Absolutely! Let’s take a cheeky and critical look at this rather unfortunate hiccup in the comic world, shall we? Buckle up, because we’re diving headfirst into the realm of cartoon controversy and social media outrage!
—
The Curious Case of “Spirou et la gorgone bleue”: A Comic Catastrophe
So, picture this: the beloved comic series Spirou releases a new album—“Spirou et la gorgone bleue”. Sounds delightful, right? It’s got the classic hero, a splash of adventure, maybe a talking animal or two…except this time, the universe had a different plan. Published in September 2023, this album has managed to stir the pot, all while selling a modest 16,000 copies, which, if we’re being honest, is slightly less than a summer blockbuster.
Wait, What Happened?!
Fast forward to October 31, 2024—a date better known for spookiness rather than cultural faux pas. Editions Dupuis announced a full withdrawal of the album from “all points of sale”. Now, unless you’re living under a rock or absolutely adore avoiding social media, you’ve probably caught a whiff of the drama. The criticism? Well, just a minor detail: Spirou meets characters drawn as black people likened to monkeys. Yes, you heard that right. It’s like the creative team thought they were still playing in a racially tone-deaf era. Spoiler alert: they weren’t!
Whoops, My Bad!
Dupuis editions wasted no time in apologizing, expressing they were “deeply sorry if this album could shock and hurt.” Now, that’s a bit like saying sorry for setting fire to a cake; the damage is already done! They recognized the album as drawing from a style of representation passé by at least a few decades, which makes you wonder—are these creators working with old pencils or just old ideals?
The company took to social media to clarify that the album was part of a derivative series, “seen by,” hinting that this mishap was merely a side note rather than the main plot. But let’s be honest: while the idea of reappropriating Spirou is charming, invoking outdated caricatures isn’t just a misstep; it’s a full-on belly flop into a swimming pool of cultural insensitivity.
Social Media: The Untamed Beast
As they say, the internet is forever. The backlash on social media soared as people expressed their anger and disappointment at the depictions. One would think that in 2024, we’d be well past the point of drawing caricatures that belong in a museum of ‘What Were They Thinking?!’ Yet, here we are, confronting concepts that should have been buried alongside dial-up internet.
Lessons Learned?
So what’s the takeaway from this comic catastrophe? Beyond the obvious need for a douse of sensitivity training and a history lesson for the creative team? It’s a stark reminder of art’s power and the responsibility that comes with it. Comics are more than just playful escapism—they wield the potential to shape opinions, challenge norms, and yes, sometimes even ignite foxfire debates on the ethics of representation.
Finally, let’s give credit where it’s due: Dupuis has recognized their miscalculation and taken steps to make things right. That’s a positive move! But perhaps in the future, a bit more foresight (and a better editor) might go a long way. Until then, let’s leave Spirou to his adventures—preferably sans any cringe-worthy stereotypes.
—
There you have it! A light-hearted yet sharp exploration of a rather serious topic. Sometimes, the funniest insights come from pointing out the truly ludicrous aspects of our cultural landscape, and if we can’t laugh a little while learning a lot, are we really living?
The album, produced by Dany and Yann, was published in September 2023.
Published on 10/31/2024 3:43 p.m.
Reading time: 1min Editions Dupuis are withdrawing the album “Spirou et la gorgone bleue”, published in September 2023. (MICHAEL ESDOURRUBAILH / MAXPPP)
Accused of racism on social networks, Dupuis editions announced, Thursday October 31, that they were withdrawing the album “Spirou et la gorgone bleue” from “all points of sale”. Published in September 2023, the album, produced by Dany and Yann, notably features the meeting between Spirou and black people drawn like monkeys. According to information from France Inter, this album has sold just over 16,000 copies since its release.
“In recent days, there has been an increase in speeches to express the anger felt at the representation of black people and women” in this album, write the Dupuis editions. They say to themselves “deeply sorry if this album could shock and hurt.”
“This album is part of a caricature style of representation inherited from another era”, recognize Dupuis editions. “More aware than ever of our moral duty and the importance that comics represent as a publisher, and more broadly the book in the evolution of societies, we take today full responsibility for this error of appreciation. This is why we would like to offer our most sincere apologies. We have implemented the withdrawal of the work from all points of sale.”
“Spirou and the Blue Gorgon” is not part of the main series. The album comes, as Dupuis specifies in his communication, from a derivative series, “seen by“, composed of special albums, and highlighting the reappropriation of Spirou by certain authors.
**Interview with Cultural Critic, Alex Rivers**
**Editor**: Welcome, Alex! Thank you for joining us today to discuss the recent controversy surrounding *Spirou et la gorgone bleue*. What’s your take on this situation?
**Alex Rivers**: Thanks for having me! Honestly, it’s quite shocking to see such a well-established comic franchise step into such a minefield. The idea that in 2024 we’re still confronting depictions that echo outdated and offensive stereotypes is unsettling.
**Editor**: Absolutely. The backlash has been intense. Why do you think this particular representation stirred such outrage?
**Alex Rivers**: It boils down to the fact that comics—not just as entertainment but as a cultural medium—carry significant weight in shaping perceptions. When characters are represented in a way that likens them to monkeys, especially within a racially charged context, it reopens wounds that many thought were healing. It’s reminiscent of racist tropes dating back to the early 20th century which have no place in today’s society.
**Editor**: Editions Dupuis has publicly apologized, stating they were “deeply sorry if this album could shock and hurt.” Do you think their response is adequate?
**Alex Rivers**: It’s a start, but it feels more reactive than proactive. A true commitment to change would involve a thorough examination of their hiring practices, sensitivity training, or at the very least, a dedicated diversity team overseeing these projects. Simply saying sorry after the fact feels a bit hollow.
**Editor**: Given the digital age we live in, do you think social media plays a role in amplifying such controversies?
**Alex Rivers**: Without a doubt! Social media acts as a powerful megaphone. It can mobilize voices that were previously marginalized and shine a much-needed light on cultural insensitivity. It’s a double-edged sword, though, as it can also lead to rapid polarization, turning discussions into outrage mobs. But in this case, it served to hold a beloved brand accountable for its missteps.
**Editor**: So, what can creators learn from this incident moving forward?
**Alex Rivers**: They need to understand the cultural implications of their work. Comics must evolve alongside society. Rigorous editorial processes and diverse perspectives are crucial in steering away from such catastrophic representation blunders. Ultimately, it’s about respect—respect for the audience and the diverse cultures they draw inspiration from.
**Editor**: Well said, Alex! Any final thoughts on this comic controversy?
**Alex Rivers**: It’s a necessary reminder that art holds responsibility. While we can enjoy the escapism comics provide, it’s paramount that they reflect the values of inclusivity and respect. Here’s hoping that *Spirou* can return to its adventures with a more reflective and enlightened approach.
**Editor**: Thank you so much for your insights, Alex. This conversation has been enlightening!
**Alex Rivers**: Thanks for having me!
