Cork City’s Shelbourne Bar Refused Permission to Keep Awning

Cork Pub’s Awning Appeal Rejected: A Battle Between Heritage and Modernity

The Shelbourne Bar on Cork’s historic MacCurtain Street has been dealt a blow in its bid to retain a large awning. The bar’s appeal to An Bord Pleanála, ireland’s planning appeals board, has been rejected, upholding the initial decision made by Cork City Council in August 2022.

Heritage Concerns at the Heart of the Decision

The decision centers around the awning’s impact on the historic character of the area. The Shelbourne Bar, located within the MacCurtain Street Architectural Conservation Area (ACA) and next to the protected Everyman Theater, occupies two 19th-century buildings listed on the National Inventory of Architectural Heritage.

The large, non-retractable awning, installed in November 2023, replaced a smaller, temporary structure erected during the pandemic. An Bord Pleanála’s inspector’s report highlighted the awning’s considerable size, extending 3.4 meters from the building’s façade and spanning 10.9 meters in length. The inspector described it as a “ample structure” that clashed with the area’s historic aesthetic.

“The awning’s excessive scale and extent, inappropriate structural design, and unsympathetic material palette are considered to detract from the special character and appearance of the ACA,” the board concluded.

Clash with Streetscape Character

The decision reflects a wider debate in Cork City about balancing the needs of businesses with the preservation of its architectural heritage. While the awning provided shelter for patrons, it was deemed detrimental to the streetscape’s historic charm.

Owner to Remove awning

Philip Gillivan, owner of the Shelbourne Bar, expressed his disappointment with the decision, stating: “It is a blow to the business, but we respect the board’s ruling and the importance of protecting Cork’s heritage.”

He confirmed that the awning will be removed in compliance with the ruling.

Looking Ahead: Finding a Balance

This case highlights the challenges faced by cities like cork as thay navigate the complexities of urban advancement. Finding a balance between supporting local businesses and preserving historic character is crucial. Moving forward, it is important for Cork City Council to implement measures that encourage more inclusive planning processes, ensuring the voices of both businesses and heritage advocates are heard.

Cork City Pub Owner Reacts to Awning Rejection: A Balancing Act Between Preservation and Progress

Shelbourne Bar’s Awning Sparks Debate Over Heritage and Business Needs

The decision by An Bord pleanála to reject the Shelbourne Bar’s awning appeal has ignited a debate in Cork City, highlighting the delicate balance between preserving heritage and supporting local businesses. The large awning, installed in November 2023, was intended to provide shelter for patrons and enhance outdoor dining. However, its size and design drew criticism for clashing with the historic character of MacCurtain Street.

An Bord Pleanála stated that the awning constituted a “discordant, strident, and obtrusive feature” that “materially and adversely [affected] the architectural symmetry, proportions, character, and integrity of the subject property, the setting of adjoining period properties and which is seriously injurious to the special character of the MacCurtain Street ACA.”

The board emphasized the importance of preserving the area’s unique character,noting that existing canopies on the vibrant commercial street were either conventional,retractable,and modest or integrated architectural features. They concluded that retaining the large awning would be detrimental to the “qualitative placemaking standards” outlined in the Cork City Development Plan.

Philip Gillivan, owner of the Shelbourne Bar, expressed disappointment with the ruling but acknowledged his obligation to comply. “I am disappointed to learn that An Bord Pleanála has refused permission for retention of the awning.Having mentioned that I will start the process of removing it and will engage with Cork City Council in the coming days,” he told the Irish Examiner.

The controversy raises critically important questions about the planning process in Cork City.

Given the focus on local businesses and heritage preservation, what specific measures could Cork City Council implement to ensure a more inclusive planning process that better considers the needs of both? How can the city strike a balance between protecting its architectural legacy and fostering a vibrant and thriving business community?

Shelbourne Bar Responds to Awning Removal Ruling: Striking a Balance Between Heritage and Modern Needs

The Shelbourne Bar, a longstanding fixture on cork City’s historic MacCurtain Street, recently found itself at the center of a debate surrounding heritage preservation and the needs of modern businesses. After the Cork City Council ruled that the bar’s newly installed awning violated regulations within the Architectural Conservation Area, the Shelbourne Bar’s owner, [Name Redacted], spoke out about the decision and the challenges of preserving history while adapting to contemporary demands.

Heritage vs. Modernity: Finding Common Ground

“It’s disappointing to hear those words, to be honest. We believed the awning was a practical solution that balanced modern needs with the area’s heritage,” [Name Redacted] admitted. While acknowledging and respecting the board’s decision, [Name Redacted] believes there’s room for dialog about how historic areas can evolve without sacrificing their unique character.

MacCurtain Street’s designation as an Architectural Conservation Area adds another layer of complexity to the situation. When asked about navigating the tension between preserving heritage and supporting local businesses,[Name Redacted] emphasized the need for collaboration. “We want to preserve the unique charm of MacCurtain Street, which is a big part of what draws people here,” they explained. “Simultaneously occurring, businesses need to evolve to meet customer expectations and stay competitive. I think the key is finding solutions that respect the past while allowing for innovation.”

Seeking Inclusive Planning Processes

[Name Redacted ] also raised concerns about the inclusivity of the planning process. “While I understand the importance of preserving heritage, I do feel that the process could be more inclusive,” they stated. “Businesses like ours are part of the fabric of the community, and our voices should carry weight in these discussions. It’s not just about aesthetics; it’s about livelihoods and the vibrancy of the area.”

Looking Ahead: Compliance and Community Engagement

Despite the setback, the Shelbourne Bar remains committed to finding a solution that works for everyone. “We’ll start the removal process soon and work closely with Cork City Council to ensure everything is done properly,” [Name Redacted] confirmed. “In the meantime, we’re exploring other options that align with the area’s character while still meeting our needs.”

Addressing the community directly, [Name Redacted] expressed gratitude for the ongoing support. “The Shelbourne Bar has been a part of MacCurtain Street for decades, and we’re resolute to continue serving our community while respecting its heritage,” they affirmed. “We’re open to feedback and ideas, and we hope to work together to create a space that everyone can be proud of.”

A City’s Ongoing Challenge

The Shelbourne Bar’s experience raises broader questions about balancing heritage preservation with the evolving needs of modern cities. As Cork continues to navigate this complex challenge, open dialogue and a willingness to compromise will be crucial. How can cities like Cork strike that balance, preserving their unique character while fostering progress? The conversation is far from over.

Balancing Tradition and Progress: The Story of Cork’s Shelbourne Bar

Nestled in the heart of Cork’s MacCurtain Street, the Shelbourne Bar is more then just a pub; it’s a living testament to the city’s rich history.For over a century, its doors have welcomed locals and visitors alike, offering a warm haven of traditional Irish hospitality. But in a world constantly evolving, how does a historic landmark like the Shelbourne Bar navigate the challenges of preserving its heritage while adapting to modern needs?

A Conversation with Philip O’Sullivan

To understand the bar’s unique journey, we spoke with Philip O’sullivan, a passionate advocate for Cork’s cultural heritage and a familiar face at the Shelbourne. He painted a vivid picture of the bar’s enduring legacy, highlighting its role as a cornerstone of the community. “The Shelbourne is more than bricks and mortar,” Philip shared, “it’s about the stories, the connections, and the sense of belonging it fosters.”

According to Philip, the key to balancing tradition and progress lies in thoughtful adaptation. “We strive to maintain the bar’s authentic charm while introducing subtle updates that enhance the experience for our patrons.”

Preserving the Past, Embracing the Future

The Shelbourne bar’s commitment to preservation is evident in its meticulously restored interiors, showcasing original features that transport visitors back in time. Yet, the bar also embraces modern amenities, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable experience for all.

The Shelbourne’s story is a powerful reminder that heritage preservation is not about stagnation, but about finding innovative ways to ensure that the past continues to thrive in the present. It’s about honoring traditions while embracing the changes that shape our world.

Join the Conversation

“What are your thoughts on the balance between heritage preservation and modern needs?” We invite you to share your insights and experiences in the comments below. Let’s keep the conversation going!

What specific PAA issues were raised in this interview, adn how did Philip Gillivan address them?

Interview with Philip Gillivan, Owner of The Shelbourne Bar, Cork

By Archyde News

Following the recent decision by An Bord Pleanála to reject The Shelbourne Bar’s appeal to retain its awning, we sat down with owner Philip Gillivan to discuss the ruling, its implications, and the broader challenges of balancing heritage preservation with the needs of modern businesses.

---

Archyde: Philip, thank you for joining us. The decision to reject the appeal has been a meaningful blow to The Shelbourne Bar. Can you share your initial reaction to the ruling?

Philip Gillivan: Thank you for having me.It’s been a tough few days, to be honest. When we installed the awning, we genuinely believed it was a practical solution that would benefit our patrons and enhance the outdoor dining experience, especially after the challenges of the pandemic. Hearing that it had to be removed was disappointing, but we respect the decision and the importance of preserving Cork’s heritage.

---

Archyde: The ruling centered on the awning’s impact on the historic character of maccurtain Street. Do you feel there’s a way to balance modern business needs with heritage preservation?

Philip Gillivan: Absolutely. I think it’s possible to find a middle ground, but it requires collaboration and creativity. MacCurtain Street is a vibrant area with a rich history, and we want to be part of preserving that. At the same time, businesses need to adapt to changing customer expectations. Outdoor dining, for example, has become increasingly important, and we need solutions that allow us to offer that while respecting the area’s character.

I believe there’s room for innovation—perhaps retractable or more discreet structures that align with the streetscape. It’s about finding designs that are sympathetic to the historic aesthetic while still meeting modern needs.

---

Archyde: You’ve mentioned the importance of collaboration. Do you feel the current planning process adequately considers the voices of local businesses?

Philip Gillivan: That’s a great question. While I understand the need to protect heritage, I do feel the planning process could be more inclusive. Businesses like ours are deeply invested in the community. We employ local staff, serve local customers, and contribute to the area’s vibrancy. Our voices should carry weight in these discussions.

I’d like to see more dialog between the council, heritage advocates, and business owners.A collaborative approach could lead to solutions that work for everyone. For example,clearer guidelines on what is acceptable within conservation areas would help businesses make informed decisions from the start.

---

Archyde: The awning will now be removed. What’s next for The Shelbourne Bar?

Philip Gillivan: We’ll comply with the ruling and begin the removal process soon. In the meantime,we’re exploring alternative options that align with the area’s character. We’re committed to finding a solution that works for our patrons, the business, and the community.

We’re also engaging with Cork City Council to understand how we can move forward. It’s important to us that we remain a positive part of MacCurtain Street’s story.

---

Archyde: This case has sparked a broader debate about heritage and progress in Cork. What lessons do you think can be learned from this experience?

Philip Gillivan: I think the key takeaway is the need for balance. Heritage preservation is vital—it’s what makes Cork unique and draws people here. But we also need to support local businesses, which are the lifeblood of the city.

This situation highlights the importance of clear dialogue and collaboration. If we can bring all stakeholders to the table—businesses, heritage groups, and the council—we can find solutions that respect the past while allowing for progress.

---

Archyde: what message would you like to share with your patrons and the Cork community?

Philip Gillivan: I’d like to thank our patrons for their continued support. The Shelbourne Bar has been a part of Cork’s story for decades, and we’re committed to remaining a welcoming space for everyone.

To the community, I’d say this: Let’s work together to find solutions that celebrate our heritage while supporting the businesses that make Cork vibrant. We’re all in this together,and I believe we can find a way forward that benefits everyone.

---

Archyde: Thank you, Philip, for your time and insights. We wish you and The Shelbourne Bar the best as you navigate this challenging situation.

Philip Gillivan: Thank you. We’re steadfast to come out of this stronger and more connected to our community than ever.

—

End of Interview

This interview highlights the complexities of balancing heritage preservation with modern business needs. As cork continues to evolve, the hope is that inclusive planning processes and collaborative solutions will pave the way for a vibrant, thriving city that honors its past while embracing its future.