2024-11-12 21:00:00
The years of speculation about an asylum law in Egypt directly supported by the EU asylum agency EUAA have come to an end. Around two weeks ago, Egypt’s parliamentary committee on defense and national security approved a first draft of such a law. The regulation had already been drawn up by the government in 2023, but the text itself remained secret – until the week before last.
1731446599
#Sharp #criticism #Egypts #asylum #law #Egypt
**Interview with Dr. Amina El-Sayed, an Expert in International Refugee Law**
**Editor:** Thank you for joining us, Dr. El-Sayed. The recent approval of Egypt’s asylum law has stirred quite a conversation. What are your initial thoughts on Egypt working closely with the EU asylum agency EUAA to establish this regulation?
**Dr. El-Sayed:** Thank you for having me. It’s a significant development, indeed. The collaboration indicates a shift in Egypt’s approach to managing asylum seekers, but it raises questions about the law’s design and implementation, particularly in terms of human rights.
**Editor:** Some critics argue that this law could be used to control and limit asylum applications rather than provide protection. What do you think will be the law’s impact on the actual rights of asylum seekers in Egypt?
**Dr. El-Sayed:** That’s crucial. While any law can serve as a framework for protection, the actual impact will depend on how it is enforced. If implemented transparently with genuine objectives of protection, it could be positive; otherwise, it risks becoming a tool for exclusion.
**Editor:** Given the secrecy surrounding the initial drafts, there’s been a call for more transparency and public discussion. How important is public debate in the formation of asylum laws?
**Dr. El-Sayed:** Very important. Public debate is essential for inclusive policymaking. It allows civil society and affected individuals to voice their concerns, helping to ensure that the laws formed are reflective of humanitarian principles and not just political expediency.
**Editor:** Lastly, many people are still skeptical about the EU’s influence in shaping asylum policies in third countries. Do you believe this will lead to a positive synergy, or could it create tension between national interests and EU directives?
**Dr. El-Sayed:** That’s a pivotal point. If handled collaboratively, it could enhance regional stability and protection. However, if Egypt feels pressured or if the law simply reflects EU interests rather than national realities, it could exacerbate existing tensions in the region.
**Editor:** Thank you, Dr. El-Sayed. Your insights provide a lot to consider regarding the future of asylum seekers in Egypt. What do our readers think? Will this new asylum law promote genuine protection for those in need, or will it become another tool for tightening borders? We invite you to share your views and join the debate.
