‘Antiques roadshow’ Appraiser Stunned by Owner’s sentimental Attachment to Vintage Pens
Table of Contents
- 1. ‘Antiques roadshow’ Appraiser Stunned by Owner’s sentimental Attachment to Vintage Pens
- 2. A Glimpse into the Past: The Waterman Pens’ Story
- 3. Valuation and Sentimental Value Clash
- 4. beyond the pens: Other Highlights from Derry/Londonderry
- 5. What is the most surprising thing for you when it comes to situations where the monetary value of an antique is less vital than its sentimental value to the owner?
- 6. An interview with Penelope Sterling: The Waterman Pens and Sentimental Value connection
- 7. The Waterman Pens: A Case Study
- 8. Valuation Versus Sentimentality
- 9. Looking Ahead: The Future of Sentimental Value
Published: April 6, [Current Year]
Derry/Londonderry, Northern Ireland
The BBC’s Antiques Roadshow captivated audiences on Sunday as it showcased a range of intriguing artifacts from Ebrington Square in Derry/Londonderry, Northern Ireland. Among the standout moments was the appraisal of a set of vintage Waterman ballpoint pens,a gift bestowed upon the owner by her father,a veteran of the dutch Merchant Navy. The pens, remarkably preserved and unused, sparked a discussion about value, sentimentality, and the enduring appeal of Art Deco design.
The guest, whose name was not disclosed, presented the pristine set to expert Mark Hill. Despite their personal significance, she admitted that the pens had never been used. This immediately piqued Hill’s interest, setting the stage for an insightful appraisal.
“Would you ever be tempted to use them?”
Mark Hill, Antiques Roadshow Expert
The owner’s response was a firm “no. Just never thought about it,” highlighting the pens’ status as cherished keepsakes rather than functional writing instruments.
A Glimpse into the Past: The Waterman Pens’ Story
Mark Hill explored the pens’ captivating history, emphasizing their “original” condition and the significance of their intricate details. These pens weren’t just writing tools; they were artifacts of a bygone era, potentially dating back to the late 1930s, a tumultuous period marked by global conflict. The fact that they survived the owner’s father’s service in the Dutch Merchant Navy, which could have included perilous voyages during World War II, added another layer of intrigue.
“I wonder where he got them from, and how they survived being torpedoed at least once. Because, if these date from the late 1930s, I’m guessing he must have somehow stored them somewhere, and then given them to you.”
Mark Hill, Antiques roadshow Expert
Hill’s speculation highlights the ancient context that dramatically increases the value of such antiques. The pens provide a tangible connection to stories of resilience and survival.
Valuation and Sentimental Value Clash
The appraisal culminated in a valuation that caught the owner by surprise. Hill revealed that the set, in its original box, was worth between £400 and £600 (approximately $500 to $750 USD). This valuation reflects the rarity and desirability of vintage Waterman pens among collectors.
“You stored them so wisely, and I’m glad you did! In the original box, four to six hundred pounds.”
mark Hill, Antiques Roadshow Expert
The guest’s reaction was one of genuine astonishment. “Really?! They’re lovely. I wouldn’t sell them,” she exclaimed, underscoring the profound sentimental value that outweighed any monetary gain. This highlights a common theme on Antiques Roadshow, where personal connections often trump market prices.
The owner’s steadfast refusal to part with the pens, even after learning their value, visibly surprised Mark Hill. He then offered a different perspective, suggesting that she consider restoring them and using them to write a letter, thereby connecting with their history in a tangible way. This suggestion underscores the idea that antiques can be more than just display pieces; they can be functional objects that connect us to the past.
“Get them restored, and use them, and write a letter with them. They are stunning pieces of Art Deco design by one of the world’s greatest vintage fountain pen makers, superb things. Thank you so much!”
Mark Hill, Antiques Roadshow Expert
This advice resonates with a growing trend in the U.S., where people are seeking ways to connect with history and craftsmanship through tangible objects.Whether it’s restoring a vintage car, collecting antique furniture, or using a vintage pen, there’s a desire to appreciate the quality and artistry of previous generations.
The owner’s final remark, “Well done, Dad.Yes, they’re beautiful!” served as a touching tribute to her father’s legacy and the enduring power of family heirlooms.
beyond the pens: Other Highlights from Derry/Londonderry
The episode from Derry/Londonderry featured other notable finds. ronnie Archer-Morgan was captivated by a collection of over a thousand compact purses, showcasing the evolution of fashion accessories.Gordon Foster examined a hurling trophy, shedding light on the cultural significance of this traditional Irish sport. John Sandon, meanwhile, discovered a pair of 18th-century plates, offering a glimpse into the region’s rich history of ceramics.
| Artifact | Expert | Description | Significance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Waterman Pens | Mark Hill | Vintage ballpoint pen set in original box | Art Deco design, family history |
| Compact Purses | Ronnie Archer-Morgan | Collection of over 1,000 purses | Fashion history, social trends |
| Hurling Trophy | Gordon Foster | Trophy related to traditional Irish sport | Cultural heritage, sporting traditions |
| 18th-Century Plates | John sandon | pair of antique ceramic plates | ceramics history, regional artistry |
What is the most surprising thing for you when it comes to situations where the monetary value of an antique is less vital than its sentimental value to the owner?
An interview with Penelope Sterling: The Waterman Pens and Sentimental Value connection
published: April 6, 2025
Derry/Londonderry, northern Ireland
Archyde News: Welcome, Penelope. Thank you for joining us today. We’re eager to delve into the stories behind the objects that capture our hearts. The recent “Antiques Roadshow” episode from Derry/Londonderry highlighted a truly touching instance. Can you tell us about the core of sentimental value in object appraisal?
Penelope Sterling: Absolutely. Sentimentality plays a humongous part in valuing an item. It frequently overrules the market valuation. Objects trigger memories, connect us to loved ones, and become vessels for personal histories.
The Waterman Pens: A Case Study
Archyde News: The “Antiques Roadshow” segment focused on a set of vintage Waterman pens. The owner admitted to never using them, yet recognized them as lovely items from a certain era.What specific elements made these pens so critically important, from your viewpoint?
Penelope Sterling: The pens are an amazing example through its Art deco design, the potential dating to the late 1930’s and family connection. Their pristine condition combined with the fact the pens were received from her father, who served in the Dutch Merchant Navy, enhanced their value. It was more than a fountain pen; it was a tangible link to the past.
Valuation Versus Sentimentality
Archyde News: The appraiser revealed the pens’ monetary value, but the owner wasn’t swayed, which is interesting. What is the most surprising thing for you when it comes to this type of situation?
Penelope Sterling: People who are given an antiques’ value and still reject to sell it, that is fascinating and shows how much people value past keepsakes rather than monetary items.
Looking Ahead: The Future of Sentimental Value
Archyde News: The episode suggested the owner use the pens. how could historical pens become a link between past and present?
penelope Sterling: Get them restored, and use them, and write a letter with them. They are stunning pieces of Art Deco design by one of the world’s greatest vintage fountain pen makers, superb things. That idea shows how personal connection can develop and enhance the love for such things.
Archyde News: Beyond the pens, what other advice would you give someone who wants to connect with history?
Penelope Sterling: I’d suggest to begin by learning your family history and identifying pieces that have stories that you can trace.Then, you must research the era and the context of any antique you own. I would also recommend restoring the objects,and ensuring that they do not get damaged.
Archyde News: Thank you,Penelope,for sharing your insights. Where do you see the line between personal thankfulness and market value, and how do we balance the two? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.
