Will Massachusetts Fill the Void Left by Scrapping Standardized Testing?
Last month, Massachusetts voters made a big change to the state’s education system, eliminating the Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System (MCAS) as a high school graduation requirement via ballot measure Question 2.
No Standardization After MCAS Removal
This move leaves Massachusetts with no statewide standard for high school graduation. Now, there’s worry among educators that a diploma may not hold the same value across the state. Some fear that without the MCAS, a high school diploma’s worth could vary drastically depending on where a student lived.
Momentum For a New Set of Standards
This event sparked a conversation, with many advocating for a new state-level standard — something uniform across the board. “A really uniform standard” would ensure “different expectations for students depending on which ZIP code they’re in,” as noted by Governor Maura Healey, emphasizing the importance of statewide consistency.
Recent polling mirrors this sentiment, with 75 percent of Massachusetts residents supporting a new graduation requirement based on statewide curriculum standards
Many believe a robust school curriculum should be a priority. Whether one supported or opposed the MCAS, it had provided a consistent bar for success. Now, with its sunsetting, there’s concern about how different curriculum standards from district to district may result in uneven outcomes for Massachusetts students.
For example, only a small number of the state’s largest school districts require coursework aligning with public college admission standards, according to the Mass Department of Higher Education. This creates a situation where the MCAS may be gone, but the public is worried about a new issue: local schools may not be preparing their graduates adequately for what’s ahead, whether it be higher education or entering the workforce.
Seeking a Balanced Approach
“A uniform standard” is a major factor, not only for college acceptance, but also as a point for discussion. It’s about making sure Massachusetts stays top-ranked for education. It shouldn’t mean legislators disregard voter action, but it could mean finding a suitable replacement to ensure quality
<!–Related to original datawrapper embed code
Should the development of a new standardized system prioritize the use of alternative assessment methods, such as portfolio reviews and performance-based tasks, alongside traditional exams?
## Will Massachusetts Fill the Void Left by Scrapping Standardized Testing?
**Host:** Welcome back to the show. Today we’re diving into a crucial topic for Massachusetts education: the aftermath of Question 2, which eliminated the MCAS as a graduation requirement. Joining us to discuss the future of standardized testing in the state is education policy expert, Dr. Emily Carter. Dr. Carter, thanks for being here.
**Dr. Carter:** It’s a pleasure to be here.
**Host:** Let’s start with the elephant in the room. With the MCAS gone, Massachusetts is now without a statewide standard for high school graduation. This has sparked concerns about the value of diplomas potentially varying across different school districts. What are your thoughts on this?
**Dr. Carter:** It’s certainly a valid concern. [1 (https://www.masslive.com/news/2024/09/how-did-your-school-score-read-the-2024-mcas-results-here.html)] shows that the MCAS results were a key metric for evaluating school performance, despite the ongoing debate surrounding its use as a graduation requirement. Without a common benchmark, there’s a risk of inconsistencies in educational standards across the state, potentially affecting college preparedness and future opportunities for students.
**Host:** It seems like this has ignited a push for a new standardized system. Governor Healey has voiced support for a ”uniform standard,” and recent polls indicate strong public backing for adopting a new graduation requirement based on statewide curriculum standards. What do you believe are the key elements that should guide the development of this new system?
**Dr. Carter:** Creating a successful replacement for the MCAS requires careful consideration.
It’s crucial to ensure the new system reflects the diverse needs of Massachusetts students while maintaining high academic standards. This could involve incorporating a variety of assessment methods beyond standardized tests, including portfolios, project-based assessments, and real-world application of skills.
Moreover, it’s essential to involve educators, students, parents, and community stakeholders in shaping the new system to ensure it’s truly representative of the state’s educational values.
**Host:** This is a complex challenge, but it seems like the conversation is moving in a positive direction. Dr. Carter, thank you for sharing your valuable insights on this crucial issue.
**Dr. Carter:** It’s been my pleasure.
