The Cold Hard Truth About Cold Water Immersion
Cold water immersion – think icy baths or bracing showers – is having a moment. Fans tout its potential benefits for everything from mental clarity to immunity. But is there scientific backing for these claims?
Researchers at the University of South Australia (UniSA) have been diving deep into the evidence, conducting the most comprehensive review and meta-analysis to date on the effects of cold water immersion on the general population.
“While cold water immersion has been extensively studied in sporting contexts to aid athlete recovery,we no surprisingly little about its impact on everyday individuals,” explains Tara Cain,a research assistant at UniSA’s Alliance for Research in Exercise,Nutrition and Activity (ARENA) and the study’s lead author.”Our research shows some promising results, but they’re often short-lived.”
Indeed,the studies revealed a range of time-dependent effects. Cold water immersion seemed to temporarily reduce stress levels for up to 12 hours post-exposure.Participants who incorporated 30, 60, or 90-second cold showers into their daily routine for 30 days reported slightly better quality of life scores. However, these benefits faded after three months.
“There is some evidence that regular cold showers might reduce sick days, with one study reporting a 29% decrease,” adds Cain. “We also saw some correlations between cold water immersion and improved sleep, but the data was limited to males, so more research is needed to confirm these findings.”
Interestingly, the researchers also uncovered a counterintuitive effect: cold water immersion initially spiked inflammatory markers, both immediately and an hour after the immersion.
“This seems contradictory, as ice baths are often used by athletes to reduce inflammation and muscle soreness after exercise,” notes Dr. Ben Singh,ARENA research fellow and senior author of the study.”However, this initial inflammatory response is the body’s way of adapting to the cold stressor. It’s similar to how exercise causes muscle damage before strengthening them.
“It’s important to remember that this initial inflammation spike could be detrimental for individuals with existing health conditions. They should be extra cautious when considering cold water immersion,” warns Dr. Singh.
The researchers point out that these studies, conducted in Australia, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Switzerland, Japan, the US, and Finland, represent a valuable starting point. However, more extensive, randomized controlled trials with larger, diverse participant groups are needed to fully understand the long-term benefits and risks of cold water immersion. Further research should also explore the optimal temperature,duration,and frequency of exposure.
Cain emphasizes, “Whether you’re an athlete or someone just looking for a wellness boost, it’s crucial to understand the effects cold water immersion has on yoru body. Right now, the evidence isn’t conclusive enough to say definitively who benefits most or what the ideal approach is.”
“Right now, there isn’t enough high-quality research to say exactly who benefits most or what the ideal approach is to cold-water immersion.” – Tara Cain
This recently published study in the journal PLOS One is a valuable contribution to this ongoing discussion. It serves as a reminder that while cold water immersion might sound appealing,it’s essential to approach it with awareness and a healthy dose of skepticism until more research provides definitive answers.