Digging up History: The Whimsical Search for Muriel McKay
Ah, the British countryside! Rolling hills, tranquil farms, and the occasional body that just refuses to be found. Yes, folks, we’re diving into the peculiar case of Muriel McKay — the woman who went missing in 1969 and has, quite frankly, made her absence the talk of the town for way too long.
The Great Kidnapping Misunderstanding
Picture it: Stocking Farm, Hertfordshire, where our unfortunate heroine Muriel was mistaken for none other than the wife of press mogul Rupert Murdoch. Imagine the kidnappers doing their homework while sipping tea, only to get it so wrong that they’re now looking for a body instead of cash. It’s almost farcical, but alas, it’s also quite tragic.
Muriel, living her life, suddenly found herself amidst a game of mistaken identities sparked by a Rolls Royce. Yes, that’s right, a fancy car turned out to be the catalyst for her kidnapping! Forget about looking for buried treasure; these guys were after the kind of money that would make Scrooge McDuck green with envy: a cool million! Sadly, they ended up with the world’s worst case of buyer’s remorse instead.
Let’s Try This Again!
Fast forward to 2024, and we’re still talking about this case! The Metropolitan Police threw money at the problem (to the tune of £160,000, mind you) to dig around for Muriel but found…nothing. Dyer family, you might want to throw in a lottery ticket if you’re hoping the “dig and pray” technique works out this time around.
Can We Buy a Farm?
Mark Dyer, Muriel’s grandson, is now looking to buy the farm and…wait for it…dig up the garden like it’s an episode of Cash in the Attic! You’ve got to admire the determination though. He dubbed the place “the most evil on earth.” I’d be inclined to agree, but have you seen my ex’s cookbook collection?
A Whole Lot of Digging and a Bad Guy on Standby
Meanwhile, the surviving kidnapper, Nizamodeen Hosein, living in sunny Trinidad, is willing to help pinpoint where they may have buried Muriel. What a pal! But the authorities have said, “nope, not in our backyard.” Seems a bit harsh, doesn’t it? If a guy admits he buried a body, at least let him lend a shovel! Or at least a map. GPS doesn’t hurt either.
The Family Deserves Closure, Not a Continuously Open Case
At some point, you’ve got to ask: at what cost will the Dyer family achieve closure? Ian McKay, Muriel’s son, suggested buying up the farm might provide that needed emotional release. Listen, Ian, if I owned a farm that involved potential forensic excavations every other year, I’d be charging admission at the gate!
The Final Curtain?
The case has been cold for a long time, and all this digging — quite literally — might serve as a way to not only seek closure but turn Muriel’s tragic story into a bizarrely entertaining evening for future dinner parties. “Did you hear about the time my grandmother was mistaken for Rupert Murdoch’s wife?” You can’t make this stuff up!
So let’s keep our fingers crossed for the Dyer family. May their determination to find Muriel end in a way that gives a little peace to their long-standing drama. Because, honestly, after 55 years, who doesn’t deserve that?
Remember, in the realm of true crime, sometimes the bizarre twists can feel like one of those hours-long sitcoms that just keeps plucking at the heartstrings, with the potential for a punchline we’re all ready to hear.
image copyrightMark Dyer
image captionMuriel McKay’s body has not been found since her disappearance and murder on December 29, 1969.Item information
- Author, Editor
- Author’s title, BBC News World
-
2 hours
The family of a woman who was kidnapped and murdered on a farm in England wants to buy the property and dig for her body.
After her death in 1969 at Stocking Farm (formerly Rooks Farm), Hertfordshire, Muriel McKay was never found.
She was kidnapped because she was thought to be someone else; none other than the then wife of press magnate Rupert Murdoch.
Mrs. McKay was the wife of Alick McKay, who at the time worked alongside the powerful businessman.
According to BBC reporter Louise Parry, “Murdoch had lent the McKays (his car) Rolls Royce, which led to the mistaken identity case.”
“Her kidnappers mistook her for Murdoch’s then-wife Anna in a failed attempt to extort her for one million pounds ($1.3 million).”
In July 2024, 55 years later, the Metropolitan Police returned to the scene and spent £160,000, equivalent to around $200,000, on an eight-day search. But, as with a 2022 excavation, it was unsuccessful.
Now Mrs McKay’s grandson, Mark Dyer, said he was prepared to pay more than a million pounds to buy the property, which he called “the most evil place on earth”, and continue the tireless search. from his grandmother.
BBC reporters Lewis Adams and Justin Dealey explain that Dyer admitted that this would be “something difficult to do” emotionally, but that at the same time it could be necessary to find at least some closure to the family’s grieving process.
The July excavations took place after the last surviving murdererNizamodeen Hosein, who now lives in Trinidad, gave information about the place where Mrs. McKay was supposedly buried.
Although Hosein was willing to travel to help with the search process for the body, authorities did not allow him to return to the United Kingdom, which the McKay family considered an obstacle to their efforts.
image copyrightSteve Hubbard/BBC
Caption, Three excavations have been carried out at Stocking Farm – which belonged to one of the kidnappers – since the murder, but none have been successful.
Ian McKay, Mrs McKay’s son, told the BBC: “This all depends on whether the owner wants to sell.”
“The purchase of Rook’s Farm would be an emotional response to allow the family to properly search and hopefully find closure.”
Caption: Nizamodeen Hosein, who murdered Mrs McKay, has said he is willing to travel to England to help with any search.
Dyer said that if his family bought the farm in the future, they would own it only on a “transitional” basis: they would buy it, hire specialists to conduct a private search and then they would sell ithe explained.
Earlier this year, Mr Dyer flew to Trinidad with Ms McKay’s daughter Dianne, and Nizamodeen showed them on a map where he believed the body was buried, reigniting their search.
The killer’s lawyer, Matthew Gayle, told the BBC that Nizamodeen was still willing to travel to England to help with an eventual excavation.
In March 2024, Hosein stated that he was willing to travel to Hertfordshire and pinpoint the location where she was buried.
“I am willing to give a place of rest to the family, peace of mind, as you would say”said.
The details of the case
On December 29, 1969, Mrs. McKay was returning home when she was intercepted by her kidnappers and put into a car.
At the time, Muriel was 55 years old, the mother of three adult children and four grandchildren.
Years later, when talking with Nizamodeen, her daughter Dianne learned more details about that moment.
“For years I had pondered the question of ‘how did my mother let those men, who seemed quite tough, into the house?’ “He told me very simply: she was out.”he stated in July in conversation with the BBC.
“He saw them coming. He ran in and grabbed the phone, but he didn’t lock it. That’s how they got in.”
image copyrightPA
Caption: Muriel McKan was 55 years old at the time of her kidnapping.
After the kidnapping, both Nizamodeen and his brother made repeated calls to the McKay family asking for sums of money and threatening to kill Muriel.
Then her grandson, Mark Dyer, said an anonymous call was made from a pub phone box, claiming she was dead.
Despite extensive searches by police at Rooks Farm in 1970, Mrs McKay’s body was not found.
Those responsible
Arthur Hosein, owner of Rooks Farm, and his younger brother, Nizamodeen Hosein, were arrested on February 7, 1970.
In one of the first murder trials in the UK without a body yet being discovered, both were sentenced to life imprisonment for the kidnapping and murder of Muriel McKay.
Arthur died in prison, but Nizamodeen was deported to his native Trinidad after serving his sentence.
Over the years, the case went cold and the family tried to move on with their lives.
But in 2021, Sky aired a documentary titled The Wimbledon Kidnappingwhich included a recent interview with Hosein.
Dyer said that “opened the door” to a new investigation. “I saw a man who wanted to confess,” he said on that occasion.
Together with her mother, Dianne, she hired a lawyer in Trinidad to establish contact with Hosein. Before long, they spoke on a video call and he said that “Nizam revealed everything.”
The family said Hosein He admitted having kidnapped Mrs. McKay, but told them that she died of a heart attack after seeing her family make an appeal about the case on television.
Hosein revealed that after Mrs. McKay’s sudden death, the brothers hid her body under a large pile of manure behind the barn.
Thus, he pointed out the place on a map of Rooks Farm, where the search for the remains of the Australian woman was reactivated – still without success.
Subscribe here to our new newsletter to receive a selection of our best content of the week every Friday.
And remember that you can receive notifications in our app. Download the latest version and activate them.
