “Unsolicited Advice” and its relevance to the American context? Share your thoughts in the comments below!