Erik Menéndez lashes out at Ryan Murphy in Netflix series

Erik Menéndez has spoken out about the new Netflix series focusing on his life. On September 20, he released a statement on his brother Lyle‘s Facebook page, criticizing the series Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menéndez Story, directed by Ryan Murphy.

Erik, 53, expressed his outrage regarding how the show depicts him and his brother Lyle, 56. Both brothers have claimed they experienced abuse from their parents and killed them in self-defense; however, Erik argues that the show misrepresents this truth.

“I thought we had moved beyond the lies and harmful characterizations of Lyle,” he wrote. “In the series, they create a caricature of him based on terrible and obvious falsehoods… I cannot believe they did this unintentionally.”

Related: Ex-Menudo Roy Roselló discusses the abuse he endured as a teenager at the hands of José Menéndez.

Erik also conveyed his disappointment regarding the revival of outdated notions that downplay male sexual abuse. He stated that Netflix’s portrayal “takes us back to a time when the prosecution built a narrative based on the belief that men do not experience sexual abuse in the same manner as women.”

The Menendez brothers at their home in Beverly Hills, in 1989.

Erik accused Murphy, 58, of crafting a “horrible narrative” laden with “repugnant characterizations and slander.” He further questioned, “Isn’t the truth sufficient? Is it really that challenging to accept the reality of childhood trauma?”

If you don’t want to miss anything, subscribe for free here to the People en Español newsletter to stay updated on everything your favorite celebrities are doing, the most shocking news, and the latest in fashion and beauty.

Erik concluded his message by expressing gratitude to those who have shown their support.

The series narrates the story of the murder of Erik and Lyle’s parents, Jose and Kitty Menendez, in August 1989, and the brothers’ subsequent trial in the 1990s. Ultimately, the Menendez brothers were sentenced to life imprisonment for two counts of first-degree murder. They are currently serving their sentences at the Richard J. Donovan Correctional Institution in San Diego.

The actors Nicholas Alexander Chavez and Cooper Koch portray the Menendez brothers, while Javier Bardem and Chloë Sevigny represent their parents. The series is now available on Netflix.

The protagonists of the Netflix series, Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story.

Erik Menéndez Breaks Silence on Netflix’s ‘Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menéndez Story’

On September 20, 2023, Erik Menéndez took to social media to voice his discontent with the new Netflix series Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menéndez Story, directed by Ryan Murphy. Posted on his brother Lyle‘s Facebook page, Erik criticized the show for its portrayal of their lives and the events surrounding the tragic murders of their parents.

Allegations of Inaccuracies

At the age of 53, Erik expressed anger regarding the series’ depiction of him and his brother, Lyle, aged 56. The Menendez brothers have long claimed that they were victims of parental abuse and that the murders were committed in self-defense. However, Erik asserts that the Netflix adaptation distorts this crucial aspect of their lives.

Character Distortion and Misrepresentation

Erik stated, “I thought we had moved past the lies and destructive characterizations of Lyle.” He criticized the show for creating a caricature of his brother based on what he termed “horrible and blatant lies.” This narrative, he believes, perpetuates damaging stereotypes and misunderstandings about their experiences. Erik added, “I can’t believe they did it by mistake.”

Reviving Old Myths About Male Sexual Abuse

Furthermore, Erik expressed concern that the series reintroduces harmful ideas minimizing the impact of sexual abuse on men. He contended that Netflix’s portrayal “takes us back to a time when the prosecution built a narrative based on the belief that men do not suffer sexual abuse in the same way as women.” This assertion underlines the ongoing societal challenges regarding gender perceptions of victimhood.

Critique of Ryan Murphy’s Narrative Choices

Erik placed significant blame on director Ryan Murphy, accusing him of crafting a “horrible narrative” filled with “vile characterizations and slander.” The emotional weight of Erik’s words raises the question, “Isn’t the truth enough? Is it so hard to accept the reality of childhood trauma?” Such sentiments reflect a deeper frustration with how media representations can overshadow individual truth.

The Broader Impact of Misrepresentation

The impact of misrepresentation in media extends far beyond the Menendez brothers. It raises important questions about how stories are told and whose narratives are prioritized. Erik concluded his message by thanking his supporters for their ongoing encouragement during this trying time.

Background of the Menendez Case

The series explores the infamous case of the murder of Erik and Lyle’s parents, Jose and Kitty Menendez, which occurred in August 1989. The trial garnered massive media attention in the 1990s as the brothers were ultimately convicted of two counts of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without parole, where they currently remain at the Richard J. Donovan Correctional Institution in San Diego.

Cast of the Series

The new series features actors Nicholas Alexander Chavez and Cooper Koch as the Menendez brothers, with Javier Bardem and Chloë Sevigny portraying their parents. As of now, the series is available for streaming on Netflix, attracting attention not just for its dramatic retelling but also for the controversy surrounding its accuracy and portrayal of sensitive themes.

Audience Reactions and Cultural Commentary

User Reaction	Commentary
Sympathy for Erik and Lyle	Many viewers express empathy for the brothers, understanding their past trauma and questioning the ethics of dramatization.
Critiques of Media Representation	Several commentators highlight the need for responsible storytelling, emphasizing the importance of accuracy when dealing with sensitive subjects like abuse.
Debate on Sexual Abuse Narratives	Audiences engage in discussions regarding the complexities of male sexual abuse, amplifying Erik’s concerns about societal perceptions.

Insights and Reflections

The backlash from Erik Menéndez demonstrates the profound impact of public narratives on personal experiences. The critique of Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menéndez Story highlights a critical intersection of media, trauma, and justice. The conversation triggered by Erik’s statements serves as a reminder that real-life tragedies are not merely stories for entertainment but deeply personal histories that shape the lives of those involved.

Final Thoughts from Erik Menéndez

As the public continues to consume the dramatized narrative, Erik remains steadfast in advocating for a more accurate and respectful interpretation of his and Lyle’s experiences. Criticism of the series has opened up a space for further dialogue about the implications of storytelling in true crime narratives and the importance of acknowledging the complexities of human lives.