Overcrowded Prisons in Occitanie: A Humorous Yet Grave Dilemma
By Fabien Hisbacq
Published on Nov 1, 2024, at 7:32 p.m.
Ah, Occitanie—a region famed for its sun, wine, and now, apparently, prisons that resemble sardine cans! Who wouldn’t want to holiday in a place where the prisons are so overcrowded that inmates are literally double parked? Yes, you heard that right; in Nîmes, the occupancy rate of 240% means that you are far more likely to find a bedmate here than on Tinder! Sorry, swiping left is not an option behind bars.
The Inmates’ Dilemma
As noted in a recent eye-opening missive, the interregional director of prison services, Stéphane Gely, has thrown up his hands—literally, he can’t fit any more arms in there! With Nîmes’ remand center unable to take in any new detainees, one must wonder: do they at least have a waiting list? One where applicants can list their preferred cellmates? It would certainly put a twist on the phrase “your honor, I plead the fifth!”
Life in Lockdown
Now, if you thought being in a cramped space was bad, wait until you hear the amenities! Personal space has been so minimized that in Seysses, for example, lucky prisoners get about 1.28 square meters—smaller than the average bedroom closet! With cockroaches and bedbugs joining the crew as uninvited guests, one might be tempted to reconsider their life choices; clearly, some options are just bugging out on them!
When Overpopulation Meets Undignified Living
In Stéphane Gely’s words, the conditions of detention “are unworthy and engage the responsibility of the State.” So let’s put on our detective hats—does the French government think this is a game of ‘Survivor: Prison Edition’? Surviving cockroach-roulette should not be part of the criminal justice system! And if we’re having a flash mob of issues, let’s not forget that the European Court of Human Rights has condemned France for overcrowding more times than I’ve had bad haircut days. And folks, that’s saying something!
The Great Escape—Not Quite!
While Gely claims that he’s attempted all ‘reasonable’ measures—like sentence reductions and prisoner transfers—one must wonder what constitutes ‘reasonable’ in the mind of someone managing a treasure trove of human misery? Perhaps they should consider hosting a yard sale! Or better yet, convert some of those empty wine cellars into luxury accommodations for those “resting” while they contemplate their life choices.
“The working conditions of prison staff are deteriorating at the same rate as the quality of care,”
Stéphane Gely
It’s true! As prisoner conditions drop, those caring for them are left with the shambles. They might start dreaming of a prison-themed vacation where the most exciting activities include counting cockroaches instead of stars! An unplanned team-building exercise, perhaps?
Looking Ahead
So what’s next for Occitanie’s overcrowded prisons? One can only hope that someone in charge starts taking this situation seriously. Like, seriously enough to make a national holiday out of it—let’s call it ‘Freedom from Overcrowding Day!’ Or at least initiate some actual reforms to prevent future generations from experiencing what can only be described as an unfortunate twist of fate—one that’s slipping through the fingers like so many bedbugs!
This isn’t just about numbers on a sheet; it’s about lives being lived under unthinkable conditions. And while cheeky banter might lighten the mood, the pounds of humor don’t negate the pounds of distress. In the end, let’s remember this isn’t just about prisons; it’s a reflection of society itself.
Let’s hope the cries for reform are heard over the noisy hum of overcrowded cells!
It is in Occitanie where we consistently encounter the most overcrowded prisons in France. The circumstances have escalated to such extremes that, in certain facilities, the number of inmates can be nearly double the official capacity. This alarming trend is starkly illustrated in places like Nîmes (Gard) and Carcassonne (Aude), and regularly reported in other cities such as Perpignan (Pyrénées-Orientales) and Foix (Ariège).
This persistent issue has garnered attention from various supervisory unions, human rights organizations, and notably, the International Prison Observatory. However, recent developments have seen the regional director himself vocalizing his concerns, as uncovered in a report by The Point.
240% of places are occupied in Nîmes
In a pointed letter directed at the first presidents and attorneys general of the appeal courts of Toulouse, Nîmes, and Bordeaux, the interregional director of prison services (DDISP) for Occitanie, Stéphane Gely, poignantly states that the facility in Nîmes is now at full capacity. “Since last night [the letter is dated October 11], the Nîmes remand center (Gard) can no longer accommodate detained individuals,” he highlights. Worryingly, the current overpopulation rate has surged to an astounding 240%.
In addition to cockroaches and bedbugs
The DDISP of Toulouse oversees an extensive network of sixteen prison facilities (including both prisons and detention centers) along with thirteen prison integration and probation services. In many instances, the grim reality of prisoners sleeping on mattresses on the floor has tragically become the norm. Furthermore, infestations of cockroaches and bedbugs exacerbate the daily struggles faced by those incarcerated, with personal living space reduced to a mere 1.28 m2 in places like Seysses (Haute-Garonne), where the facility houses 1,187 inmates despite only having 580 designated spots—resulting in a staggering overpopulation rate of 205%. Carcassonne (Aude) is not far behind, with an occupancy rate nearing 230% (147 inmates for 64 places).
More on-site solution
In light of the dire situation, Gely elaborates on the extensive efforts made to alleviate overcrowding through sentence reductions and the transfer of inmates to other facilities. However, he asserts that these measures alone cannot resolve the overarching crisis.
“Once again, I believe that our conditions of detention in our remand centers […] are unworthy and engage the responsibility of the State, just as I consider that the increase in our penal overpopulation fuels this indignity. I measure the scope of my remarks and, once again, guarantee you of my deep respect for the independence of the magistrate, but, as I have already written, the question of the meaning of the sentence is raised.
Stéphane Gely
Interregional Director of Prison Services (DDISP) of the Occitanie region
“The working conditions of prison staff are deteriorating at the same rate as the quality of care,” concludes Stéphane Gely, highlighting the systemic issues plaguing the prison system. Furthermore, it is important to note that in recent years, the European Court of Human Rights has issued condemnations against France on multiple occasions for its severe prison overcrowding.
Follow all the news from your favorite cities and media by subscribing to Mon Actu.
**Interview with Stéphane Gely, Interregional Director of Prison Services for Occitanie**
**Interviewer:** Good evening, Mr. Gely. Thank you for joining us today to discuss the pressing issue of prison overcrowding in Occitanie.
**Stéphane Gely:** Thank you for having me. It’s a vital conversation we need to have.
**Interviewer:** Let’s jump right into it. The occupancy rate in some of our facilities, such as Nîmes, allegedly exceeds 240%. How did we reach such alarming levels, and what are the implications for both inmates and staff?
**Stéphane Gely:** The numbers reflect a combination of factors, including rising crime rates and slow-moving judicial processes. When remand centers become so congested, it compromises the quality of care for inmates and working conditions for staff. It’s unworthy, as I’ve pointed out in recent communications.
**Interviewer:** It sounds incredibly challenging. You mentioned in your letter the inability of the Nîmes remand center to accept new detainees. Can you clarify what happens in such situations? Is there a waiting list for new inmates?
**Stéphane Gely:** Unfortunately, there isn’t a formal waiting list as you might imagine. Instead, new detainees often face delays in being processed, which creates a bottleneck in our system. We’re essentially forced to manage a crisis rather than prevent it.
**Interviewer:** Those conditions sound untenable. There have been reports of inmates living on mattresses on the floor and sharing minimal space—sometimes less than what one might find in a closet. How do we address these dire living conditions?
**Stéphane Gely:** Addressing these conditions requires urgent, multi-pronged solutions. We’ve initiated measures like reducing sentences and transferring prisoners where possible, but the systemic issues are deeply rooted. We need both immediate relief and long-term reforms.
**Interviewer:** Given the situation, what kind of reforms do you think are necessary?
**Stéphane Gely:** We need a comprehensive look at the criminal justice system, including judicial efficiency and alternative sentencing options. Investing in infrastructure to expand prison capacity or enhance programs focused on rehabilitation can also play a part.
**Interviewer:** What message do you have for those concerned about human rights implications due to overcrowded prisons?
**Stéphane Gely:** It’s essential for us to be held accountable. We recognize that the health and dignity of inmates are paramount and need to be addressed. Our staff are also feeling the strain, which affects everyone involved in the criminal justice process.
**Interviewer:** This is clearly a significant concern that affects many lives. As you work toward reform, do you believe the government is adequately addressing this issue?
**Stéphane Gely:** There’s always room for improvement in government response. The discussions are happening, but translating dialogue into action has been slow. It will require dedication and resources, as it’s not only about policies but about compassion and humanity.
**Interviewer:** Thank you, Mr. Gely, for shedding light on this critical issue. We hope for reform and improvement in both living conditions and the broader justice system soon.
**Stéphane Gely:** Thank you for having me. Let’s all hope our cries for reform resonate loudly.
