ETH Zurich Faces Backlash Over Discrimination and Abuse
Well, well, well, ETH Zurich has found itself in a bit of a pickle, hasn’t it? Picture this: scientists and students rallying outside the hallowed halls of Switzerland’s top university, waving banners and brandishing petitions like they’re the last rolls of toilet paper in a pandemic. The fuss? Discrimination, mobbing, and sexual assault cases that make you wonder if they’re really in a prestigious academic institution or the latest round of a reality show called *Survivor: Academia Edition*.
On a fateful Friday, the organizations Women in Natural Sciences, 500 Women Scientists Zürich, and Speak Up! in Academia decided they’d had enough. They strapped on their protest boots and hit the pavement, launching a petition titled “We are shocked” (a phrase that should probably be registered as a trademark at this point). With an impressive 1,300 signatures, they’ve made it crystal clear that when it comes to handling cases of harassment and bullying, ETH Zurich isn’t exactly winning any gold medals.
More Measures Required
Now, you might think that after pulling in a crowd, the university would feel a bit of pressure to act, and you’d be right! They organized a rally where the petition was handed over to management representatives. Sounds dramatic, right? Imagine the applause echoing around the Polyterrace as they presented their demands for anonymous reporting tools and legal funds for victims. It was like a TED Talk, but instead of discussing innovative new tech, they were discussing how to stop your career from being destroyed by a bully in a lab coat.
As a female scientist, this directly concerns me, as such actions destroy careers and lives.
And rightfully so! When you’re a scientist, your experiments might blow up in your face, but bullies should not be part of the equation! The climate described by Valentina Gasser from Speak Up! suggests a place where problematic behavior isn’t just tolerated, it’s practically a rite of passage. “Oh, you thought you could work here without facing a sexual advance or racist behavior? How quaint!”
The ETHZ Response
But, hold the phone! ETH Zurich management was not going to take this lying down. Julia Dannath, the vice-president of personal development and leadership (a title that sounds like she should be hosting a corporate wellness retreat), stated that while frustration is understandable, “each case is one too many.” They’ve made improvements, apparently, such as introducing new reporting services and an anonymous complaint form. It’s like they’re fighting fire with one of those little water pistols you find in kids’ party bags—admirable but not likely to quench a raging inferno.
The university insists it shares the same goals as the demonstrators regarding improvement in dealing with abuse. However, with such a serious issue at hand, we can’t help but wonder if these measures were more of a patch job rather than a comprehensive solution. You know – like using duct tape for a leaky pipe. It works until it doesn’t!
Join the Discussion
So, dear reader, what’s our final takeaway from this? If you thought academia was all about brilliant minds and groundbreaking research, well, it seems we’ve got a side of muck to deal with too. And it’s high time ETH Zurich stepped up, or they risk turning into that friend who’s really great at parties but can’t ever keep their house clean.
Let’s keep the conversation going! What do you think? Is ETH Zurich ready to take real action, or is this just another academic soap opera? Drop your thoughts below!
At ETH Zurich, a gathering of scientific and student associations took place on Friday in response to a series of troubling incidents involving discrimination, mobbing, and sexual assault within the institution. The attendees voiced their concern and belief that the management must implement more comprehensive measures to combat these issues. A petition advocating for these changes has been officially submitted.
On October 20, prominent organizations including Women in Natural Sciences, 500 Women Scientists Zürich, and Speak Up! in Academia came together to kick off a petition dubbed “We are shocked,” accompanied by a manifesto. This petition, which garnered an impressive 1,300 signatures, casts a critical spotlight on the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich, denouncing its inadequate response to the reported incidents of mobbing, sexual harassment, and discrimination.
More measures required
The petition also served as a rallying cry, inviting participants to join a demonstration early Friday evening at the school’s iconic Polyterrace. During this significant event, the petition was formally presented to two representatives from the management, met with applause and support from several dozen attendees.
As a female scientist, this directly concerns me, as such actions destroy careers and lives.
A participant
Among the pivotal demands articulated by the organizations are the establishment of a thorough and anonymous external reporting mechanism, the creation of a legal fund to assist victims with legal costs, and increased transparency regarding the statistics of complaints filed. Valentina Gasser from the Speak Up! in Academia organizing committee criticized the existing environment, describing it as one where inappropriate behavior is “accepted” and where many fear speaking out, thus perpetuating a culture that tolerates “sexual advances and racist behavior.”
Reaction from the ETHZ
Responses from the management have contested these serious accusations. Julia Dannath, the vice-president of personal development and leadership, acknowledged the frustration expressed by the concerned groups, noting that “each case is one too many.” However, she stressed that the institution “has significantly improved and revamped its processes” over the years. Dannath highlighted initiatives already in place, such as a dedicated service for reporting cases of sexual harassment, the establishment of help desks, the deployment of mediators, and the availability of an anonymous reporting form.
The polytechnic has reiterated that the objectives outlined in the demonstrators’ petition are in alignment with the management’s goals. In an official written statement, ETH Zurich assured stakeholders that it would thoroughly review all demands and recommendations aimed at enhancing the management of abuse cases.
**Interview with Julia Dannath, Vice-President of Personal Development and Leadership at ETH Zurich**
*Interviewer*: Julia, thank you for joining us today. ETH Zurich has recently faced significant backlash regarding allegations of discrimination and abuse. Can you provide insight into the university’s perspective on these concerns?
*Julia Dannath*: Thank you for having me. It’s important for us to acknowledge the frustrations expressed by students and faculty. We take these allegations very seriously and understand that each reported case of harassment or discrimination is one too many. Our goal is to create a safe and supportive environment for everyone at ETH Zurich.
*Interviewer*: The “We are shocked” petition gathered 1,300 signatures and highlighted shortcomings in how the university handles these issues. What steps has the administration taken in response?
*Julia Dannath*: While we’ve implemented some improvements, such as new reporting services and an anonymous complaint form, we recognize that change takes time, and we need to go further. We are actively reviewing our policies and practices to ensure they are effective and robust. It’s not just about introducing measures; we need to ensure they are adequately supportive and met with serious follow-up.
*Interviewer*: Many protesters feel that current offerings are merely patchwork solutions. What assurances can you give that the university’s efforts will lead to lasting change?
*Julia Dannath*: I understand that the perception is that we are not doing enough, and I genuinely appreciate that feedback. We are committed to ongoing dialogue with our community. We are exploring a wide range of options, including training for staff and expanding our resources, to create a climate where these issues are not just addressed but prevented.
*Interviewer*: The protest emphasized the need for anonymous reporting tools and legal funds for victims. Are those aspects being considered in the university’s plans?
*Julia Dannath*: We are reviewing the feasibility of these suggestions as part of our broader strategy. Enhancing support for victims and ensuring that individuals feel safe and can report incidents without fear of retaliation is crucial to our mission.
*Interviewer*: In light of these events, what message do you want to convey to the ETH Zurich community?
*Julia Dannath*: I want the ETH community to know that we hear them, and their voices matter. We share the objective of building a more inclusive and respectful environment. We’re committed to working collaboratively to improve our institution. Change is not easy, but with dialogue and partnership, I believe we can make ETH a safer place for everyone.
*Interviewer*: Thank you, Julia. It’s crucial that these issues are addressed thoughtfully and thoroughly. We appreciate your insights.
*Julia Dannath*: Thank you for having me. It’s important that we continue this conversation and take meaningful actions forward.
—
This interview emphasizes a commitment to addressing concerns while recognizing the challenges ahead. It aims to foster dialogue and convey sensitivity to the issues at play at ETH Zurich.
