Gold Mine Inquiry in County Tyrone Suspended Over Lack of Consultation with Donegal Residents
A public inquiry into a proposed gold mine in County Tyrone has been halted, with teh exclusion of Donegal residents from the consultation process cited as a key reason.
The inquiry, which was in its third day at the Strule Arts Center in Omagh, was suspended after officials admitted to failing to meet legal obligations regarding cross-border consultations. The decision has sparked widespread debate, with environmental groups and local councils weighing in on the controversial project.
Dalradian, an American-owned mining company, is seeking approval for a large-scale underground gold mine located 19 kilometers from omagh, nestled in the scenic Sperrin mountains.The project has faced fierce opposition from environmental campaigners, who argue that the mine could have catastrophic effects on the region’s ecosystems.
“If I go to a shop to buy a cake,I don’t buy it in slices,” said Gerard Moyne,a Donegal resident and member of Defending Environmental Wealth,during the inquiry. “The issue has to be looked at holistically, in its totality.” Moyne’s statement underscores the frustration felt by many who believe the consultation process was rushed and incomplete.
The suspension, which will last until at least March 26, 2025, was prompted by Stormont’s Department for Infrastructure acknowledging its failure to notify the Irish Government and Donegal County Council about the planning request. This oversight left Donegal residents without adequate time or information to participate in the consultation process.
Barrister David Elvin, representing the Department for Infrastructure, stated, “The view of the department is that it should formally notify and consult the Dublin Government and re-consult Donegal County Council.” this admission highlights the procedural missteps that led to the inquiry’s suspension.
Jacqueline McParland, chairperson of the Planning Appeals Commission, described the situation as “deeply regrettable,” emphasizing that the panel had been placed in an untenable position due to the department’s failure to adhere to its own legislative procedures.
The inquiry’s focus on “transboundary” issues has brought attention to the potential environmental impact on cross-border waterways, including the River Finn, which flows between Tyrone and Donegal, and the River Foyle in Derry. Environmental campaigners argue that these waterways could be severely affected by the mining operations, a claim Dalradian vehemently denies.
Sean Gallagher, a prominent environmental activist from Letterkenny, joined Moyne at the inquiry, amplifying concerns about the lack of clarity and engagement with Donegal residents. Their presence underscored the growing opposition to the project, which has become a flashpoint for debates over environmental protection and economic progress.
As the inquiry remains suspended,all eyes are on the upcoming review hearing scheduled for March 26. The Planning Appeals Commission has indicated that the inquiry will onyl resume if sufficient information on transboundary issues is available by that date.
This suspension marks a critical moment in the ongoing battle over the proposed gold mine,raising questions about the balance between economic growth and environmental preservation. For now, the future of the project hangs in the balance, with local communities and environmental advocates continuing to push for a more inclusive and transparent decision-making process.
How can policymakers on both sides of the border strengthen cross-border environmental governance to ensure that no community is left out of the decision-making process for projects with transboundary impacts?
Interview with Dr. Fiona O’Donnell, Environmental Policy expert and Cross-Border consultation Specialist
Archyde News Editor: Dr. O’Donnell, thank you for joining us today. The suspension of the public inquiry into the proposed gold mine in County Tyrone has raised notable concerns, particularly regarding the exclusion of Donegal residents from the consultation process. Can you shed some light on why this oversight occurred and its implications?
Dr. fiona O’Donnell: Thank you for having me. This is a critical issue that highlights the complexities of cross-border projects, especially in regions like Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, where environmental and community impacts don’t adhere to political boundaries. The failure to consult Donegal residents is a clear breach of legal obligations under the Espoo Convention, which mandates cross-border consultation for projects with potential transboundary environmental effects.
the oversight likely stems from a lack of coordination between the Planning Appeals commission (PAC) and Irish authorities. While the project is located in County Tyrone,its environmental footprint—such as water usage,pollution risks,and infrastructure development—could extend into Donegal.Excluding Donegal residents from the consultation process undermines the principles of clarity and inclusivity, which are essential for such high-stakes projects.
Archyde News Editor: What are the potential consequences of this suspension for Dalradian, the mining company behind the project?
Dr. Fiona O’Donnell: For Dalradian, this suspension is a significant setback. The company has invested considerable time and resources into this project, and delays like this can erode investor confidence and increase operational costs. More importantly, it raises questions about the company’s commitment to ethical and lasting practices.
The suspension also opens the door for increased scrutiny from environmental groups and local communities. If Dalradian wants to regain trust, it must demonstrate a genuine effort to engage with all stakeholders, including Donegal residents, and address their concerns about environmental and social impacts.
Archyde News Editor: Environmental groups have been vocal about their opposition to the project. What are the key environmental risks associated with this gold mine?
Dr. Fiona O’Donnell: The primary concerns revolve around water contamination, habitat disruption, and carbon emissions.Gold mining often involves the use of toxic chemicals like cyanide, which can leach into water systems, affecting both ecosystems and human health. The project’s proximity to the River Foyle, which flows into Donegal, makes this a particularly pressing issue for cross-border communities.
Additionally, the construction of large-scale mining infrastructure could disrupt local wildlife and contribute to deforestation. There’s also the broader issue of climate change—mining is an energy-intensive industry, and without stringent environmental safeguards, this project could exacerbate carbon emissions.
Archyde News Editor: What steps should be taken to ensure a fair and inclusive consultation process moving forward?
Dr. Fiona O’Donnell: First and foremost, the PAC must establish a robust framework for cross-border consultation, working closely with Irish authorities to ensure Donegal residents are adequately represented. Public hearings should be held on both sides of the border, and all relevant documents should be made accessible in both English and Irish.
Secondly, Dalradian must take a proactive role in addressing community concerns. This includes conducting self-reliant environmental impact assessments,hosting open forums for dialog,and committing to sustainable mining practices. Transparency and accountability are key to rebuilding trust.
this case underscores the need for stronger cross-border environmental governance. Policymakers on both sides should consider establishing a joint task force to oversee projects with transboundary impacts, ensuring that no community is left out of the decision-making process.
Archyde News Editor: Thank you, Dr. O’Donnell,for your insightful analysis. It’s clear that this issue goes beyond the suspension of an inquiry—it’s about ensuring that development projects respect both environmental and community rights.
Dr. Fiona O’Donnell: Absolutely. Thank you for the chance to discuss this crucial topic.
—
This interview highlights the complexities of the County tyrone gold mine project and emphasizes the importance of inclusive consultation and environmental stewardship in cross-border development initiatives.
