In the late 18th century, philosophers and scientists proposed that the planets formed from a condensed disk of dust and gas surrounding the newborn sun. However, it was not until about 200 years later that astronomers first observed evidence through telescopes to support this hypothesis. At that time, infrared astronomical satellites discovered additional infrared radiation around the hot star Vega, which was interpreted as a planetary disk composed of cold dust. Years of observations have shown that such dust disks are common around young stars, and Vega was just the first clue to the phenomenon.
Now, astronomers have combined the capabilities of the Hubble and James Webb Space Telescopes to once again detect the disk around Vega. Hubble observed particles the size of smoke, while Webb captured particles about the size of a grain of sand. Surprisingly, no clear evidence of large planets passing through the disk was found. The disk around Vega is almost as smooth as a pancake, showing no signs of planets. Researchers even described it as “ridiculously smooth.” This has prompted astronomers to rethink the diversity of planetary systems around other stars. Apparently, the structure of dust disks takes on various forms in different star systems. Observations from the Hubble and Webb telescopes tell us that the planet-forming environments in the universe are full of unexpected diversity.
The study shows that dust in the dust disk around Vega is distributed in layers because the star’s radiation pressure pushes smaller particles farther away than larger ones. Different physical processes cause particles of different sizes to be distributed in different locations, and the dust size distributions we observe help understand fundamental dynamics in the dust disks surrounding stars. The Webb telescope observed infrared light emitted by a disk of dust the size of sand grains orbiting a hot blue-white star. Hubble captured the outer halo of the dust disk, which is composed of smoke-sized particles that reflect the star’s light. There is indeed a faint gap in the Vega disk, about 60 AU from the star, equivalent to twice the orbital distance of Neptune; but other than that, the dust disk remains extremely smooth close to the star, showing no trace of any Large planets orbit.
▲ On the left is an image taken by the Hubble Space Telescope, showing the 150 billion-kilometer-wide dust disk surrounding Vega. Hubble observed light reflected from smoke-sized dust particles that are mostly found in the disk’s outer halo. The image on the right is an image analyzed by the Webb Space Telescope, showing a dust disk about 37 billion kilometers away from Vega. It is composed of particles the size of sand grains and emits infrared radiation. Vega’s planetary disk is extremely smooth and does not show any signs of large planets orbiting it.
The structure of the Vega system is significantly different from our solar system. However, Vega is about twice as massive as the Sun and has a surface temperature as high as 9,600K. In comparison, the structure of the dust disk around it, which is similar in distance, age and temperature to Vega, is quite different. There are three obvious gaps in the dust disk of Nanmenmen. It is speculated that these gaps are ring structures formed by the primitive planets passing through the disk. Given the similarities in physical properties between Vega and Promena, why does Promena seem to be able to form planets but Vega is not? Astronomers are studying the diversity of dust disks surrounding stars and their connections to planetary systems. Although many unknowns remain about the planet formation process, Vega’s observations will help define planet formation models.
The paper will be published in the Astrophysical Journal (Su et al. 2024; Wolff et al. 2024）。
(This article is written by Taipei Planetarium Reprinted with permission; source of first image:NASA/JPL-Caltech/T. Pyle (SSC)Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons）
Want to buy us some coffee?
65 yuan per cup of coffee
Your coffee sponsorship will keep us going
The total amount is NT$0
“Q & A about buying coffee”
Follow TechNews via Google News here
New scientific and technological knowledge, updated from time to time
Oh, delightful! Let’s delve into the cosmic wonders, shall we? It seems we’ve got ourselves a universe-sized mystery on our hands! Or should I say, an "astronomical" curiosity, if you will?
Vega’s Dust Disk: Smooth as a Pancake, or Have We Been Served a Cosmic Hoax?
So, in the late 18th century, the philosophers and scientists – those cheeky intellectual types – were already pontificating about how planets formed from some sort of cosmic dust bunny around the sun. Fast forward 200 years, and it looks like we’ve finally got a decent telescope to help us take a peek at these dust disks. I mean, nothing says “serious science” like a bunch of blokes squinting through a telescope, right?
Now, astronomers were buzzing about finding something new around Vega, a hot young star looking all snazzy at a temperature of 9,600K – you know, just your average Tuesday in the cosmos. Not to be left out, the Hubble and James Webb telescopes had a little "telescope-off," capturing everything from smoke-sized particles to those pesky granules of sand – the annoying type you’d much rather find at the beach than in your cosmic backyard!
And what’s the result? The dust disk around Vega has been officially dubbed "ridiculously smooth." I mean, how does one even achieve that cosmic level of smoothness? Did they use a space-age pancake recipe? "Just one cup of stellar dust, a pinch of radiation pressure, and voilà – cosmic serenity!"
The Great Cosmic Divide: Gaps and Dust Particles
Here’s where it gets juicy! Researchers are scratching their heads over why Vega doesn’t seem to be cranking out planets like a month-old bakery. They’ve even found a faint gap in the disk – about 60 AU from Vega! That’s twice the distance of Neptune! It’s like the universe just put up a neon sign saying, “No planets allowed beyond this point!” Perhaps the planets are too busy binge-watching the latest interstellar series on a cosmic streaming service?
What’s even more amusing? Vega’s dust disk looks like it’s doing a great impression of a smooth operator, while another star, Promena, seems to be throwing a planet-formation party with three obvious gaps – like it’s inviting planets for a cosmic dance-off! What’s the difference? Same dust, different vibes. It’s the universe’s version of that one friend who can’t keep a relationship while the other is dating around like there’s no tomorrow.
Dust Distributions: The Cosmic Tinder of Planets
The paper, soon to be published in the Astrophysical Journal (probably in the “Most Likely to Cause Big Bang Afterparties” section), hints at the possibility that density and distribution of dust particles can give us vital clues to understanding the dynamics surrounding star systems. Almost like saying, “Hey, get your act together, Vega! Your dust is looking like it came from a low-budget sci-fi flick!”
And just to round up our chat, if you’re confused by dust layers, just remember this: smaller particles seem to be taking the early trains away from the hottest spots. Meanwhile, the larger ones are slower, hanging around like the last guests at a house party, asking, “So, are we doing this again next week?”
Conclusion: A Cosmic Cornucopia of Questions
In the end, astronomers are left with more questions than a kid at a science fair: Why does Promena seem to throw planets like confetti while Vega is a barren wasteland? It’s a study in cosmic contrasts, full of unexpected diversity that even the best observational thinkers couldn’t fathom with their knobby glasses!
So, raise your cups of coffee – or, as suggested by the article, make a donation for a cup of coffee that might just fuel another astronomical discovery. And remember, the universe doesn’t come with a manual; it’s more of a "figure it out as you go" situation!
Who knew planets and particles could provide so much comedic fodder? Whether you believe they’re out there or not, it’s all pretty starry and amusing, wouldn’t you say? Cheers to dust and planets! Or is it just one big cosmic joke? Who knows!
In the late 18th century, a group of visionary philosophers and scientists theorized that the planets originated from a condensed disk of dust and gas encircling the newly formed sun. This intriguing idea rested for nearly two centuries until astronomers turned their telescopes to the cosmos and uncovered evidence supporting this hypothesis. Notably, infrared astronomical satellites made a groundbreaking discovery, detecting additional infrared radiation emanating from the hot star Vega, subsequently interpreted as a planetary disk rich in cold dust. Over the years, continued observations have confirmed that such dust disks are not anomalies but rather common features around young stars, with Vega serving as the pivotal first clue to this celestial phenomenon.
Recently, astronomers have ingeniously harnessed the combined power of the Hubble and James Webb Space Telescopes to re-examine the dust disk encircling Vega. The Hubble Space Telescope detected particles comparable in size to smoke, while the Webb telescope focused on even larger particles, akin to grains of sand. Despite these detailed observations, astronomers were surprised to find no definitive evidence of large planets traversing the disk. Remarkably, the disk around Vega exhibits an astonishingly smooth surface, resembling a pancake, devoid of any signs of planet formation, leading researchers to label it as “ridiculously smooth.” This unexpected finding has sparked a reassessment among astronomers regarding the potential diversity of planetary systems that may exist in the universe. The structure of dust disks, as it turns out, varies significantly across different star systems.
The detailed study of the Vega system reveals that the dust surrounding the star is stratified in layers, largely influenced by the radiation pressure emitted by Vega, which pushes smaller particles further away than their larger counterparts. Distinct physical processes govern the distribution of particles of various sizes, and these observed dust size distributions are pivotal for understanding the fundamental dynamics within the dust disks surrounding stars. Specifically, the Webb telescope recorded infrared light emitted from a disk of dust composed of sand-sized particles orbiting this hot blue-white star. Simultaneously, Hubble captured the outer halo of the dust disk, primarily composed of smoke-sized particles reflecting the brilliant light of Vega. Notably, while there is a faint gap in the Vega disk situated roughly 60 astronomical units (AU) from the star—equivalent to twice the orbital distance of Neptune—the majority of the disk remains exceptionally smooth near the star, with no traces of any large planets orbiting within its vicinity.
▲ On the left, an image captured by the Hubble Space Telescope illustrates the vast dust disk surrounding Vega, which spans approximately 150 billion kilometers in width. Hubble’s observations focused on light reflected by smoke-sized dust particles predominantly located in the disk’s outer halo. Conversely, the image on the right, analyzed by the Webb Space Telescope, illustrates a dust disk approximately 37 billion kilometers away from Vega, comprised of particles comparable to sand grains that emit infrared radiation. Remarkably, the planetary disk encircling Vega appears extremely smooth, lacking any indications of large planets within its bounds.
Interestingly, the configuration of the Vega system markedly contrasts with that of our solar system. Vega, with nearly double the mass of the Sun and a scorching surface temperature soaring to about 9,600K, creates an environment that is quite different from our own. In comparison, the dust disk surrounding the star Promena, which shares similarities in distance, age, and temperature with Vega, exhibits three prominent gaps. These gaps are speculated to be ring structures formed by primordial planets navigating through the disk. This raises an intriguing question among astronomers: given the physical similarities between Vega and Promena, why does Promena appear capable of planetary formation while Vega does not? As researchers delve into the diverse characteristics of dust disks enveloping stars, they aim to uncover the connections to the birth of planetary systems. Although numerous mysteries shroud the planet formation process, observations of Vega are poised to play a crucial role in refining our models of planet formation.
The findings of this research will be published in the esteemed Astrophysical Journal (Su et al. 2024; Wolff et al. 2024).
(This article is written by Taipei Planetarium and is reprinted with permission; source of the first image: NASA/JPL-Caltech/T. Pyle (SSC) Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons).
Want to buy us some coffee?
65 yuan per cup of coffee
Your coffee sponsorship will keep us going
The total amount is NT$0
“Q & A about buying coffee”
Follow TechNews via Google News here
New scientific and technological knowledge, updated from time to time
Intriguing questions about the processes governing planet formation and the diverse evolutionary paths of different star systems.
The stark differences between Vega and other stars like Promena reveal that even within similar conditions, outcomes can vary dramatically. The apparent smoothness of Vega’s dust disk poses a puzzle: why has planet formation stalled here when it seems to flourish elsewhere? Perhaps the intense radiation from Vega, paired with its different mass and temperature, alters how dust accumulates and how planets can form. As researchers probe deeper into these cosmic environments, they may uncover the underlying mechanisms that lead to such variations.
Moving forward, studies focusing on the dynamics of dust particle interactions and the influence of stellar radiation will be essential in piecing together the planet formation story around Vega and similar stars. The ultimate goal? To refine our understanding of how planets, including potentially habitable ones, arise from dust disks, and what factors tilt the scales toward formation or barren existence.
In this cosmic quagmire of questions, discoveries made about Vega could illuminate broader trends in astrophysics, creating a context for understanding not just our own solar system but also the myriad potentially habitable worlds that exist throughout the cosmos. As we continue to unravel these mysteries, who knows what other surprises the universe has in store for us? Cheers to the pursuit of knowledge amidst the cosmic dance of dust and planets!
