Guatemala
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
CSJ nominator admits 1 of 32 objections against candidates
The nomination committee for the CSJ concluded its review of objections on Saturday, September 7; it rejected the majority for not complying with the previously approved parameters.
The nomination committee for the CSJ decided to reject 31 of the 32 objections against candidates. It only accepted one, against Juan Carlos Rodil Quintana, presented by Da Vinci University. (Photo Prensa Libre: Guatemala Visible)
Foto:
The nomination committee for the Supreme Court of Justice (SCJ) met this Saturday, September 7, to review 32 objections filed against candidates for one of the 13 magistrate positions.
The commissioners, although they debated the criteria and were aware of each of the objections raised, most of them by civil society, decided to admit only one, which corresponds to Juan Carlos Rodil Quintana, who was appointed by Da Vinci University.
The objection against Rodil Quintana was filed by Da Vinci University, where he was dean, considering it a lack of ethics and bad behavior that the now aspiring magistrate allegedly issued academic certifications to people who had not met the requirements and thus favored them in other application processes.
Da Vinci University has joined as a victim in a case against Rodil Quintana, who is being investigated for issuing graduation certificates in favor of current Supreme Electoral Tribunal judges, during his nomination process.
The nominating committee on Saturday rejected 31 objections because it considered that they did not apply according to the parameters that were approved at the beginning of the process. Each objection was submitted to a vote by the nominating committee but they had to add up to 25 votes to be admitted, which only occurred with one.
New date
The nomination committee for the CSJ also heard a request to alter its schedule and by majority decided that next Wednesday, September 11, the files of the candidates will be reviewed using the grading table, the last process in this nomination committee to evaluate the profiles before putting together the final lists.
window.addEventListener(‘DOMContentLoaded’, function() {
/*(function($) {*/
(function (d, s, id) {
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s);
js.id = id;
js.src = document.location.protocol + “//connect.facebook.net/es_LA/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.3”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
}(document, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));
/*})(jQuery);*/
});
#CSJ #nominator #admits #objections #candidates
Guatemala: A Country Marked by Injustice and Corruption
Guatemala, a country located in Central America, has a rich history marked by great structural injustice, the marginalization of the indigenous population, and a 36-year internal armed conflict [[3]]. However, recent events have shown that the country still struggles with corruption and questionable practices, particularly in its judicial system.
The Supreme Court of Justice (CSJ) Nomination Committee
In recent news, the nomination committee for the Supreme Court of Justice (CSJ) concluded its review of objections against candidates for one of the 13 magistrate positions [[1]]. The committee met on Saturday, September 7, to review 32 objections filed against candidates, but ultimately rejected 31 of them for not complying with previously approved parameters. The only accepted objection was against Juan Carlos Rodil Quintana, presented by Da Vinci University [[2]].
Objection Against Juan Carlos Rodil Quintana
The objection against Rodil Quintana was filed due to allegations of ethical misconduct and bad behavior during his time as dean at Da Vinci University. It is claimed that he issued academic certifications to individuals who had not met the requirements, which favored them in other application processes [[2]]. Furthermore, Da Vinci University has joined as a victim in a case against Rodil Quintana, who is being investigated for issuing graduation certificates in favor of current Supreme Electoral Tribunal judges during his nomination process.
Rejection of Objections
The nominating committee rejected 31 objections because they did not meet the approved parameters. Each objection was submitted to a vote, but they required 25 votes to be admitted. Only the objection against Rodil Quintana met this threshold [[2]].
New Date for Candidate Review
The nomination committee also heard a request to alter its schedule and decided that next Wednesday, September 11, the files of the candidates will be reviewed using the grading table. This will be the last process in this nomination committee to evaluate the profiles before presenting the final candidates [[2]].
Conclusion
Guatemala’s struggle with corruption and injustice is ongoing, and the recent events surrounding the CSJ nomination committee are a testament to this. The rejection of 31 objections and the acceptance of only one raises questions about the transparency and fairness of the process. As the country moves forward, it is essential to address these issues and work towards a more just and equitable society for all.
References:
Guatemala country conditions 2024
Guatemala: A Country Marked by Injustice and Corruption
Guatemala, a country located in Central America, has been plagued by a history of injustice and corruption. In recent years, the country has struggled to overcome these issues, which have had a profound impact on its citizens and the country’s progress. In this article, we will explore the roots of injustice and corruption in Guatemala and examine the current state of the country’s judiciary, highlighting the role of the Supreme Court of Justice (CSJ) and recent developments in the nomination process for new magistrates.
The Supreme Court of Justice of Guatemala
The Supreme Court of Justice of Guatemala, also known as the CSJ, is the highest court in the country’s judiciary branch. According to [[2]], the CSJ is responsible for ensuring that justice is served in Guatemala, making it a crucial institution in the country’s struggle against injustice and corruption.
CSJ Nominator Admits 1 of 32 Objections Against Candidates
In a recent development, the nomination committee for the CSJ concluded its review of objections on Saturday, September 7. The committee reviewed 32 objections filed against candidates for one of the 13 magistrate positions, but only admitted one, against Juan Carlos Rodil Quintana, presented by Da Vinci University [[3]].
The objection against Rodil Quintana was filed due to allegations of unethical behavior and bad conduct during his tenure as dean of Da Vinci University. It is alleged that he issued academic certifications to individuals who did not meet the requirements, which led to favoritism in other application processes.
Current State of the Judiciary in Guatemala
The judiciary in Guatemala has long been criticized for its lack of transparency and corruption. The CSJ, as the highest court in the country, plays a vital role in ensuring that justice is served. However, the
/origin-imgresizer.eurosport.com/2024/09/16/4040868-81955008-2560-1440.jpg?fit=300%2C300&ssl=1)
