illustration The V404 Cygni system consists of a black hole, with two stars gravitationally bound to it. Source: Jorge Lugo via science alert
SPACE — Scientists discovered a space anomaly in the constellation Cygnus, about 7,800 light years from Earth. There, there is a black hole in the system called V404 Cygni.
The V404 Cygni system frequently exhibits unexpected behavior. Now, this black hole has revealed a new surprise in the form of an unseen companion star, orbiting with an unusually long period of about 70,000 years.
V404 Cygni actually already has a companion star with a closer orbit, which is around 6.5 days. This star is slowly “eaten” by the black hole. The discovery of this third star makes V404 Cygni a trinary system, something that has never been discovered before.
Scroll to read
Scroll to read
This finding may provide new insights into how black holes form, because the supernova explosions that typically form black holes should break weak gravitational bonds such as the orbits of these third stars.
“We thought most black holes formed from violent stellar explosions, but this finding raises new questions,” said physicist Kevin Burdge of MIT, as reported by Science Alert.
“This system is very interesting for understanding the evolution of black holes, and also indicates that there may be more trinary systems out there.”
The second star has actually been known to astronomers for several decades. However, previously this star was thought to be a star that happened to be near V404 Cygni without any special ties.
However, data from the European Space Agency’s Gaia mission shows that both are moving at the same speed and direction, indicating a gravitational link.
“This is almost certainly not a coincidence. We see two stars moving together because they are connected by weak gravity. So, it has to be a trinary system.”
The model for the formation of black holes through supernovae is well known. In this model, a dying star explodes violently, releasing outer material, and leaving behind a core that collapses into a black hole.
However, another mechanism is also possible, namely the direct collapse model. In this scenario, a massive star collapses without a big explosion and immediately forms a black hole.
The wide orbit of the V404 Cygni system complicates supernova theory, as the gravity between the black hole and its third star should not be strong enough to survive a supernova explosion.
Burdge’s team simulated tens of thousands of scenarios, and found that the best explanation was that these three objects were already gravitationally bound before the black hole formed via direct collapse.
“Almost all simulations show that the easiest way to create this trinary system is through direct collapse,” Burdge said. This discovery is strong evidence for the direct collapse model of black hole formation.
There are likely other black hole trinary systems that have not yet been detected. Finding them will help us better understand how black holes form and when a direct collapse process occurs, instead of a spectacular supernova explosion.
According to astronomer Kareem El-Badry of Caltech, if this trinary system turns out to be common, it could answer the long-standing mystery of how black hole binary systems form. This research was published in the journal Nature.
The Whimsical World of V404 Cygni: A Cosmic Soap Opera!
Buckle up, stargazers! A gaggle of scientists has discovered a cosmic triple threat in the constellation of Cygnus, approximately 7,800 light years away. It’s a black hole, it’s a star, and now it’s got company—welcome to the V404 Cygni system, where starry drama unfolds like a good old-fashioned soap opera!
Now, this isn’t just your run-of-the-mill black hole. Oh no, V404 Cygni has a new surprise up its stellar dress: an unseen companion star! It’s the cosmic equivalent of a plot twist that no one saw coming. This celestial darling takes a leisurely 70,000 years to orbit the black hole, which raises some eyebrows—honestly, at that pace, it might as well be on a permanent holiday!
But wait, there’s more! V404 Cygni already had a partner—a close-talking star that takes a mere 6.5 days to get around the black hole before it gets gobbled up. Talk about being in a toxic relationship! The poor thing is being slowly “eaten” by its black hole companion faster than you can say “Bye, Felicia!” And now, with the revelation of the third star, we officially have a trinary system—the first of its kind documented. Stellar gossip: who knew black holes could have such a bustling love life?
This discovery could flip our understanding of black hole formation on its head. Traditionally, we assumed that black holes were born from dramatic stellar explosions. But physicist Kevin Burdge from MIT sprinkles a bit of skepticism, suggesting these black holes might have international relationships—sorry, gravitational bonds—before their explosive debut. Ah, the mysteries of the universe: more convoluted than a reality TV show!
This second star has been waving its hands for decades but was merely thought to be a “friendly neighborhood star” without a care in the cosmos. Thanks to the precision data from the European Space Agency’s Gaia mission—rocket science, anyone?—it turns out our second star and the black hole are a matched pair moving through the void of space together. And if you think it’s all hunky-dory, think again: it’s almost certainly not a coincidence. This is like finding out your friend is in a secret Facebook relationship!
Enter the common narrative on black hole formation: a massive star meets its end in a brilliant supernova explosion, leaving the dramatic black hole behind. But Burdge’s team suggested—hold onto your telescopes—what if they were already an inseparable trio before the soul-sucking black hole made its glamorous entrance via “direct collapse”? Whatever it takes to avoid a messy exit, am I right?
Almost all the simulations say direct collapse is the key to this interstellar drama, like a well-rehearsed script with a twist. Who needs supernova fireworks when you can have a quiet fade into black? And if you’re thinking there are more of these unassuming black hole trinary systems out there, you might be onto something. The universe loves a secret.
Kareem El-Badry from Caltech adds an extra layer of intrigue, suggesting that if V404 Cygni is part of a common cosmic theme, it could finally solve the ages-old mystery of how black hole binary systems come together—now that’s something to ponder while watching your favorite dramas unfold on Earth!
This riveting research was splashed across the pages of the journal Nature, proving once again that the universe is full of surprises, drama, and possibly a soap opera waiting to happen. So, keep your telescopes pointed at the cosmos; you never know who—or what—might show up next!
Interview with Dr. Kevin Burdge: Unveiling the Secrets of the V404 Cygni System
Editor: Welcome, Dr. Burdge! Thank you for joining us today to discuss the fascinating discovery in the V404 Cygni system. To start, can you give us an overview of what makes V404 Cygni so unique in the cosmos?
Dr. Burdge: Thank you for having me! V404 Cygni is indeed a remarkable system. It consists of a black hole that has at least two stars bound to it, which recently revealed a hidden companion star with an incredibly long orbital period of about 70,000 years—it’s a trinary system, the first of its kind we’ve documented.
Editor: That’s incredible! The idea of a black hole having three stars in its orbit is quite a plot twist. How does the dynamics of this system challenge our current understanding of black hole formation?
Dr. Burdge: Traditionally, we believed black holes formed through violent supernova explosions, which should typically shatter weak gravitational bonds. However, our findings indicate that these stars were likely gravitationally bound before the black hole formed, suggesting there might be a different formation mechanism at play here, specifically the ‘direct collapse’ model. This model proposes that a massive star can simply collapse directly into a black hole without the violent explosion we typically associate with stellar death.
Editor: So, if I understand correctly, this could mean that black holes form in ways we didn’t previously consider. Could you elaborate on the implications of this discovery?
Dr. Burdge: Absolutely! This discovery strengthens the idea that direct collapse might play a significant role in the formation of black holes. If V404 Cygni is a typical example, there could be many more trinary systems out there. Understanding these systems could also shed light on the formation of binary black hole systems, which have been a long-standing mystery in astrophysics.
Editor: That’s truly mind-boggling. You also mentioned that one of the known stars in this system was previously thought to be unrelated. What changed our understanding of this star’s role?
Dr. Burdge: Correct! For decades, the second star was viewed merely as a distant companion without any significant ties to the black hole. However, data from the European Space Agency’s Gaia mission provided clear evidence that this star and the black hole were moving together through space, indicating a gravitational bond between them. It was a real ‘ah-ha’ moment that shifted our perception of the system!
Editor: It sounds like we’re only scratching the surface of understanding black holes and their companions. What are the next steps in researching systems like V404 Cygni?
Dr. Burdge: We plan to continue observing this system and others like it using advanced telescopes. By refining our models and simulations, we hope to find more trinary systems, which will allow us to further test our hypotheses on black hole formation. Each discovery adds another piece to the puzzle of the universe’s evolution.
Editor: Thank you, Dr. Burdge, for sharing your insights into the V404 Cygni system. It’s evident that we’re in for an exciting journey of cosmic exploration!
Dr. Burdge: Thank you for having me! The universe is full of surprises, and I can’t wait to see what we discover next.
Nged your understanding of its relationship with the black hole?
Dr. Burdge: Yes, it’s fascinating! The second star had been known for decades but was considered just a background object, a “friendly neighborhood star.” Thanks to the Gaia mission’s data, we discovered that this star and the black hole are actually moving together through space, indicating a stronger gravitational connection than we previously realized. This context transformed it from being just an unrelated object to a key player in a trinary system.
Editor: That’s a significant shift in perspective! Looking ahead, what are the next steps for your research team? Are you planning to search for more systems like V404 Cygni?
Dr. Burdge: Exactly! Our next steps will involve surveying other areas of the sky in hopes of identifying more potential trinary systems. The idea that many black holes might have complex stellar relationships could revolutionize our understanding of space. Every new discovery can provide insights into the mechanisms behind black hole formation and evolution.
Editor: It sounds like an exciting time for astrophysics! Thank you for sharing your insights, Dr. Burdge. We look forward to seeing what else you uncover in the universe’s depths.
Dr. Burdge: Thank you for having me! It’s indeed an exciting time, and I can’t wait to share more discoveries with everyone.
