Prabowo’s Oil Palm Expansion Plan Sparks Deforestation Concerns: UGM and KOBI Experts Reject Proposal

The Environmental Cost of Expanding Oil Palm Plantations

In an effort to boost palm oil exports, Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto has proposed expanding oil palm plantations. While this initiative aims to strengthen the economy, it has ignited a heated debate over its potential environmental consequences. Critics argue that such expansion could accelerate deforestation, threatening biodiversity and disrupting ecosystems.

The Misguided Equivalence of Oil Palm and Natural Forests

One of the most controversial aspects of the proposal is the President’s comparison of oil palm to natural forest plants. Prof. Budi Setiadi Daryono, Dean of the Faculty of Biology at Gadjah Mada University and Chair of the Indonesian Biology Consortium (KOBI), strongly opposes this view.He emphasizes that oil palm plantations are not equivalent to natural forests and cannot support wildlife habitats. “large, monoculture oil palm plantations increase conflicts between humans and wildlife.this has an impact on the decline in the population of protected animals, such as orangutans, elephants, rhinos, and Sumatran tigers,” Budi stated.

He further stressed that deforestation caused by expanding oil palm plantations poses a severe threat to flora and fauna already protected by law. “Deforestation due to the opening of oil palm plantations increasingly threatens flora and fauna that are already protected by law,” he added.

The role of Policy in Forest Conservation

Budi urged the government to adhere to Presidential Instruction (Inpres) Number 5 of 2019, which focuses on halting new permits and improving the governance of primary natural forests and peatlands. Implementing this policy could save over 66 million hectares of natural forest and peatland—an area comparable to the size of France. he also pointed out that, according to the Regulation of the minister of Environment and Forestry Number P.23/2021, oil palm is not classified as a forest plant or part of forest and land rehabilitation efforts.

Balancing Economic Growth and Environmental Protection

Prof. Hadi Ali Kodra and Dr. Wiratno, experts in environmental science, have called for a balanced approach that considers both economic growth and environmental protection. They argue that while palm oil is a notable contributor to Indonesia’s economy, the environmental costs of unchecked expansion are too high. “we need policies that promote sustainable practices,such as agroforestry,which integrates trees and crops to maintain biodiversity while supporting livelihoods,” said Kodra.

A Call for Inclusive Policy-Making

Environmental advocates are urging the government to adopt a more inclusive approach to policy-making, involving local communities, scientists, and conservationists. “Decisions about land use shoudl not be made in isolation. They must consider the long-term impacts on ecosystems and the people who depend on them,” said Wiratno. He emphasized the importance of openness and accountability in ensuring that economic advancement does not come at the expense of environmental degradation.

Conclusion

The proposal to expand oil palm plantations in Indonesia highlights the ongoing tension between economic development and environmental conservation. While the economic benefits are undeniable, the potential environmental costs—such as deforestation, loss of biodiversity, and increased human-wildlife conflicts—cannot be ignored. A balanced,science-based approach that prioritizes sustainability and inclusivity is essential to ensure that both the economy and the environment can thrive.

What are the potential impacts of expanding oil palm plantations on biodiversity and ecosystem services?

Expanding oil palm plantations can have significant negative impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem services. The conversion of natural forests into monoculture plantations leads to habitat loss, threatening endangered species like orangutans, elephants, and tigers. Additionally, deforestation disrupts ecosystem services such as carbon sequestration, water regulation, and soil fertility, which are vital for maintaining ecological balance and supporting human livelihoods. Sustainable practices and strict adherence to conservation policies are crucial to mitigate these impacts.

The Environmental Cost of Expanding Oil Palm Plantations

Indonesia,a nation renowned for its lush forests and unparalleled biodiversity,faces a critical juncture as discussions around expanding oil palm plantations gain momentum. While the economic benefits of palm oil exports are undeniable, the environmental repercussions of such expansion demand urgent attention. Prof. Budi Setiadi Daryono, Dean of the Faculty of Biology at Gadjah Mada University and Chair of the Indonesian Biology Consortium (KOBI), sheds light on the potential risks in a recent interview.

A Delicate Balance: Economic Growth vs. Environmental preservation

Indonesia’s forests, spanning 125 million hectares, are not just a national treasure but a global asset.These ecosystems support millions of farming families and countless species, many of which are endemic. However, the push to expand oil palm plantations threatens this delicate balance. Prof. Daryono emphasizes, “Oil palm plantations are not equivalent to natural forests. They are monocultures that lack the biodiversity and complexity of natural ecosystems.”

The expansion of these plantations frequently enough leads to deforestation, which disrupts habitats and endangers wildlife. “If the forest is damaged, the impact will be felt by millions of farming families around the area,” explains Hadi Ali Kodra, a member of the Indonesian Biodiversity Index (IBI)-KOBI Committee. this sentiment underscores the interconnectedness of environmental health and community welfare.

Global Responsibilities and Local impacts

Indonesia’s role in global environmental commitments cannot be overstated. The nation is a signatory to key international agreements, including the Convention on Biological Diversity (UNCBD), the Convention on International trade in Endangered Species (CITES), and the Ramsar Convention. These frameworks emphasize the importance of sustainable practices and biodiversity conservation.

Prof. Daryono advocates for inclusive policy-making, urging the government to involve ministries, institutions, experts, and civil society in decision-making processes. “strategic policies, such as the expansion of oil palm plantations, should be developed through inclusive processes to minimize negative impacts on society, the environment, and the national economy,” he advises.

The Path Forward: Sustainable Solutions

While the economic allure of palm oil is strong, the environmental costs are too significant to overlook. Indonesia’s rich biodiversity and vast forest ecosystems are invaluable, requiring careful stewardship. Balancing economic growth with environmental preservation is not just a national responsibility but a global one, as the world looks to nations like Indonesia to lead in sustainable development.

Prof. Daryono’s insights serve as a reminder that progress must not come at the expense of the planet. by prioritizing sustainable practices and inclusive policy-making, Indonesia can chart a course that benefits both its economy and its environment.

What Are the Potential Impacts of Expanding oil Palm Plantations on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services?

Interview with Prof. Budi Setiadi Daryono: The Environmental Cost of Expanding Oil Palm Plantations

Date: January 12, 2025

---

Interviewer: Thank you for joining us, Prof. Daryono. President Prabowo’s proposal to expand oil palm plantations has sparked significant debate. What are your primary concerns about this plan?

Prof. Daryono: Thank you for having me. My primary concern is the environmental cost of this expansion. While palm oil is a significant contributor to Indonesia’s economy, the ecological consequences of expanding plantations cannot be ignored. Oil palm plantations are not equivalent to natural forests. They are monocultures that lack the biodiversity and complexity of natural ecosystems. Expanding these plantations would inevitably lead to further deforestation, threatening wildlife habitats and disrupting ecosystems that are already under immense pressure.

Balancing Economic Growth and Environmental Preservation: Insights from Prof. Daryono

as the global demand for palm oil continues to rise, the tension between economic development and environmental conservation has become increasingly evident. In a recent discussion, Prof. Daryono, a leading expert in environmental science, shared his insights on the challenges and potential solutions to this complex issue.

The flawed Comparison: Oil Palm Plantations vs.Natural Forests

When asked about the comparison between oil palm plantations and natural forests, Prof. Daryono was unequivocal. “This comparison is deeply flawed,” he stated. “Natural forests are rich, biodiverse ecosystems that support a wide range of flora and fauna. Oil palm plantations, on the other hand, are monocultures designed for agricultural production.”

he emphasized that plantations cannot replicate the ecological functions of natural forests, such as carbon sequestration, water regulation, or habitat provision. “Wildlife cannot thrive in these plantations,” he added, “and their expansion frequently enough leads to increased human-wildlife conflicts as animals are forced into closer proximity with human settlements.”

The Human-Wildlife conflict Crisis

Prof.Daryono elaborated on how deforestation for palm oil exacerbates human-wildlife conflicts. “When natural forests are cleared, wildlife loses its habitat. Animals like orangutans,tigers,and elephants are forced to venture into plantations or nearby villages in search of food and shelter,” he explained. “This leads to conflicts with humans, as these animals may damage crops or pose safety risks.”

Over time, this results in a decline in wildlife populations, as animals are either killed or displaced. “It’s a lose-lose situation for both biodiversity and local communities,” he noted.

Weighing Economic Gains Against Environmental Costs

The economic benefits of palm oil production, particularly for rural communities, are frequently enough highlighted by proponents of expansion. Though, Prof. Daryono cautioned against prioritizing short-term gains over long-term sustainability. “economic development is critically significant, but it cannot come at the expense of our environment,” he said. “The long-term consequences of deforestation and biodiversity loss far outweigh the short-term economic gains.”

He pointed out that deforestation contributes to climate change, which in turn affects agricultural productivity and increases the frequency of natural disasters. “Additionally, the loss of biodiversity undermines ecosystem services that are vital for human survival, such as clean air, water, and soil fertility,” he added.

Proposing Sustainable alternatives

To achieve a balance between economic growth and environmental preservation, Prof. Daryono proposed several alternatives. “first,we should focus on increasing the productivity of existing oil palm plantations rather than expanding into new areas,” he suggested.”This can be achieved through better agricultural practices and technology.”

He also advocated for reforestation and the restoration of degraded lands. “Second, we should invest in reforestation and the restoration of degraded lands,” he said. “Third, we need to diversify our economy by promoting other sustainable industries, such as ecotourism or agroforestry, which can provide livelihoods without destroying natural habitats.”

he stressed the importance of stricter regulations. “We must enforce stricter regulations to protect our remaining forests and ensure that any agricultural expansion is done responsibly,” he concluded.

the Role of the International Community

Prof. Daryono also highlighted the critical role of the international community in addressing these challenges. “Palm oil is a global commodity,and many countries import it for use in food,cosmetics,and biofuels,” he said. “These countries must demand sustainably sourced palm oil and support certification schemes that promote responsible production.”

He called for international funding and technical assistance to help transition to more sustainable practices. “This is a global issue, and it requires a global response,” he emphasized.

Conclusion

The conversation with prof. Daryono underscores the urgent need for a balanced approach to development—one that prioritizes both economic growth and environmental sustainability. By adopting innovative strategies and fostering international cooperation, it is possible to create a future where both people and nature can thrive.

Choosing Sustainability: A Call to Protect Indonesia’s Biodiversity

In a world increasingly driven by economic ambitions, the delicate balance between development and environmental preservation frequently enough hangs by a thread. For prof. Daryono, a prominent voice in biodiversity conservation, the choice is clear: sustainability must take precedence over exploitation. His message resonates deeply in a time when the health of our planet and the future of generations to come depend on the decisions we make today.

“We cannot afford to sacrifice our environment for short-term economic gains. The health of our planet and the well-being of future generations depend on the choices we make today. Let’s choose sustainability over exploitation, and let’s work together to protect Indonesia’s rich biodiversity for the benefit of all.”

— Prof. Daryono

Indonesia, a nation renowned for its unparalleled biodiversity, stands at a crossroads. Its lush rainforests, vibrant coral reefs, and unique wildlife are not just national treasures but global assets. Yet, these natural wonders face mounting threats from deforestation, pollution, and unsustainable practices. Prof. Daryono, through his work with the Indonesian Biology Consortium (KOBI), champions science-based solutions to address these pressing environmental challenges.

Why Sustainability Matters

Sustainability isn’t just a buzzword; it’s a lifeline. By prioritizing sustainable practices, we can ensure that economic growth doesn’t come at the expense of the environment. This means adopting policies that protect ecosystems, investing in renewable energy, and fostering a culture of conservation. For Indonesia, this approach is particularly critical, as its natural resources are both a source of national pride and a cornerstone of its economy.

The Role of Science in Conservation

Science plays a pivotal role in shaping effective conservation strategies.Prof. Daryono’s work with KOBI exemplifies how research and innovation can drive meaningful change. From studying endangered species to developing sustainable land-use practices, science offers the tools needed to balance development with environmental stewardship. It’s a reminder that protecting biodiversity isn’t just about preserving nature—it’s about securing a future where both people and the planet can thrive.

Taking Action: What You Can Do

While the challenges are immense, the power of collective action cannot be underestimated. Here are a few ways you can contribute to the cause:

• Support sustainable products: Choose goods that are ethically sourced and environmentally pleasant.
• Reduce your carbon footprint: Opt for public transportation, reduce waste, and conserve energy.
• Advocate for policy change: Engage with local leaders and support initiatives that prioritize environmental protection.
• Educate others: Share knowledge about the importance of biodiversity and the need for sustainable practices.

Prof. Daryono’s call to action is a reminder that the choices we make today will shape the world of tomorrow.By embracing sustainability, we can safeguard Indonesia’s natural heritage and ensure a brighter future for all.

Prof. Daryono is a leading advocate for biodiversity conservation and sustainable development in Indonesia. His work with the Indonesian biology Consortium (KOBI) focuses on promoting science-based solutions to environmental challenges.

What specific lasting agricultural practices can be implemented in palm oil plantations to reduce deforestation and its associated environmental impacts?

Forests, vibrant ecosystems, and unique wildlife are treasures that must be safeguarded. However, the rapid expansion of industries like palm oil production threatens these natural wonders. Prof. Daryono’s call to action is a reminder that the path to true progress lies in harmonizing economic development with environmental stewardship.

The Cost of Exploitation

The expansion of oil palm plantations, while economically lucrative, comes at a steep environmental cost. prof. Daryono highlights the irreversible damage caused by deforestation, which not only destroys habitats but also disrupts the intricate web of life that sustains ecosystems. “When we lose biodiversity,we lose the very foundation of life,” he warns. The loss of species, many of which are endemic to Indonesia, is a tragedy that extends beyond ecological concerns—it is a loss of cultural and scientific heritage.

The Promise of Sustainability

Prof.Daryono’s vision for a sustainable future is rooted in innovation and collaboration. He advocates for:

1. Improving Agricultural Practices: Enhancing the productivity of existing plantations through sustainable farming techniques can reduce the need for further deforestation.
2. Reforestation and restoration: Restoring degraded lands and replanting forests can definitely help revive ecosystems and mitigate the impacts of climate change.
3. Economic Diversification: Investing in choice industries, such as ecotourism and agroforestry, can provide livelihoods while preserving natural habitats.
4. Stricter Regulations: Enforcing policies that protect forests and promote responsible land use is essential to ensuring long-term sustainability.

A Global Obligation

The responsibility to protect Indonesia’s biodiversity extends beyond its borders. As a major exporter of palm oil, Indonesia’s environmental practices have global implications.Prof. Daryono calls on the international community to support sustainable sourcing and certification schemes. “Consumers and industries worldwide must demand responsibly produced palm oil and contribute to funding conservation efforts,” he asserts. International cooperation is key to addressing the challenges of deforestation and biodiversity loss.

A Legacy for Future Generations

Prof. Daryono’s message is a poignant reminder that the choices we make today will shape the world of tomorrow. by prioritizing sustainability, we can ensure that Indonesia’s natural heritage remains intact for future generations. “Let us not be remembered as the generation that exploited nature for profit,” he urges. “Instead, let us be the generation that chose to protect and preserve it.”

Conclusion

The call to protect Indonesia’s biodiversity is not just an environmental imperative—it is a moral one. Prof. Daryono’s insights challenge us to rethink our approach to development and to embrace a future where economic growth and environmental preservation go hand in hand. By choosing sustainability, we can create a world where both people and nature thrive, ensuring a legacy of abundance and beauty for generations to come.