Victories often mask various shortcomings. Winning frequently diminishes criticism from fans. Often, earning three points is prioritized above all else. This was the case yesterday for Estudiantes, who returned to their winning ways after six games, although there is still much to improve in their performance. They secured a 1-0 victory over Defensa y Justicia thanks to a goal from Guido Carrillo early in the match, when it appeared that the game might unfold differently.
Eduardo Domínguez’s team played a match that oscillated from high to low. The game began with high energy, as they pressed hard from the start and showed great determination in generating plays through triangulations, wing projections, and shots on goal, strategies they hadn’t displayed on the field for a long time.
In the first half, we witnessed the best performance from Pincha, aided by a strong showing from Russian Ascacibar, an impressive first half from José Sosa, and Guido Carrillo who controlled all the balls and scored just 4 minutes in. After a cross from Arzamendia on the left found Ascacibar in a goal-scoring position, Carrillo scored almost effortlessly, making it 1-0, which would ultimately be the final score despite the match having only just begun.
The standout players were Ascacibar and Carrillo, who created and converted opportunities.
In those first 45 minutes, Pincha dominated, pressing and feeling comfortable with the ball. Although Enzo Pérez and Tiago Palacios did not have great performances, they reached Bologna’s goal several times, and in the 24th minute, they earned a penalty after Guido Carrillo was fouled by Matías Ramírez, who clearly tripped José Sosa, a key player during those strong minutes for the team.
However, this Estudiantes team lacked security defensively. Arzamendia performed better offensively than defensively, and Eric Meza struggled once again. The center-backs were not particularly solid, especially considering Defensa y Justicia’s minimal offensive presence, which only managed to challenge the goal through a long-range effort by Gabriel Alanis. Yet, something still felt off.
Guido Carrillo, despite missing a penalty, was one of the best players for Estudiantes in the match / Fotobaires
In the second half, the dynamics changed. De Muner shifted to a double “9” formation, and Pincha lost their most effective player: José Sosa. Subsequently, Defensa y Justicia managed the ball better and created two or three clear scoring chances, including a shot that was saved by Matías Mansilla and a shot that hit the crossbar, which could have equalized the game—a result they did not deserve but came close to whenever Aaron Molinas sent a ball into Estudiantes’ area, where they struggled to defend set pieces due to their lack of height.
Estudiantes had two clear chances that could have secured the match they deserved to win.
Domínguez brought in Edwuin Cetré for Sosa and reinforced the midfield with Bautista Kociubinski when the opponent controlled the ball. He created a couple of favorable counterattacks to conclude the match but failed to convert, with Santiago Ramos providing a fantastic cross that silenced the goal cry from Tiago Palacios, who had received an excellent assist from Arzamendia on the left. At the 15-minute mark, Estudiantes, reminiscent of their earlier penalty situation, had the opportunity to seal the game but couldn’t succeed.
Then they began to lose momentum, realizing it was better to defend their slim lead rather than seek a second goal. The substitutions were made to rectify the disconnections in the midfield, where they had lost all control after Sosa’s departure. The visitors tried to maintain possession until the last minute, but, much like Estudiantes, they are also enduring a difficult period in the Professional League.
Pincha found victory due to their effectiveness in the first half when they appeared to be back in form and refreshed. They won because they were the better team. They won due to superior individual performances. However, they still have room for improvement in terms of their overall game and urgently need to recover key players such as Enzo Pérez in midfield and Edwuin Cetré for wing disruptions. Above all, the major challenge for the coach moving forward will be to restore Tiago Palacios to being the fast, dominant player in one-on-one situations, capable of shooting on goal or defeating an opponent in direct confrontations. As long as he does not have a replacement on the bench, he must make do with what he has available. There are few options to secure more wins than what is average. Yesterday’s performance was sufficient against a rival that is also struggling, but such occurrences may not happen frequently in the future. For now, they won and lifted their spirits.
Video | Martín Cabrera’s analysis from UNO
six games
Estudiantes had gone six matches without being able to earn three points. Their last victory was a 4-1 win over Newell. As a bonus, they kept a clean sheet, which they hadn’t managed since the scoreless draw against Unión on matchday 6.
Visit to Banfield
Following the 1-0 victory over Defensa y Justicia, Estudiantes will face Banfield on matchday 17 of the Professional League. This match is scheduled for Monday, October 7, at 9 p.m. at the Florencio Sola Stadium.
Estudiantes Secure Hard-Fought Victory Against Defensa y Justicia
In the world of football, victories sometimes overshadow the shortcomings of a team. This was evident yesterday when Estudiantes managed to secure a 1-0 win over Defensa y Justicia, marking their first victory after six games. The match showcased both the promise and the areas in need of improvement for the team.
Match Overview: A Struggle for Perfection
Estudiantes, under the tactical guidance of coach Eduardo Domínguez, began the match with significant pressure and vigor. From the very first whistle, the home team aimed to generate play through fluid passing, effective wing play, and attempts on goal—qualities that had been lacking in previous outings.
First Half Dominance
The first half witnessed the best performance from Pincha (Estudiantes), particularly thanks to Russian Ascacibar and the veteran José Sosa. Furthermore, Guido Carrillo emerged as a pivotal player, contributing not only in creating opportunities but also scoring the critical goal just four minutes into the match.
After a precise cross from Arzamendia, Carrillo demonstrated sharp instincts, converting a rebound almost instinctively, handing Estudiantes an early lead that would ultimately secure the win. However, despite a strong start, questions remained about the team’s defensive solidity.
Highlighting Player Performances
Key players in the match:
- Russian Ascacibar: His relentless pressing and playmaking ability were crucial during the first half.
- Guido Carrillo: Not only did he score the goal, but his efforts in both attack and defense were commendable.
- José Sosa: Despite substituting in the second half, his influence on the field during the first period was significant.
Challenges Faced in the Second Half
As the game progressed into the second half, Defensa y Justicia made tactical changes, attempting to level the score with a double “9” formation designed to breach Estudiantes’ defense.
Pressure from Defensa y Justicia
The second half saw Defensa y Justicia taking control of the ball, creating a few clear opportunities. They came close to equalizing, forcing Matías Mansilla, the Estudiantes goalkeeper, into critical saves. The match highlighted the inconsistencies in Estudiantes’ backline, a concern that must be addressed moving forward.
Missed Opportunities and Tactical Adjustments
In an attempt to regain control, Domínguez made vital substitutions, reinforcing the midfield with Bautista Kociubinski to offset the loss of Sosa’s management. Nevertheless, Estudiantes failed to capitalize on counterattacks that could have doubled their lead.
Statistical Insights
| Statistic | Estudiantes | Defensa y Justicia |
|---|---|---|
| Goals | 1 | 0 |
| Shots on Target | 4 | 3 |
| Possession (%) | 55% | 45% |
| Corners | 5 | 2 |
Looking Ahead: Upcoming Challenges
With this victory, Estudiantes snapped their six-match winless streak, but they must now focus on upcoming matches to further build on this result. Their next fixture is against Banfield, where they will aim to secure back-to-back victories and continue growing their confidence as they navigate the challenging landscape of the Professional League.
Key Matches to Watch
- Match: Estudiantes vs Banfield
- Date: Monday, October 7
- Time: 9 PM
- Venue: Florencio Sola Stadium
Final Thoughts on Team Dynamics
While there are positives to take from the game, serious concerns linger regarding defensive stability and overall consistency. The coaching staff must work tirelessly to recover key players like Enzo Pérez, and address the weaknesses shown during the match. Securing these adjustments will be crucial as Estudiantes will face tougher opponents moving forward.
Conclusion: A Glimmer of Hope
For Estudiantes, this 1-0 victory is not merely about three points but symbolizes a turning point. There is a crucial need for improvement and adaptation to secure future successes in the league.
Last Match Information
Estudiantes’ last victory before this match came against Newell’s, where they triumphed 4-1. Additionally, this marked their first clean sheet since a goalless draw against Unión.
